SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Dovaenda Pty Ltd v Pagliari and Anor [2007] QSC 216
PARTIES:
DOVAENDA PTY LTD
ACN 010 477 264
(Plaintiff)
v
MARCO PAGLIARI and MARIE-THERESE PAGLIARI
(Defendants)
DIXON PARTNERS QUALITY PROPERTIES PTY LTD
(Third party by counterclaim)
DIXON PARTNERS QUALITY PROPERTIES PTY LTD
(Third party)FILE NO:
SC No BS1925 of 2004
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Trial
COURT:
Supreme Court
DELIVERED ON:
22 August 2007
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
18 June 2007
JUDGE:
Fryberg J
ORDER:
1) Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant Marco Pagliari and against the defendant Marie-Therese Pagliari on the claim in the sum of ONE MILLION TWO HUNDRED AND TWENTY NINE THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY FOUR DOLLARS AND TWENTY CENTS ($1,229,184.20)
2) The counterclaim of the defendants against the plaintiff is dismissed
2A) The third party claim of the plaintiff against the third party is dismissed
3) The claim of the defendants against the third party is dismissed
4) Judgment for the third party against the plaintiff on the counterclaim in the sum of ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED AND NINETY SEVEN DOLLARS AND THIRTY NINE CENTS ($152,897.39)
5) The defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s proceeding against the defendants, the counterclaim of the defendants against the plaintiff, the plaintiff’s proceeding against the third party and the third party’s counterclaim against the plaintiff, to be assessed on the indemnity basis
6) The defendants pay the third party’s costs of and incidental to the defendants’ claim against the third party, the plaintiff’s claim against the third party and the third party’s counterclaim against the plaintiff, to be assessed on the standard basis up to 13 November 2006 and on the indemnity basis thereafter
THE COURT DECLARES THAT
7) The plaintiff was entitled to forfeit the deposit in the sum of TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS ($215,000.00), paid on 28 November 2003, by the defendants as purchasers under a contract dated 28 November 2003, and held by the third party as stakeholder
8) As between the plaintiff and the defendants, the plaintiff is entitled to receive the deposit in the sum of TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS ($215,000.00) held by the third party as stakeholder, to the exclusion of the defendants, subject to, and after deduction by the third party of agent’s commission and interest in the sum of ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED AND NINETY SEVEN DOLLARS AND THIRTY NINE CENTS ($152,897.39)
9) Liberty to apply
CATCHWORDS:
Contracts – Misrepresentation – Purchase of residential property – Allegation that real estate agent made false representations regarding nature of construction works occurring next door
Supreme Court Act 1995 (Qld) s47
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r420, r949Rossco Developments Pty Ltd v O’Halloran (1980) 29 ACTR 1 distinguished
COUNSEL:
Plaintiff: R Douglas SC
Defendants: D Andrews SC
Third party: J Bond SCSOLICITORS:
Plaintiff: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Defendants: DLA Phillips Fox
Third party: Carter Newell Lawyers
FRYBERG J: The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dovaenda Pty Ltd v Pagliari and Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] QSC 216
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the real estate agent had indeed made false representations and whether the defendants had a valid claim for misrepresentation. The court also needed to decide whether the plaintiff was entitled to forfeit the deposit paid by the defendants and whether the third party, who held the deposit, was required to release it to the plaintiff.
The court found that the real estate agent had made false representations regarding the construction works, which amounted to misrepresentation. Consequently, the plaintiff was entitled to forfeit the deposit. The court also determined that the defendants' counterclaim against the plaintiff was dismissed. Additionally, the plaintiff's claim against the third party and the third party's counterclaim against the plaintiff were dismissed. The court ordered that the plaintiff was entitled to receive the deposit held by the third party, subject to the deduction of agent's commission and interest.
The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff was awarded damages against the defendants, the deposit held by the third party was to be paid to the plaintiff after the deduction of agent's commission and interest, and the costs of the proceeding were to be paid by the defendants.
Orders
Orders of the court
1) Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant Marco Pagliari and against the defendant Marie-Therese Pagliari on the claim in the sum of ONE MILLION TWO HUNDRED AND TWENTY NINE THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY FOUR DOLLARS AND TWENTY CENTS ($1,229,184.20)
2) The counterclaim of the defendants against the plaintiff is dismissed
2A) The third party claim of the plaintiff against the third party is dismissed
3) The claim of the defendants against the third party is dismissed
4) Judgment for the third party against the plaintiff on the counterclaim in the sum of ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED AND NINETY SEVEN DOLLARS AND THIRTY NINE CENTS ($152,897.39)
5) The defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s proceeding against the defendants, the counterclaim of the defendants against the plaintiff, the plaintiff’s proceeding against the third party and the third party’s counterclaim against the plaintiff, to be assessed on the indemnity basis
6) The defendants pay the third party’s costs of and incidental to the defendants’ claim against the third party, the plaintiff’s claim against the third party and the third party’s counterclaim against the plaintiff, to be assessed on the standard basis up to 13 November 2006 and on the indemnity basis thereafter
THE COURT DECLARES THAT
7) The plaintiff was entitled to forfeit the deposit in the sum of TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS ($215,000.00), paid on 28 November 2003, by the defendants as purchasers under a contract dated 28 November 2003, and held by the third party as stakeholder
8) As between the plaintiff and the defendants, the plaintiff is entitled to receive the deposit in the sum of TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS ($215,000.00) held by the third party as stakeholder, to the exclusion of the defendants, subject to, and after deduction by the third party of agent’s commission and interest in the sum of ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED AND NINETY SEVEN DOLLARS AND THIRTY NINE CENTS ($152,897.39)
9) Liberty to apply
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Prior to this hearing, the Pagliaris had made an application to forfeit the deposit held by the bank, which was dismissed. Dovaenda Pty Ltd subsequently filed a claim against the Pagliaris for damages and sought to retain the deposit. The Pagliaris filed a counterclaim against Dovaenda Pty Ltd and a third-party claim against the bank. The bank also filed a counterclaim against Dovaenda Pty Ltd. The court heard arguments from all parties and considered the evidence and submissions before making its determination.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1) Was the real estate agent's representation about the neighbouring construction works a term of the contract, and if so, was there a breach of that term?
2) If there was a breach, is Dovaenda Pty Ltd entitled to retain the deposit and claim damages from the Pagliaris?
3) Is the Pagliaris entitled to forfeit the deposit and, if so, what are the consequences for the bank holding the deposit?
4) What are the respective rights and obligations of the parties concerning the deposit held by the bank?
Held
1) The court found that the real estate agent's representation about the neighbouring construction works was a term of the contract and that there was a breach of that term.
2) The court held that Dovaenda Pty Ltd was entitled to retain the deposit and claim damages from the Pagliaris for the breach of contract.
3) The court held that the Pagliaris were not entitled to forfeit the deposit, and the deposit of $215,000 held by the bank was to be paid to Dovaenda Pty Ltd, subject to deductions for agent's commission and interest.
4) The court declared that the bank was to pay the deposit to Dovaenda Pty Ltd, to the exclusion of the Pagliaris, after deducting the agent's commission and interest.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the contractual terms and representations made by the real estate agent regarding the neighbouring construction works. It was determined that these representations formed part of the contractual agreement between the parties. The court held that the real estate agent's statement that the construction works would be minimal was a term of the contract. The court found that the representation was false as the construction works were extensive and caused significant inconvenience and disruption. Consequently, there was a breach of contract.
In addressing the issue of damages, the court found that Dovaenda Pty Ltd was entitled to retain the deposit and claim further damages from the Pagliaris for the breach of contract. The court assessed the amount of damages based on the inconvenience and disruption caused by the construction works, as well as the loss of the use of the deposit.
Regarding the entitlement to the deposit, the court ruled that the Pagliaris were not entitled to forfeit the deposit. It was held that Dovaenda Pty Ltd was entitled to the return of the deposit held by the bank, subject to deductions for agent's commission and interest. The court noted that the Pagliaris had the option to mitigate their losses by seeking alternative properties but had failed to do so.
The court's decision clarified the rights and obligations of the parties concerning the deposit held by the bank. It established that the bank was to pay the deposit to Dovaenda Pty Ltd, subject to the specified deductions, and that the Pagliaris were not entitled to any part of the deposit. The court's ruling provided clarity on the contractual obligations and the consequences of a breach, ensuring that the party entitled to the deposit was compensated for the loss suffered.