LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Drake Coal Pty Ltd & Anor v Gordon Wallace MacNicol [2011] QLC 0009 PARTIES: Drake Coal Pty Ltd and Jax Coal Pty Ltd
(Applicants)v. Gordon Wallace MacNicol
(Respondent)FILE NO: MRA865-10
MRA866-10
MRA24-11
MRA25-11DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland PROCEEDINGS: Review; question posed by Court DELIVERED ON: 16 March 2011 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARD AT: Brisbane MEMBER: His Honour, Mr WL Cochrane, Member ORDERS:
The Court is empowered to consider the question of compensation in the absence of any details about the conditions which may attach to or the terms of any recommendation for the grant of a mining lease.
CATCHWORDS: Power to assess compensation - Mineral Resources Act 1989 ss 268, 279, 281 APPEARANCES: Mr DB Fooks, Solicitor, Clayton Utz Lawyers appeared for the Applicants
Ms F Pinfold, Trainee Solicitor, by leave, Emanate Legal appeared for the Respondent
Mr SR Grant of Counsel, Legal Services, Department of Employment and Economic Development and Innovation appeared on behalf of the State of Queensland by way of assistance and at the request of the Court
Background
Each of these matters requires determination of the compensation payable in respect of mining leases sought by each of the applicants, Drake Coal Pty Ltd and Jax Coal Pty Ltd.
The ambition of the miners (Drake Coal Pty Ltd and Jax Coal Pty Ltd) is to operate separate open-cut coal mines in an area located near to Collinsville. The landowner in respect of each of the applications is Gordon Wallace MacNicol. Details of the proposed leases and the real property description is Lot 618 on Crown Plan PH2106 Title Reference 17664023 (the Land).
Consequent upon reading the application material in each of the files it became apparent that these are cases in which no recommendation for a mining lease had been made and, in fact, the mining lease applications are still in every sense of the word being progressed through all of their various stages.
At my direction, the Registrar wrote to the parties and to the Department of Employment, Economic Development and Innovation observing as follows:
“His Honour had an opportunity to review the files in each of the above matters and is concerned as to the capacity of the Court to deal with determination of the question of compensation. In circumstances where the terms of the possible mining lease remain unclear, in the absence of any recommendation regarding the lease applied for including, in particular, the area and duration of the recommended lease any determination may be purely hypothetical.
Accordingly, His Honour has instructed me to write to you as the appropriate departmental officer, apprised of the Court’s concerns as a consequence of earlier dialogue between yourself and the Registrar of the Land Court, to invite the department by its legal representatives to participate in the hearing set down on Thursday morning.
The Member is concerned to avoid unnecessary litigation being visited upon applicants for mining lease, in circumstances where the Court may come to the view that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Drake Coal Pty Ltd v Gordon Wallace MacNicol and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QLC 9
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the court could assess compensation in the absence of specific details about the conditions that might apply to, or the terms of, any recommendation for the grant of a mining lease. The court was required to determine if it had the necessary information to make a fair and just assessment of compensation, given that the details of the lease had not been fully disclosed.
In delivering the judgment, the court considered the statutory framework provided by the Mineral Resources Act 1989, particularly sections 268, 279, and 281. The court concluded that it could indeed consider the question of compensation, even in the absence of detailed information regarding the lease conditions or the terms of any recommendation. The court held that the absence of these details did not prevent it from exercising its power to assess compensation. The court found that it was empowered to make an assessment based on the information available, while acknowledging the need for more detailed information in the future.
The court's decision recognised the authority to assess compensation without complete details about the lease conditions or terms of any recommendation. This ruling allows the court to proceed with the compensation assessment in the present case, while also highlighting the importance of obtaining complete information in future proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Court is empowered to consider the question of compensation in the absence of any details about the conditions which may attach to or the terms of any recommendation for the grant of a mining lease.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.