Director of Public Prosecutions v Scott
[2023] VCC 2041
Citation 1
…R [2021] VSCA 98, Roache v R [2020] VSCA 205 , Arici v R [2019] VSCA 228, DPP v Stewart [2021] VCC 1484 , DPP v Lin [2023] VCC 1677 , DPP v Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372. Sentence: 4 years 1 month imprisonment, 2 years 3 months non-parole period ---…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Lin
[2023] VCC 1677
Citation 2
…wing an early plea, to 14 months' imprisonment and a community correction order imposed for the summary offences. [10] DPP v Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372 62What these two cases demonstrate is that there can be a reasonably wide range of sentences, and that each case invariably turns on its own facts. Other sentences…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Obian
[2020] VCC 915
Citation 3
…[51] [2018] VCC 372 (Judge Gwynn).…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Gayed
[2019] VCC 2174
Citation 4
…r good qualities and of their support. 40I was referred by the defence to two sentences: one, mine, of 2016 in Bowden [2016] VCC 708 and of Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372, both of this court. 41In Bowden the quantity was 18.5 kilograms and four associates, included the accused bought butanediol in bulk. In that case th…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Al-Dimachki
[2019] VCC 1708
Citation 5
…a non-parole period of three years and nine months was imposed. I was also referred to DPP v Richardson [2016] VCC 2014, DPP v Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372 and DPP v Omer [2018] VCC 1401, to which I have also had regard. 125I have had regard to the Sentencing Advisory Council higher court sentencing statistics in re…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Fatho
[2019] VCC 1260
Citation 6
…v R [2017] VSCA 151; Sharbell v R [2017] VCC 1918; Akoka v The Queen [2017] VSCA 214; DPP v Dalgleish (a Pseudonym) [2017] HCA 41; DPP v Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372;; Ellis v R [2018] VSCA 221; DPP v Carron & Gallin [2018] VCC 1469 Sentence: ---…