Drummond v Registrar of Probates (SA)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
25 CLR 318

DRUMMOND

THE REGISTRAR OF PROBATES (SOUTH

AUSTRALIA)

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Administration and Probate-Resealing foreign probate-Person entitled to apply-

Executor of deceased executor--Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.) (No. 537), sec. 26 (1) - Additional Rules under the Administration and Probate Act ADELAIDE,

1891 (S.A.), rule 94.

Sec. 26 (1) of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.) provides that " When any probate

granted by any Court of competent jurisdiction in the United Kingdom

shall be produced to and a copy thereof deposited with the Registrar, such probate with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia, and shall have the like force and effect and the same operation in South Australia, and every executor

thereunder shall have the same rights and powers, perform the same duties, and be subject to the same liabilities, as if such probate been originally granted by the Supreme Court of South Australia."

25 CLR 319

Rule 94 of the Additional Rules under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 provides that Application for the sealing of any probate under sec. 26 of the Act may be made by the executor (lawfully authorized for the purpose) of such executor person or through a solicitor."

Probate of the will of A, who had real estate in South Australia, was granted by the High Court of Justice of England to his executor, B. B having died, probate of his will was granted by the same Court to his executor, C, and was sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

Held, that C was entitled as of right under sec. 26 (1) to have the probate of the will of A sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

In the Goods of Gaynor, L.R. 1 P. &M., 723, distinguished. Decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of South Australia.

On 25th June 1913 probate of the will of the Right Honourable George Wyndham, who owned certain real property in South Australia, was by the Principal Probate Registry of the High Court of Justice of England granted to Percy Lyulph Wyndham, his son and the sole executor appointed by the will. On 15th September 1914 Percy Lyulph Wyndham died, and on 20th November 1914 probate of his will was granted by the Principal Probate Registry of the same Court to George Henry Drummond, one of the executors named in the will, power being reserved to the other executor. On 10th December 1917 the probate of the will of Percy Lyulph Wyndham was sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia. On 26th March 1918 application was made on motion to that Supreme Court on behalf of John Whinham Packard, the attorney of George Henry Drummond, for an order that an exemplification of the probate of the will of George Wyndham should be sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court. The applica- tion…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Drummond v Registrar of Probates (SA) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1918] HCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appellant, George Henry Drummond, sought to have an exemplification of the probate of the will of George Wyndham sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia. Probate of Wyndham's will had originally been granted in England to his executor, Percy Lyulph Wyndham. Upon Percy Lyulph Wyndham's death, probate of his will was granted in England to Drummond, who was one of his executors. The dispute arose when the Registrar of Probates refused to seal the probate of Wyndham's will in South Australia, a decision upheld by the majority of the Supreme Court.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether George Henry Drummond, as the executor of the deceased executor (Percy Lyulph Wyndham), was entitled as of right under section 26(1) of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.) to have the probate of the original testator, George Wyndham, sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia. This involved determining whether the chain of executorship was maintained and if the provisions of the Act and relevant rules permitted such an application by an executor of a deceased executor whose own probate had been sealed in South Australia.

The High Court, allowing the appeal, reasoned that the principle established in legal texts, such as Tristram & Coote's Probate Practice, dictates that an executor who has taken probate of their testator's will becomes, ipso facto, the executor of any testator of whom the first testator was the sole or surviving executor. The Court found no break in this chain of executorship in the present case, particularly as the probate of the deceased executor, Percy Lyulph Wyndham, had been sealed in South Australia. Furthermore, the Court held that the word "shall" in section 26(1) of the Act, when read in conjunction with section 34 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1915 (S.A.), imposed a mandatory obligation on the Registrar to seal the probate. The Court distinguished the present case from *In the Goods of Gaynor*, noting that here the applicant was seeking to complete an action that the original executor had failed to undertake.

Consequently, the High Court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia be discharged, and the Registrar of Probates be directed to reseal the probate of George Wyndham's will.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 25th June 1913, the High Court of Justice of England granted probate of the will of George Wyndham to his son, Percy Lyulph Wyndham. George Wyndham owned certain real property in South Australia. On 15th September 1914, Percy Lyulph Wyndham died, and on 20th November 1914, probate of his will was granted by the Principal Probate Registry of the same Court to George Henry Drummond, who was named as one of the executors in the will. The probate of Percy Lyulph Wyndham's will was sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia on 10th December 1917.

On 26th March 1918, George Henry Drummond, through his attorney John Whinham Packard, applied to the Supreme Court of South Australia for an order to seal an exemplification of George Wyndham's will with the seal of the Supreme Court. The Full Court of the Supreme Court, by a majority, dismissed the application. George Henry Drummond appealed to the High Court of Australia, arguing that he was entitled to have the probate of George Wyndham's will sealed under section 26(1) of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.). The appeal was based on the argument that George Henry Drummond, as the executor of Percy Lyulph Wyndham, was entitled to have the probate sealed, as he was the executor of the deceased executor of the original testator.

The Registrar of Probates opposed the appeal, arguing that the sealing of the probate was not mandatory and that the court had the discretion to determine the applicant's entitlement to have the probate sealed. The Registrar further contended that the chain of executorship was broken when Percy Lyulph Wyndham failed to have the probate of George Wyndham's will sealed in South Australia. The Registrar also referred to rule 94 of the Additional Rules under the Administration and Probate Act 1891, which specifies that the application for sealing the probate could only be made by the executor of the testator in South Australia.

The matter of Drummond v Registrar of Probates (SA) came before the High Court of Australia on appeal from the Supreme Court of South Australia. The initial probate of the will of George Wyndham, who owned real property in South Australia, was granted by the Principal Probate Registry of the High Court of Justice of England to Percy Lyulph Wyndham on 25 June 1913. Following the death of Percy Lyulph Wyndham on 15 September 1914, probate of his will was granted to George Henry Drummond by the same Court on 20 November 1914. On 10 December 1917, the probate of Percy Lyulph Wyndham's will was sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court of South Australia. Subsequently, on 26 March 1918, an application was made to the Supreme Court of South Australia by John Whinham Packard, the attorney of George Henry Drummond, seeking an order that an exemplification of the probate of George Wyndham's will should be sealed with the seal of the Supreme Court. The Full Court of the Supreme Court dismissed the application by a majority decision, with Murray C.J. and Buchanan J. concurring and Gordon J. dissenting. This decision was subsequently appealed to the High Court, where the appeal was allowed, and the Registrar of Probates was directed to reseal the probate in accordance with section 26(1) of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (SA).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the executor of a deceased executor entitled to have the probate of the original testator's will sealed under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.)?
2. Does the mandatory language of section 26 (1) of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.) obligate the Registrar of Probates to seal the foreign probate when produced and a copy deposited?
3. Does the requirement in rule 94 of the Additional Rules under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 that the application for resealing must be made by the executor "lawfully authorized for the purpose" restrict the entitlement of the appellant to have the probate sealed?
4. Does the failure of the original executor to have the probate of the testator's will resealed in South Australia constitute a break in the chain of executorship under section 54 of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.)?
5. Is the decision in In the Goods of Gaynor (1875) L.R. 1 P. & M. 723 applicable to the question of resealing an English probate in South Australia?

Held
1. The executor of a deceased executor is entitled to have the probate of the original testator's will sealed under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.).
2. The mandatory language of section 26 (1) of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.) obligates the Registrar of Probates to seal the foreign probate when produced and a copy deposited.
3. The requirement in rule 94 of the Additional Rules under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 does not restrict the entitlement of the appellant to have the probate sealed.
4. The failure of the original executor to have the probate of the testator's will resealed in South Australia does not constitute a break in the chain of executorship under section 54 of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.).
5. The decision in In the Goods of Gaynor (1875) L.R. 1 P. & M. 723 is not applicable to the question of resealing an English probate in South Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Drummond v Registrar of Probates (SA) considered several issues pertaining to the sealing of a foreign probate in South Australia under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.). The central issue was whether the executor of a deceased executor was entitled to have the original testator's will sealed under the Act. The court held that the executor of a deceased executor was indeed entitled to have the will resealed, as they became the executor of the original testator by virtue of their appointment under the earlier will. This interpretation was based on the principle that an executor who has taken probate of their own testator's will becomes, ipso facto, the executor of the will of any testator of whom the other was the sole or surviving executor.

The court further addressed whether the mandatory language of section 26(1) of the Act obligated the Registrar of Probates to seal the foreign probate when produced and a copy deposited. The court ruled that the word "shall" in section 26(1) was indeed mandatory, and the Registrar was required to seal the foreign probate under the provisions of section 34 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1915. This interpretation was supported by authorities such as In re Rankine and In re Thornley, which held that the Registrar was not at liberty to decline sealing the probate without inquiry into the applicant's title.

Another issue considered was whether the requirement in rule 94 of the Additional Rules under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 that the application for resealing must be made by the executor "lawfully authorized for the purpose" restricted the entitlement of the appellant. The court found that the appellant, as the executor of the deceased executor, was lawfully authorized to make the application for resealing, and the rule did not impose any additional restrictions on the appellant's entitlement.

The court also examined whether the failure of the original executor to have the probate of the testator's will resealed in South Australia constituted a break in the chain of executorship under section 54 of the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.). The court held that there was no break in the chain, and the appellant remained the executor of the original testator's will by virtue of their appointment under the earlier will.

Finally, the court considered whether the decision in In the Goods of Gaynor (1875) L.R. 1 P. & M. 723 was applicable to the question of resealing an English probate in South Australia. The court distinguished the case of In the Goods of Gaynor, noting that it dealt with the grant of administration rather than the resealing of an English probate, which is a purely ministerial act. The court concluded that the decision in In the Goods of Gaynor had no application to the present case.

The ratio decidendi of the case is that the executor of a deceased executor is entitled to have the original testator's will sealed in South Australia under the Administration and Probate Act 1891 (S.A.), and the Registrar of Probates is obligated to seal the foreign probate when produced and a copy deposited. The court also held that there was no break in the chain of executorship, and the decision in In the Goods of Gaynor was not applicable to the question of resealing an English probate in South Australia.