Duffy v Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2013 0102

MATHEW DUFFY

Applicant

v

SALVATION ARMY (VICTORIA) PROPERTY TRUST

Respondent

---

JUDGES HANSEN and TATE JJA and BEACH AJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING On the papers
DATE OF JUDGMENT 20 September 2013
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2013] VSCA 253
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM Duffy v Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust [2013] VCC 683 (Judge K L Bourke)

---

NEGLIGENCE – Duty of care – Breach of duty – Common law employee – Safe system of work – Access to unloading area not restricted – Rush to catch heavy mirror falling from truck while being unloaded – Shoulder injury – Judge held incident could not have happened in manner alleged – Core features of incident not contradicted – Respondent chose not to call witnesses – Read v Nerey Nominees Pty Ltd (1979) VR 47, Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, McLean v Tedman (1984) 155 CLR 306, applied – Appeal allowed.

---

Appearances: Counsel Solicitors
No Oral hearing.  By consent the matter was decided having regard to the written materials filed by the parties.

HANSEN JA

TATE JA
BEACH AJA:

  1. This is an application for an extension of time to lodge a Notice of Appeal against orders made in the County Court on 17 June 2013, by which the judge dismissed the claims of the applicant (‘Duffy’) against the respondent (the ‘Salvation Army’) for negligence and for breach of the duty owed by an occupier of premises under s 14B(3) of the Wrongs Act.[1]  The Salvation Army consents to the grant of an extension of time.  Both parties have also consented to have the substantive appeal heard on the papers, should the extension of time be granted.

    [1]See Duffy v Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust [2013] VCC 683 (‘Reasons’). Her Honour also dismissed a claim for breach of regulations made under the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004.

  1. For the reasons that follow, we will grant the application for an extension of time to appeal.  We will also allow the appeal upholding Duffy’s claim that the Salvation Army breached the duty of care it owed to him.  We will remit the matter to the County Court solely on the issue of damages, to be heard by a different judge.

The incident with the falling mirror

  1. Duffy is a disability support pensioner, and a shearer by occupation, although he had been in receipt of benefits from Centrelink because of the sporadic nature of shearing work.  He alleged that he received an injury to his left shoulder while working at premises occupied by the Salvation Army at 63 Macleod Street, Bairnsdale (‘the premises’) as part of the Work for the Dole Program (‘the program’) initiated by the Commonwealth of Australia and implemented through the Department of Workplace Relations and Centrelink.  The Salvation Army accept that Duffy was a ‘worker’ pursuant to the program and had been directed to work at the premises, primarily compressing clothing into wool…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duffy v Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] VSCA 253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Duffy v Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust, the plaintiff, a labourer employed by a subcontractor, sought compensation for a shoulder injury sustained while working at the defendant’s premises. The plaintiff alleged that the injury occurred when a heavy mirror fell from a truck as it was being unloaded, and he rushed to catch it, causing him to twist his shoulder. The case was heard in the Court of Appeal of Victoria. The primary judge dismissed the plaintiff's claim, finding that the incident could not have happened in the manner alleged and that the plaintiff’s account was not supported by the core features of the incident.

The legal issues before the court centred on whether the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and, if so, whether that duty was breached. The plaintiff argued that the defendant failed to provide a safe system of work by not restricting access to the unloading area and allowing the plaintiff to be in a position where he could be injured while attempting to catch the falling mirror. The defendant contended that the plaintiff’s account was not credible and that the incident could not have occurred as described.

The court examined the evidence and found that the plaintiff's account was not contradicted in its core features. The court applied the principles from Read v Nerey Nominees Pty Ltd, Jones v Dunkel, and McLean v Tedman, concluding that the defendant did owe a duty of care to the plaintiff and that there was a breach of that duty. The court held that the plaintiff's account of the incident was not implausible and that the defendant had failed to provide adequate safety measures. The appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the trial judge for assessment of damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Duffy v Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust involves an incident that occurred while a mirror was being unloaded from a truck at the Salvation Army's property. The plaintiff, Mr. Duffy, who was an employee of a contractor engaged to unload goods from the truck, attempted to catch a heavy mirror that was falling from the truck. In doing so, he rushed to intercept the mirror, which resulted in a shoulder injury. Mr. Duffy subsequently brought an action against the Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust, claiming that the Trust breached their duty of care by not implementing a safe system of work and by not restricting access to the unloading area. The Trust denied the allegations, arguing that the incident could not have occurred in the manner described by Mr. Duffy. The judge found in favour of the Trust, concluding that the core features of the incident as described by Mr. Duffy were not contradicted and that the Trust had not breached any duty of care.

This case came before the court following a trial in the County Court of Victoria. Mr. Duffy filed a statement of claim against the Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust, alleging negligence and breach of duty of care. The Trust filed a defence denying the allegations and asserting that the incident could not have happened as described. The matter proceeded to a trial before a judge who heard evidence from Mr. Duffy and other witnesses. After considering the evidence, the judge found in favour of the Trust and dismissed Mr. Duffy's claim. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Mr. Duffy appealed to the Court of Appeal, which heard the appeal and subsequently allowed it, ordering a new trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust breached their duty of care by not implementing a safe system of work and by not restricting access to the unloading area.
2. Whether the judge's findings on the core features of the incident and the lack of contradiction in Mr. Duffy's account were correct.
3. Whether the Trust's decision not to call witnesses affected the outcome of the case.

Held
1. The court held that the Salvation Army (Victoria) Property Trust breached their duty of care by not implementing a safe system of work and by not restricting access to the unloading area. The breach of duty caused the plaintiff's shoulder injury.
2. The court found that the judge's determination on the core features of the incident and the absence of contradiction in Mr. Duffy's account were correct. The incident could not have happened as alleged by the plaintiff.
3. The Trust's decision not to call witnesses did not affect the outcome of the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the breach of duty of care by the Trust, focusing on their failure to implement a safe system of work and restrict access to the unloading area. The court emphasised that a safe system of work includes not only the physical environment but also the procedures and practices in place. The Trust failed to ensure that the unloading area was properly secured, which led to the plaintiff rushing to catch the heavy mirror falling from the truck and sustaining a shoulder injury. The court held that the Trust's failure to establish a safe system of work and restrict access to the unloading area amounted to a breach of duty of care.

Regarding the judge's findings on the core features of the incident and the lack of contradiction in Mr. Duffy's account, the court agreed with the judge's assessment. The court found that the incident could not have happened in the manner alleged by the plaintiff and that there was no credible evidence to contradict Mr. Duffy's account of the events. The court relied on the principles established in Read v Nerey Nominees Pty Ltd and Jones v Dunkel to support its decision. The court also noted that the Trust chose not to call witnesses, which did not affect the outcome of the case.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that employers have a duty of care to implement a safe system of work and restrict access to hazardous areas. Failure to do so can result in liability for injuries sustained by employees. Additionally, the court's findings on the core features of the incident and the absence of contradiction in the plaintiff's account were upheld, reinforcing the importance of credible evidence in establishing negligence claims. The decision in this case follows the authorities cited and does not depart from any established legal principles.