Dr. Rudolf J.F. Guertler v Antenna Engineering Australia Pty

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952 - and - In the Matter of Petty Patent 529212 in the Name of DR. RUDOLF J.F. GUERTLER - and - In the Matter of a Notice under Sub-Section 68B(3) by ANTENNA ENGINEERING AUSTRALIA PTY. LTD.

 

FINAL DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER OF PATENTS:

This matter concerns petty patent number 529212 entitled "Controlled- Directivity Wide-Band High-Frequency Antenna". The application, number 88662/82 was lodged on 24 September, 1982 and the petty patent was sealed on 26 March, 1984. Notice under sub-section 68B(3) was lodged by A. Tatlock & Associates, Patent Attorneys, on 11 April, 1984 on behalf of Antenna Engineering Australia Pty. Ltd. ("the informant"). The sub-section 68B(3) notice was the subject of a hearing on 5 June, 1984 before Mr. P. Heathcote, Supervising Examiner of Patents, as delegate of the Commissioner of Patents.

According to the specification as accepted, the invention relates to an antenna for radio communication in the high frequency band, 2 to 30 MHz, for use where service over very different distances is required. The hearing officer decided that the claim was invalid on the grounds of obviousness and non-compliance with the requirements of section 40. The material part of the decision reads:

"I must pay heed to the patentee's contention, both orally and by declaration, that his invention lies in providing two grounding metal rods at each end of the antenna, to which the ends of the separate conductor (or earth wire) are conductively connected and to which the corners of tie wings of the antenna are respectively anchored and that this provides better mechanical stability with the rods at each end located on either side of the wing plane, and that this together with the fact that no other grounding is provided elsewhere along the separate conductor, provides an antenna with improved electrical characteristics. Nevertheless, these features are not defined in the claim albeit they have been described in the body of the specification, and this makes the claim bad, as it fails to comply with the requirements of section 40 of the Act However, I am satisfied that a claim drafted to include these features would not only comply with the requirements of section 40, but would also be not obvious in the light of the evidence presented by the informant. An antenna defined by such a claim would be defining more than the combined features of the two antennae shown in figs. 6 and 11 of exhibit DC5, and the additional features would provide an improved result electric- ally and mechanically, and this in my opinion takes it away from the realm of obviousness.

Under the circumstances, I feel that rather than reject the petty patent entirely, the patentee should be given an opportunity to amend the claim to encompass the features which he has argued as being the features of his invention. Accordingly, I direct the patentee to lodge amendments to amend the claim to my satisfaction within a period of 30 days from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dr. Rudolf J.F. Guertler v Antenna Engineering Australia Pty and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1985] APO 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dr. Rudolf J.F. Guertler contested a notice under sub-section 68B(3) lodged by Antenna Engineering Australia Pty. Ltd. concerning the validity of petty patent number 529212, titled "Controlled-Directivity Wide-Band High-Frequency Antenna". The dispute centred on whether the patent met the requirements of section 40 of the Patents Act 1952 and was not obvious. The hearing officer, Mr. P. Heathcote, found the initial claim invalid due to non-compliance with section 40 and obviousness. However, he allowed the patentee an opportunity to amend the claim.

The court examined several legal issues, including the extension of the term of an expired petty patent, the amendment of petty patent specifications during section 68B proceedings, and whether the amended claim met the hearing officer’s requirements and remained non-obvious. The court interpreted the provisions of the Patents Act to allow the extension of the term of a lapsed petty patent and found that section 68B proceedings did not preclude amendments under sections 77 to 84. It also determined that the amended claim sufficiently addressed the hearing officer’s concerns and did not render the invention obvious.

Ultimately, the court granted an extension of the term of the petty patent and ruled in favour of the patentee, Dr. Guertler. The costs of the proceedings were awarded to the informant up to the date of the advertisement of the amendments and to the patentee thereafter. This decision ensured that the patentee's rights were protected while addressing the issues raised by the informant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established