Dubbin v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

Dubbin v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2017] QIRC 067

PARTIES:  

Dubbin, Krestopher
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2016/207

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

6 July 2017

HEARING DATE:

23 June 2017

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

MEMBER:

Deputy President Bloomfield

ORDERS:

1.      The decision of the Regulator dated
4 October 2016 is confirmed. 

2.      Mr Dubbin's appeal against that decision is dismissed. 

3.      Mr Dubbin is to pay the Regulator's costs of, and incidental to, the Appeal, with recourse to the Commission as presently constituted if the parties cannot agree on the costs involved.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION – APPEAL AGAINST DECISION – claim for industrial deafness – whether appellant satisfies requirements at s 125(2) of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 – rules of statutory interpretation – s 125(2) strictly limits when an application for industrial deafness must be made – one of three requirements to be satisfied before a claim can be accepted – appellant does not meet any of the three requirements – appeal refused – costs awarded.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 11, s 113, s 125.
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cwth), schedule 1, part 2-5.
Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 14A, s 14B.

The Metropolitan Gas Co v The Federated Gas Employees' Industrial Union [1924] 35 CLR 449.
Grey v Pearson (1857) 6 HLC 61.
Commonwealth v Baume (1905) 2 CLR 405.
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355.
Andrew v The Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland (1993) 33 WCR 346.
Blow v Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland (1985) 30 WCR 66.

APPEARANCES:

Mr A. B. Anderson, town agent, for Southside Legal for the Appellant.

Mr P. B. O'Neill, Counsel directly instructed by the Workers' Compensation Regulator, with
Ms S. Young.

Decision

  1. On 23 June 2017 I made a short announcement, at the conclusion of proceedings on that day, that because Mr Krestopher Dubbin did not meet any of the criteria specified in section 125(2) of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (the Act) his Appeal against an earlier decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator, which confirmed a decision by WorkCover Queensland (WorkCover) to reject his Application for compensation for industrial deafness, had to be refused.

  2. In making such announcement I indicated that I fully agreed with the written and oral submissions presented by Mr P. B. O'Neill, Counsel for the Regulator, and would issue a fully detailed decision in the near future which set out the full reasons for my decision to refuse Mr Dubbin's Appeal.

  3. What follows are my reasons for refusing Mr Dubbin's Appeal.

    Agreed facts

  4. Helpfully, the parties submitted an agreed statement of facts which is summarised below:

    ·the Appellant was employed as a Screen Printer/Plate Maker in the printing industry in Sydney by Mason Duplex between 1970 and 1996;

    ·he was then employed as a Compositor/Plate Maker by Bega District News in Bega (NSW)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dubbin v Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QIRC 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Dubbin v Workers' Compensation Regulator, the court was required to determine whether the appellant, Mr Dubbin, was entitled to workers' compensation for industrial deafness under the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003. The appellant had lodged a claim for compensation with WorkCover on 22 October 2015 for an injury identified as industrial deafness. The central legal issue was whether Mr Dubbin satisfied the requirements of section 125(2) of the Act, which strictly limits when an application for industrial deafness must be made. The court examined the provisions of the Act and found that Mr Dubbin did not meet any of the three requirements set out in section 125(2).

The court's reasoning was based on a strict interpretation of the statutory provisions. Section 125(2) of the Act stipulates that an application for compensation for industrial deafness must be made either while the claimant is a worker under the Act, if the claimant would ordinarily be a worker but is temporarily unemployed, or within 12 months after the claimant's formal retirement from employment. The court found that Mr Dubbin did not satisfy the requirement of being a worker under the Act at the time of lodging his application. Furthermore, the court determined that even if Mr Dubbin met the employment period requirement in section 125(3), it would not entitle him to compensation unless he also met one of the three requirements in section 125(2), which he did not.

The court confirmed the decision of the Regulator dated 4 October 2016, dismissed Mr Dubbin's appeal, and ordered that Mr Dubbin pay the Regulator's costs of, and incidental to, the appeal, with recourse to the Commission if the parties could not agree on the costs involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Regulator dated

4 October 2016 is confirmed.

2. Mr Dubbin's appeal against that decision is dismissed.

3. Mr Dubbin is to pay the Regulator's costs of, and incidental to, the Appeal, with recourse to the Commission as presently constituted if the parties cannot agree on the costs involved.

Background

Background to the litigation

What follows are my reasons for refusing Mr Dubbin's Appeal.Agreed facts Helpfully, the parties submitted an agreed statement of facts which is summarised below:·the Appellant was employed as a Screen Printer/Plate Maker in the printing industry in Sydney by Mason Duplex between 1970 and 1996;·he was then employed as a Compositor/Plate Maker by Bega District News in Bega (NSW) from 1996 to June 1999;·employed by Phoenix Graphics at Ashmore (Queensland) from 4 February 2004 to 4 September 2009 as an ink and paint mixer/printer;·employed as a cleaner by Swift & Shift Cleaning Services, Molendinar (Queensland) from 21 January 2010 to 6 October 2010;·employed as an Assistant-in-Nursing at the Seabreeze Nursing Home in Pottsville (NSW) from 17 April 2011 to 12 November 2011; ·employed as an Assistant-in-Nursing at the Heritage Lodge Aged Care facility in Murwillumbah (NSW) from 4 January 2012 until the present time;·the appellant lodged an application for compensation with WorkCover on 22 October 2015 for an injury identified as industrial deafness;·at the time of lodging his application for workers' compensation with WorkCover the Appellant was not employed in Queensland but is an employee (in NSW) for the purposes of assessment for PAYG withholding tax under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cwth);·in a statement provided to WorkCover dated 28 October 2015 the Appellant stated he was exposed to a noisy environment whilst employed at Phoenix Graphics with the noise coming from a large compressor, guillotine and printing presses. Legislation Section 125 of the Act relevantly provides:"125 Entitlements for industrial deafness(1)The worker is entitled to compensation for the industrial deafness under part 10 and sections 211(1)(a) and 219(1) and not under any other provision.(2)The application for compensation for industrial deafness must be made– (a) while the claimant is a worker under this Act; or(b) if the claimant would ordinarily be a worker under this Act but is temporarily unemployed; or(c) within 12 months after the claimant's formal retirement from employment.(3)The worker is entitled to compensation for industrial deafness that is attributable to the worker's employment in the State as a worker if the worker–(a) has been employed in an industry in the State for a period of, or for periods totaling, at least 5 years; and(b) the employment was at a location, or at locations, where the noise level was a significant contributing factor to the industrial deafness.…". Section 11 of the Act relevantly provides: "11 Who is a worker(1)A worker is a person who–(a) works under a contract; and(b) in relation to the work, is an employee for the purposes of assessment for PAYG withholding under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cwth), schedule 1, part 2-5.". Section 113 of the Act relevantly provides: "113 Employment must be connected with State(1)Compensation under this Act is only payable to employment that is connected with this State. (2)The fact that a worker is outside this State when the injury is sustained does not prevent compensation being payable under this Act in relation to employment that is connected with this State.…".

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In an earlier decision in Blow v Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland[6], Evans I.M. dismissed Mr Blow's Appeal against the rejection of his Application for workers' compensation for industrial deafness in circumstances where he took a voluntary redundancy in November 1983 and filed his Application for workers' compensation on 5 January 1984. In doing so, the Industrial Magistrate found that on the date the Application was lodged Mr Blow was not a worker or temporarily unemployed, as required by section 14(1)(C)(h)(ii) of the then legislation. [6] Blow v Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland[6] (1985) 30 WCR 66.Findings and conclusion As I recorded at the conclusion of proceedings on 23 June 2017, the submissions ofMr O'Neill on behalf of the Regulator, about the meaning to be given to the provisions at section 125(2) of the Act, are clearly correct. The wording used in the section is clear on its face and there is no need to resort to external materials to assist in its interpretation. It is a tightly worded section which acts to clearly identify who, and who is not, entitled to make an Application for workers' compensation for industrial deafness. Subject to the exceptions recorded at section 113 of the Act, section 125(2) records that applications for workers' compensation for industrial deafness may only be made by three (3) categories of persons, as follows:·by a person who is currently a worker (as defined in section 11 of the Act) while they are actually working in Queensland and covered by the Act; or·a person who would ordinarily meet the requirements immediately above but who is temporarily unemployed; or·a person who met the requirement at the first dot point and who submits an application within 12 months after their formal retirement from employment. Relevantly, in terms of the arguments presented on behalf of Mr Dubbin, neither sections 125(2)(b) and/or (c) have any relevance to his situation. His submissions are limited to the argument that he is captured by the provisions of section 125(2)(a) because he is "a worker" as defined under this Act. However, the italicised words do not appear in the Act as they would need to if Mr Dubbin's submission was to succeed. Rather, as Mr O'Neill submitted, in order to satisfy the requirements at section 125(2)(a) a person making a workers' compensation claim for industrial deafness may only do so (under that section) while the person "is a worker under this Act". Mr Dubbin did not satisfy that requirement at the time of lodging his Application in October 2015. Although Mr O'Neill's submissions did not touch on the submissions of Mr Dubbin about section 125(3) of the Act, it is clear that that section does not stand alone in the sense of providing some avenue by which Mr Dubbin might be entitled to workers' compensation for industrial deafness. Section 125(3) merely prescribes a minimum employment period in the State of Queensland before a person who has met one of the tests at section 125(2) can pursue their application. In other words, before a person is entitled to compensation for industrial deafness they must satisfy one of the three elements at section 125(2) and the whole of section 125(3). While Mr Dubbin might satisfy the provisions at s 125(3), those provisions have no application unless he falls into one of the three categories at section 125(2) – which he does not.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.