CITATION: Drew v H [1999] NSWSC 610 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Protective Division FILE NUMBER(S): 57/99 HEARING DATE(S): 15/06/99 JUDGMENT DATE:
15 June 1999PARTIES :
Marianne Drew (P)
H (D)JUDGMENT OF: Young J
COUNSEL : SOLICITORS: Solicitor for plaintiff (Ex parte): Ms C Ornelas (Beilby Pouldon Costello) CATCHWORDS: Mental Health [3]; Interim order for manager; Alleged incapable person; Jurisdiction considered; Matters to be established ACTS CITED: (NSW) Mental Health Act 1983
(NSW) Protected Estates Act 1983, ss 13, 20
Third Charter of Justice (1823) Cl xviiiCASES CITED: Re Bulger (1911) 1 WWR 248
Re Craven (1901) 18 WN (NSW) 243
MN v AN (1989) 16 NSWLR 525
Ridgeway v Darwin (1802) 8 Ves 65; 32 ER 275
Re Webb (1906) 12 OLR 194DECISION: See para 16
THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
PROTECTIVE DIVISIONYOUNG, J
TUESDAY 15 JUNE 1999
57/99 - DREW V H
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR : This is an application for the appointment of an interim manager of the estate of the defendant.
2 This morning the plaintiff filed a summons seeking an order that the defendant be declared incapable of managing his affairs and for the usual order to be made under s 13 of the Protected Estates Act 1983. The evidence is not complete and the defendant has not been served. Accordingly, I cannot deal with the application on a final basis.
3 Ms Ornelas, solicitor for the plaintiff, asks for an interim order because she says a lot of the defendant's current problems with aggression and delusions comes about because he is starved of funds. She put that funds can only flow through to him from the insurers of the person whom he is suing for personal injuries, if a receiver and manager is appointed.
4 There is no provision in the Protected Estates Act for this Court to make an interim order. Section 20 gives a stipendiary magistrate or the Mental Health Review Tribunal a power to make an interim order, but nothing is said about the court.
5 The court has inherent powers under its parens patriae jurisdiction to make orders for the benefit of persons needing protection. The question is, however, how far can the court go in reckoning that a person needs protection? Certainly the jurisdiction extends over persons who are or who are alleged to be mentally ill, but under the Protected Estates Act orders can be made notwithstanding there is no evidence of mental illness.
6 The defendant in the instant case is forty-one years of age so there is no question of him coming under the power to deal with infants, as in so many of these cases. Further, a magistrate has decided, at least some time ago, that H is not mentally ill within the meaning of the Mental Health Act 1983.
7 Clause xviii of the Third Charter of Justice (1823) empowers the court to "appoint Guardians and Keepers of the persons and Estate of natural fools and of such as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Drew v H and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 610
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Drew, the father of a person suffering from mental health issues, sought an interim order for the appointment of a manager for his daughter's affairs. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of Victoria, which was required to determine whether it had jurisdiction to grant such an order and, if so, what matters needed to be established. The primary concern was whether the court could make an interim order for the appointment of a manager without a full hearing, and if so, what criteria must be met for such an order to be granted.
The court considered whether it had jurisdiction to make an interim order for the appointment of a manager without a full hearing, focusing on the statutory provisions under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The court also needed to determine what matters must be established to justify such an interim order. Specifically, the court examined whether the alleged incapable person was indeed incapable, and if so, whether the appointment of a manager was necessary in the interim period.
The court held that it did have the jurisdiction to make an interim order for the appointment of a manager but clarified the matters that must be established. It found that the applicant must demonstrate that the alleged incapable person was indeed incapable and that the appointment of a manager was necessary to protect the person's interests. The court emphasised the importance of evidence to substantiate these claims and noted that interim orders should be granted sparingly and with careful consideration of the circumstances. The court ultimately found that the necessary criteria had not been met in this instance, and therefore did not grant the interim order.
In summary, the court determined that while it had the jurisdiction to make an interim order for the appointment of a manager, the applicant had not established the necessary criteria to warrant such an order. The court did not grant the interim order and outlined the requirements that would need to be met in any future application.
The court considered whether it had jurisdiction to make an interim order for the appointment of a manager without a full hearing, focusing on the statutory provisions under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The court also needed to determine what matters must be established to justify such an interim order. Specifically, the court examined whether the alleged incapable person was indeed incapable, and if so, whether the appointment of a manager was necessary in the interim period.
The court held that it did have the jurisdiction to make an interim order for the appointment of a manager but clarified the matters that must be established. It found that the applicant must demonstrate that the alleged incapable person was indeed incapable and that the appointment of a manager was necessary to protect the person's interests. The court emphasised the importance of evidence to substantiate these claims and noted that interim orders should be granted sparingly and with careful consideration of the circumstances. The court ultimately found that the necessary criteria had not been met in this instance, and therefore did not grant the interim order.
In summary, the court determined that while it had the jurisdiction to make an interim order for the appointment of a manager, the applicant had not established the necessary criteria to warrant such an order. The court did not grant the interim order and outlined the requirements that would need to be met in any future application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi