RE: MYPOLONGA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD;
RE: RIVER EQUITY PTY LTD;
and THE CORPORATIONS LAW
Appeal from a Master
Lander J
This is an appeal from orders made by a Master of this Court on 15 April 1998.
The appellant is an investment broker who, it is asserted, had dealings with Mypolonga Co-operative Society Ltd (Administrator Appointed), (“Mypolonga”), and River Equity Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed), (“River Equity”).
On 14 January 1998, Bruce Carter, a liquidator and the administrator of Mypolonga and River Equity, swore an affidavit in support of an application pursuant to ss596B and 597 of the Corporations Law, for an order for the examination of the appellant, Frances Charles Du Bois, relating to loans made by Mypolonga in the period between 1 January 1995 and 23 October 1996.
An order for the examination of the appellant was made on 3 February 1998 summoning him to attend before this Court on Wednesday, 25 February 1998.
Mr Du Bois attended the Court in response to the summons and was examined pursuant to the order.
On 10 February 1998, the solicitor for the appellant spoke to the barrister retained by Mr Carter who was to conduct the examination of the appellant and was told by the barrister that an order had been made that the examination of Mr Du Bois would be in private.
On 12 February 1998, the solicitor for the appellant was again informed that his client’s examination would be in private and that a solicitor, who sought to appear on behalf of Clayton Church Homes Incorporated, a party which had an interest in transactions in which Mr Du Bois and Mypolonga were involved, had applied to be present at the examination but that the application had been refused by the court.
The fiat on the court file shows that at a hearing before the Master on 12 February 1998 that, upon the administrator’s application, he made an order that the examination which had been conducted that morning and the examinations to be conducted on 25 and 26 February, should be “in camera”. That order included the proposed examination of the appellant.
At the same time the Master adjourned the application by Clayton Church Homes Incorporated for access to the transcripts to a date to be fixed after 11 March 1998.
The appellant claims that he relied upon the assertion made by the barrister acting for the administrator, and the order made by the Court on 12 February 1998, that the examinations would be held in private for the purpose of deciding whether he would claim legal professional privilege.
A solicitor, not the solicitor presently acting for Mr Du Bois, who was also the subject of an order for examination, advised Mr Du Bois that various files which had been seized by the police from that solicitor were the subject of legal professional privilege in favour of Mr Du Bois.
His present solicitor was contacted by the administrator’s solicitors seeking to have access to those documents for the purpose…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Du Bois v Carter No. Scgrg-98-48 Judgment No. S6732 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6732
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In its reasoning, the court found that the hearing before the Master miscarried due to the failure of parties to properly articulate their applications in writing, leading to confusion and a denial of natural justice to Du Bois. The court held that while Du Bois was entitled to assume that his examination would be private at its commencement due to special circumstances, he could not assume that the private nature of the examination would perpetually restrict access to its transcripts. The court emphasized that it is within its discretion to decide who may access the records of private examinations and that the public's right to inspect examination records under the Corporations Law cannot be defeated by private arrangements between examinees and eligible applicants. The court concluded that there were no special circumstances justifying the continued privacy of the examinations, and thus Clayton Church Homes Incorporated was entitled to access the transcripts of Du Bois's examination.
The court dismissed the appeal, finding that despite the procedural errors, the outcome would have been the same had Du Bois been allowed to present his evidence. The appeal was dismissed, and the orders made by the Master were upheld.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case is an appeal from orders made by a Master of the Supreme Court of South Australia on 15 April 1998. The appeal was heard by Lander J. The original application for Du Bois's examination was made pursuant to sections 596B and 597 of the Corporations Law, leading to an order for his examination on 3 February 1998. Du Bois's examination was held in private on 25 and 26 February 1998. On 9 April 1998, the administrator's solicitors informed Du Bois's solicitors of an upcoming argument regarding access to the examination transcripts. On 13 April 1998, Du Bois's solicitors responded, seeking more information about the upcoming argument. On 15 April 1998, the matter came before the Master, who made orders regarding the future conduct of the examinations and access to the transcripts.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Master err in not allowing Du Bois to put submissions and evidence in respect of Clayton Church Homes Incorporated's application for access to the transcripts of his examination?
2. Whether Clayton Church Homes Incorporated is entitled to access the transcript of Du Bois's examination.
3. Whether the Master's conclusion on the special circumstances for holding the examination in private was correct.
4. Whether the Master erred in not hearing argument on the point that the fact that the examination of Du Bois was conducted in private did not prevent Clayton Church Homes Incorporated having access to the transcript of that examination.
Held
1. The Master did err in not allowing Du Bois to put submissions and evidence in respect of Clayton Church Homes Incorporated's application for access to the transcripts of his examination.
2. Clayton Church Homes Incorporated is not entitled to access the transcript of Du Bois's examination.
3. The Master's conclusion on the special circumstances for holding the examination in private was correct.
4. The Master erred in not hearing argument on the point that the fact that the examination of Du Bois was conducted in private did not prevent Clayton Church Homes Incorporated having access to the transcript of that examination.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appeal centred around the decision of the Master to allow Clayton Church Homes Incorporated access to the transcripts of Du Bois's examination. The court examined the statutory framework under which the examination was ordered and held, focusing on sections 596B, 597, 596F, and 597(14A) of the Corporations Law. The court found that while the examination could be held in private due to special circumstances, this did not preclude other parties from accessing the transcripts under certain conditions. The court emphasised that the decision to hold an examination in private and restrict access to its records was within the court's discretion, subject to the purpose of the examination being for the benefit of the public and the principle of transparency in corporate examinations. The court held that once the special circumstances justifying a private examination ceased, the examination should revert to public, and the records should be accessible to the public, including creditors and members of the public, subject to payment of a fee. The court also noted that any assumption by the examinee that a private examination meant the records would remain inaccessible to others was unreasonable and could not bind the court. Ultimately, the court dismissed the appeal, finding that while there was procedural unfairness in how the hearing was conducted, the substantive decision on the access to the transcript was correct.