Dr Ruwan Suwandarathne v Canberra Health Services

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
[2022] FWCFB 181

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.604—Appeal of decision

Dr Ruwan Suwandarathne
v

Canberra Health Services

(C2022/5793)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT GOSTENCNIK
DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAUNDERS
COMMISSIONER MCKINNON

MELBOURNE, 12 OCTOBER 2022

Appeal against decision [2022] FWC 2011 of Commissioner Matheson at Sydney on 29 July 2022 in matter number C2021/8419

  1. The appellant, Dr Ruwan Suwandarathne, is employed by the respondent, Canberra Health Services, as a specialist intensive care medical practitioner and has been so employed since 2 March 2015. The appellant has been in dispute with the respondent about his advancement to a position of senior specialist and on 10 December 2021 he applied under s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) for the Commission to deal with a dispute in accordance with the dispute settlement term of the ACT Public Sector Medical Practitioners Enterprise Agreement 2017-2021 (Agreement). In substance, the appellant sought by way of relief that he should be advanced to senior specialist retrospectively with effect from July 2019.[1]

  1. By a decision published on 26 July 2022,[2] Commissioner Matheson determined the dispute by arbitration. The Commissioner refused the relief claimed and dismissed the application.[3]

  1. Relevantly, the Commissioner identified three questions arising from the appellant’s dispute application requiring determination. First, whether the respondent applied the criteria and robust competency framework set out in “Advancement to Senior Specialist guidelines”, to which reference is made in clause 14.3 of the Agreement, to the appellant’s application for advancement to senior specialist?[4] Second, whether the appellant met the criteria and robust competency framework so that he should progress to senior specialist?[5] Third, whether the respondent breached its consultation obligations under clause 14.5 and/or clause 124 of the Agreement?[6]

  1. The Commissioner answered these questions as follows:

[463]    Notwithstanding this, in relation to the matters that I need to determine as a part of this dispute, I have found as follows:

·  As to the question of whether the Respondent has complied with clause 14.3 of the Agreement, I find that the Respondent has not strictly complied with clause 14.3 of the Agreement in one respect. In particular, I find that, in its assessment of the Applicant against the “Teaching” criterion in CHS20/333, the Discussion Guidelines applied by the Review Panels had the effect of both narrowing the scope of the criterion as well as setting a higher bar in order for it to be satisfied. However, as I have found, the Second Review Panel actually found the Applicant was competent in relation to the “Teaching” criteria. As such, it is not the Second Review Panel’s assessment of the Applicant against this criterion that resulted in the “action” or decision that is now the subject of this dispute. In this regard, I do not consider that this technical breach by the Respondent is material to this particular dispute.

·  Based on the evidence before me, I am unable to find that the Applicant should advance to the level of Senior Specialist.

·  I am not satisfied, based on the evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dr Ruwan Suwandarathne v Canberra Health Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FWCFB 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dr Ruwan Suwandarathne, a specialist intensive care medical practitioner, appeals against a decision of the Fair Work Commission (Commission) dismissing his application for relief under s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act). Dr Suwandarathne sought to be advanced to senior specialist. The Commission found that he did not meet the criteria for advancement and dismissed his application. The Deputy President, Saunders and McKinnon, refused permission to appeal. The appellant submitted six grounds for appeal. The first ground was that the Commissioner erred in finding that the respondent had not breached clause 14 of the Agreement by delaying his application process for two years. The second ground was that the Commissioner erred by failing to take into account her finding that the discussion guidelines applied by the review panel had the effect of both narrowing the scope of the criterion as well as setting a higher bar in order for it to be satisfied. The third ground was that the Commissioner erred in not finding that the CEO’s decision as Head of Service not to advance the appellant to senior specialist was not a valid decision because there was no evidence that the recommendation of the review panel was approved in writing by the CEO or any delegate. The fourth ground was that the Commissioner erred in attaching more weight to the evidence of Dr Coatsworth than that of the appellant about whether the appellant met the criteria for advancement to senior specialist. The fifth ground was that the Commissioner erred in not finding that he should have been advanced to senior specialist based on the weight of evidence about his competence and suitability given by the appellant, and his supervisor and peers. The sixth ground was that the Commissioner erred in not finding the respondent breached clauses 14.5 and 124 of the Agreement by failing to consult about changes to level standards and competency requirements for progression when it replaced the ‘Specialist to Senior Specialist Selection Process – Guidelines for Promotion of Specialist to Senior Specialist’ (DGD13-033) with the ‘Canberra Health Services Procedure Advancement to Senior Staff Specialist’ (CHS20/333). The appeal grounds were misconceived. The third and fourth grounds were not raised at first instance and so were not available on appeal. The first ground was misconceived because the Commissioner found that the appellant was not suitable for advancement to senior specialist. The second ground was misconceived because the Commissioner took the matter into account but found that the appellant was assessed as meeting the expanded criteria and the departure was not material to the dispute. The fifth ground had no substance because the Commissioner was left with a choice of preferring Dr Coatsworth’s evidence to that of the appellant and the choice made was one that was open to the Commissioner. The sixth ground was wrong because the Commissioner found that there were existing arrangements in place for the assessment of the appellant and so any complaint about the absence of consultation about changes to level standards and competency requirements for progression could not amount to a breach of the Agreement. The appeal was refused because no appealable error was disclosed and there were no exceptional circumstances which might permit the matters raised by the appeal grounds to be considered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established