Dr Michael Van Thanh Quach v MLC Life Limited (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dr Michael Van Thanh Quach v MLC Life Limited (No 4) [2020] FCA 532

File number: ACD 18 of 2019
Judge: GRIFFITHS J
Date of judgment: 24 April 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory applications by applicant to set aside in full or part various subpoenas issued by the respondent – subpoenas found to be validly issued because they have sufficient adjectival relevance – failure by applicant to establish any of his multiple grounds of challenge to the subpoenas – interlocutory applications dismissed with costs
Legislation:

Australian Capital Territory (Self-government) Act 1988 (Cth), s 48AA

Insurance Contracts Act 1984, ss 13, 47(2)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 38(b)

Cases cited:

Forge v Australian Securities and Investment Commission (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 42; 69 NSWLR 575

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40

Quach v MLC Life Limited (No 1) [2019] FCA 1194

Quach v MLC Life Limited (No 2) [2019] FCA 1322

Quach v MLC Limited (No 3) [2019] FCA 2066

Date of hearing: 31 March 2020
Registry: Australian Capital Territory
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 29
Counsel for the Applicant: The applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr N Olson
Solicitor for the Respondent: TurksLegal

ORDERS

ACD 18 of 2019
BETWEEN:

DR MICHAEL VAN THANH QUACH

Applicant

AND:

MLC LIFE LIMITED (ABN: 90 000 000 402)

Respondent

JUDGE:

GRIFFITHS J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 APRIL 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory applications filed on 17 January 2020 and 28 January 2020 be dismissed. 

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to both interlocutory applications, as agreed or taxed. 

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

GRIFFITHS J:

  1. By two interlocutory applications filed on 17 January 2020 and 28 January 2020, Dr Quach seeks to set aside in full or in part various subpoenas which have been issued by the respondent, MLC Life Limited (MLC).  The substantive proceeding relates to Dr Quach’s dissatisfaction with the MLC’s rejection of his claim on an insurance policy called the MLC personal protection portfolio policy. 

  2. The first interlocutory application seeks the following relief (without alteration):

    1. Set aside parts of ten subpoenas issued by MLC Limited dated 21 June 2019 issued to:

    I.         Dr Michael Van Thanh Quach

    II.       Botany Medical Centre

    III.      Railway Street Medical Centre

    IV.      Dr Andrew Petherbridge

    V.       Dr Bernard St George

    VI.      Dr Karleng Tan

    VII.     Susan Morton

    VIII.    Sara Guirgis

    IX.      Dr Merson Mathew

    X.       Department of Human Service

    2.Revoke Leave to issue or set aside any further subpoenas that MLC Limited has requested leave to issue:

    I.        Dr Jeff Bertucen

    II.       Professor Roy Gary Beran

    III.      Dr Anthony Samuels

    IV.      Dr Simon John Whitfield Young

    V.       Dr Yvonne Skinner

    VI.      Dr Jonathan Phillips.

  3. The second interlocutory application seeks the following relief…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dr Michael Van Thanh Quach v MLC Life Limited (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 532
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dr Michael Van Thanh Quach sought to set aside various subpoenas issued by MLC Life Limited. The dispute was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issue before the Court was whether Dr Quach had established any grounds to challenge the validity of the subpoenas issued by MLC Life Limited. The Court was required to determine if the subpoenas were validly issued and if they sought material that was adjectivally relevant to the case. Additionally, the Court had to consider Dr Quach's arguments regarding the legal advice provided to MLC Life Limited and its impact on the issuance of the subpoenas.

The Court found that Dr Quach had not demonstrated any valid grounds to challenge the subpoenas. The material sought by the subpoenas was considered to have sufficient adjectival relevance to the case, particularly concerning Dr Quach's medical condition and his ability to work. The Court rejected Dr Quach's assertion that the legal advice provided to MLC Life Limited required them to accept liability for his claim for total disability. The advice was deemed to be tentative and did not bind MLC Life Limited. Furthermore, the principle from Mason J's judgment in Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd was found not to be applicable in this private law case. The Court concluded that the subpoenas were validly issued and that Dr Quach had failed to establish any valid grounds for setting them aside.

The interlocutory applications filed by Dr Quach on 17 January 2020 and 28 January 2020 were dismissed. Dr Quach was ordered to pay the costs of and incidental to both interlocutory applications, as agreed or taxed. The Court emphasised that the subpoenas were validly issued, and Dr Quach's challenges to their validity were unfounded. The decision underscored the importance of adjectival relevance in determining the validity of subpoenas in private law cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory applications filed on 17 January 2020 and 28 January 2020 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to both interlocutory applications, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dr Michael Van Thanh Quach brought an application seeking to set aside various subpoenas issued by MLC Life Limited. Dr Quach's medical registration was cancelled, leading to a dispute over his entitlement to total disability benefits. MLC Life Limited issued subpoenas to obtain medical records and other documents relevant to Dr Quach's medical condition. Dr Quach challenged the validity of these subpoenas on multiple grounds, arguing they were improperly issued and lacked adjectival relevance. He submitted that MLC Life Limited was bound by legal advice provided by Ms Oliver, who suggested it was arguable that Dr Quach may have been totally disabled due to Narcissistic Personality Disorder. The case revolved around the validity of the subpoenas and whether Dr Quach's challenges to them were substantiated.

Dr Quach filed interlocutory applications on 17 January 2020 and 28 January 2020 seeking to set aside the subpoenas issued by MLC Life Limited. These applications were heard by the court, which considered the arguments presented by both parties. The court reviewed the legal advice provided to MLC Life Limited by Ms Oliver and assessed the adjectival relevance of the documents sought by the subpoenas. After hearing the submissions, the court determined that Dr Quach had not established any of his grounds for challenging the subpoenas. Consequently, the court dismissed the interlocutory applications with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Quach has not established any of his multiple grounds of challenge to the subpoenas. Conclusion For these reasons, the interlocutory applications will both be dismissed, with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In respect of Ms Oliver’s advice to MLC, MLC submitted that the advice was not binding on it and, in any event, the statements made on page 4 were expressed in tentative and non-determinative terms. It further submitted that nothing said by Ms Oliver on page 8 of her advice was inconsistent with MLC’s right to issue the relevant subpoenas. It submitted that the material sought by those subpoenas was adjectively relevant to the question of Dr Quach’s medical condition. Consideration and determination At the commencement of the hearing, the Court drew to the parties’ attention that neither party had provided the Court with copies of any of the subpoenas which were the subject of Dr Quach’s challenge. The parties agreed, however, that it was sufficient for the Court to act upon the description of the relevant parts of the material in Dr Quach’s fourth affidavit. Accordingly, I have proceeded on that agreed basis. Dr Quach’s challenge to the relevant subpoenas is based on several fundamental flaws. First, and foremost, Dr Quach urges the Court to proceed on the basis that Ms Oliver’s legal advice to MLC was to accept liability for his claim for total disability. That is incorrect, as revealed in the extract set out at the beginning of Dr Quach’s outline of written submissions (see [9] above). Ms Oliver simply advised that it was “arguable” that Dr Quach may have been totally disabled if he suffered in fact from Narcissistic Personality Disorder and that is a sickness, which sickness also caused the behaviour that gave rise to the finding of professional misconduct. Dr Quach has significantly overstated the terms and effect of Ms Oliver’s advice. Moreover, there is no other material before the Court which supports his assertion that MLC had accepted liability for his claim. I consider that the subpoenas have been validly been issued because the material which they seek has sufficient adjectival relevance to the issue whether Dr Quach was unable to work due to the cancellation of his medical registration, as opposed to an illness. Ms Oliver’s advice was not binding on MLC. In any event, her advice is not properly characterised as stating that MLC had to accept liability for his claim for total disability. Ms Oliver’s advice on page 8 stated that there was no evidence of psychiatric diagnosis “at this point”, but the balance of her advice indicates that she advised that further medical reports needed to be obtained, including from Dr Pethebridge and Dr St George. Nothing in Ms Oliver’s advice provides a basis for setting aside the subpoenas or revoking leave. Secondly, Dr Quach has misunderstood the relevance and application of Mason J’s judgment in Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; 162 CLR 24 at 45, where he said that decisions must be made on the basis of the most current material available to the decision-maker. That principle is a principle in public law which applies to decision-making by public administrative officials. It has no direct application in a private law case such as the one here. Nor does it have any application to a Judge exercising judicial power, contrary to Dr Quach’s contention. Even if it did, I have explained above why I do not consider Ms Oliver’s advice to MLC to have the effect asserted by Dr Quach.