Drinkwater v Caddyrack Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
Reported Decision: [1999] 17 ACLC 1592

New South Wales


Supreme Court

CITATION: Drinkwater v Caddyrack Pty Limited [1999] NSWSC 851
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
FILE NUMBER(S): 3970/96
HEARING DATE(S): 12 March and 12 April 1999
JUDGMENT DATE:
26 August 1999

PARTIES :


Peter Westgarth Drinkwater and John Francis Drinkwater (P1)
Lustray Pty Limited (P2)
Caddyrank Inc (P3)
Caddyrack Pty Limited (P4)
Caddyrack Pty Limited (D1)
Terrance Kyrwood (D2)
Geoffery Kyrwood (D3)
Caddyrack International Pty Limited (D4)
Gedrot Pty Limited (D5)
Gavros Pty Limited (D6)
JUDGMENT OF: Master McLaughlin
COUNSEL : Mr. M. Ashurst (P)
Mr. A. McInerney (D)
SOLICITORS: Hansens Solicitors (P)
McDonald Johnson (D)
CATCHWORDS: Valuation of shares; Buy-back of shares of members of a company by other members; Method of valuation; Valuation not an exact science; Expert evidence.
ACTS CITED: Corporations Law
CASES CITED: Re London School of Electronic Limited [1985] 3 WLR 474
Dynasty Pty Limited v Coombs (1990) 14 ACSR 60
Lusk v Archive Security Limited (1991) 5 NZCLC 66,979
Ledesma v Nobule Pty Limited (Master McLaughlin, 11 December 1997, unreported)
Re Golden Bread Pty Limited [1977] QR 44
Diligenti v RWMD Operations Kelowna Limited (No. 2) (1977) 4 BCLR 134
Kizquari Pty Limited v Prestoo Pty Limited (1993) 10 ACLSR 606
Sapir v Sapir (1989) 13 FamLR 362
DECISION: 1. I certify the value of the shares in Caddyrack Pty Limited at $41,495 a share; 2. I express the view that the plaintiffs are entitled to have the fifth and sixth defendants pay the costs of the plaintiffs of the enquiry referred to in order 6 of the orders made on 28 November 1997.

SUPREME COURT OF
NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

MASTER McLAUGHLIN

Thursday, 26 August 1999

3970/96 PETER WESTGARTH DRINKWATER & ORS -v- CADDYRACK PTY LIMITED & ORS

JUDGMENT

1    MASTER: The substantive proceedings were heard before Mr Justice Young in 1997. His Honour made orders on 23 October 1997. His Honour made subsequent orders on 28 November 1997 (which were entered on 12 December 1997) to give effect to the essential items of relief claimed by the plaintiffs. That relief included a buy-back by the fifth and sixth defendants, Gedrot Pty Limited and Gavros Pty Limited of the shares held by the first plaintiffs Peter Westgarth Drinkwater and John Francis Drinkwater in the first defendant Caddyrack Pty Limited. Substantive relief in that regard was contained in orders 2 and 3, as follows:
        2. The Fifth and Sixth Defendants purchase the shares which the Second Plaintiff (or in the alternative the First Plaintiffs) hold in the First Defendant (the “Shares”) at a valuation to be agreed to assessed in accordance with orders 3 to 5 herein.
        3. For the purposes of determining the value of the Shares in order 2 the appropriate date from which the Shares are to be valued is 25 September 1997.
2 In making order 2 His Honour invoked section 260 of the Corporations Law (now renumbered as section 246AA), which makes provision for the purchase of the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Drinkwater v Caddyrack Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWSC 851
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Drinkwater v Caddyrack Pty Limited, the dispute involved the valuation of shares for the purposes of a buy-back agreement between the plaintiff, Drinkwater, and the defendant, Caddyrack Pty Limited. The case was heard and determined by the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, Drinkwater, was a shareholder in Caddyrack Pty Limited and sought to enforce a buy-back agreement whereby Caddyrack Pty Limited was obligated to purchase his shares under certain conditions. The primary issue before the court was the method by which the value of these shares should be determined, as the parties could not agree on the appropriate valuation method.

The legal issues that the court had to resolve included whether the valuation of shares in such a context should be determined by expert evidence, and if so, what weight should be given to such evidence. The court also needed to address whether the valuation of shares is an exact science or if it involves a degree of estimation and subjectivity. Furthermore, the court had to consider the appropriate approach to resolving disputes about the valuation of shares when the parties had not specified a valuation method in their agreement.

The court concluded that the valuation of shares in this context was not an exact science and involved a degree of estimation. It found that expert evidence could be a valuable tool in determining the value of the shares, but it should not be the sole determinant. The court emphasised the importance of considering all relevant factors and adopting a balanced approach that took into account both objective and subjective elements of valuation. Ultimately, the court determined that the valuation should reflect a fair and reasonable estimation of the shares' value, considering the various factors and expert evidence presented. The court ordered that the valuation be conducted by a neutral expert appointed by both parties, and that the resulting valuation would be binding on both parties unless there was clear evidence of a manifest error.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.