Douglas v State of Queensland (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Douglas v State of Queensland (No 2) [2006] FCA 1288

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for permanent stay pursuant to O 20 r 2(1)(c) Federal Court Rules – whether abuse of the process of the court – claim relates to the period between 1975 and 1986 – whether by reason of effluxion of time a fair trial is no longer possible – application of the High Court decision in Batistatos v Road Traffic Authority of New South Wales [2006] HCA 27 – whether any useful evidence remains upon which to conduct a trial

DISCRIMINATION – racial discrimination in employment – s 9 and s 15 Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) – whether such fragmentary evidence as exists shows a relationship of employment between the State of Queensland and the applicants – whether further information is available – whether evidence which does exist can be properly explained

Held: Due to the effluxion of time no useful evidence remains by which it could be determined whether the applicants were employees of the respondent in so far as the claimed employment related to the payment by the respondent to the Christian Brethren of grants for the payment of wages which were based on race and resulted in the applicants receiving wages which were at a rate less than that to which they were entitled. The claims under s 9 and s 15 Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth), in so far as they rely on the establishment of this relationship, be stayed as an abuse of process.

Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 46PO, s 46PR
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) s 9, s 15
Federal Court Rules O 20 r 2
Supreme Court Rules (NSW) Pt 13 r 5

Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement Inc v South Australia (No 1) (1995) 64 SASR 551 cited
ACT Visiting Medical Officers Association v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2006] FCAFC 109 cited
Batistatos v Road Traffic Authority of New South Wales [2006] HCA 27 applied
Batistatos v Road Traffic Authority of New South Wales [2004] NSWSC 796 discussed
Cox v Journeaux (No 2) (1935) 52 CLR 713 cited
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) [1964] 112 CLR 125 cited
Hagan v Trustees of the Toowoomba Sports Ground Trust (2001) FCA 123 cited
Herron v McGregor (1986) 6 NSWLR 246 cited
Hunter v Chief Constable of the West Midlands Police (1982) AC 529 cited
Jago v District Court (NSW) (1989) 168 CLR 23 cited
Koowarta v Bjelke-Petersen (1982) 39 ALR 417 cited
Macedonian Teachers’ Association of Victoria Inc v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (1998) 91 FCR 8 cited
Meka v Shell Company Australia Ltd [2005] FMCA 250 cited
Miller v University of New South Wales [2003] FCAFC 180 cited
Newcastle City Council v Batistatos [2005] NSWCA 20 applied
re Queensland Electricity Commission; ex parte Electrical Trades Union of Australia (1987) 72 ALR 1 cited
Reid v New Zealand Trotting Conference [1984] 1 NZLR 8 cited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Douglas v State of Queensland (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Douglas v State of Queensland (No 2), the applicants, who are Aboriginal individuals, are contesting the Queensland Government's alleged racial discrimination in the form of wage disparities during their employment at the Doomadgee Mission between 1975 and 1986. The State of Queensland, as the respondent, is defending against these claims. The central issue before the court was whether the allegations of racial discrimination by the State of Queensland through its payments to the Christian Brethren for the applicants' wages could proceed, or if a permanent stay of the proceedings was appropriate.

The court was tasked with determining the viability of the case, considering the age and health of key witnesses, the availability of documentary evidence, and the potential for an abuse of process due to the passage of time. A significant point of contention was the likelihood of Mr. Allan Hockey, a former senior manager at the Doomadgee Mission, providing evidence, given his advanced age and poor health. The court also needed to assess whether there was sufficient evidence to conduct a meaningful trial or if the proceedings would merely result in a debate based on incomplete information.

After evaluating the submissions and evidence, the court concluded that it would be an abuse of process to allow certain parts of the claim to proceed. The court found that while there were records and documents that could potentially support a trial for the period of direct employment (1975-1986), the claims related to the indirect employment period (1975-1983) through grants paid to the Christian Brethren were less substantiated. Consequently, the court ruled that the applicants' claims regarding indirect employment should be permanently stayed. However, the claims pertaining to direct employment between 1975 and 1986 were allowed to proceed, as the court deemed it unlikely that the passage of time would render the trial an abuse of process.

The final orders of the court were to permanently stay the proceedings brought by the applicants in QUD 279 of 2004 and QUD 389 of 2005 to the extent that the applicants claimed racial discrimination through the payment by the respondent to any manifestation of the Christian Brethren, including the Christian Brethren of Australia Inc, of grants for the payment of the applicants’ wages based on race, resulting in wages at a rate less than that to which they were entitled. The claims relating to the applicants' direct employment with the respondent between 1975 and 1986 were to proceed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceedings brought by each of the applicants in QUD 279 of 2004 and QUD 389 of 2005 be permanently stayed to the extent that the applicants are claiming that the respondent discriminated against each of them pursuant to s 9 and s 15 of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) through the payment by the respondent to any manifestation of the Christian Brethren, including the Christian Brethren of Australia Inc of grants for the payment of the applicants’ wages that were based on race and resulted in the applicants receiving wages which were at a rate less than that to which they were entitled.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Christian Brethren of Australia Inc was not represented before me at the hearing of the notice of motion to which it is a respondent (QUD 279/2004). From information provided in affidavits tendered on behalf of the State of Queensland, including searches of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission database, it is questionable whether such an entity continues to exist. I shall refer in this judgment to the Christian Brethren of Australia Inc, and other relevant manifestations of the Christian Brethren, as ‘the Christian Brethren’.BACKGROUNDHistory of Doomadgee Mission The history of Doomadgee Mission is recounted in the affidavit of Mr Maxwell Smith affirmed 22 May 2006, which is clearly the product of extensive research by Mr Smith and Crown Law. The involvement of the Christian Brethren at the Doomadgee Mission appears to date from the early 1930s. In 1941 an Order of Council was published in the Queensland Government Gazette Vol CLVI, dated 14 June 1941, No 141, p 2181, a copy of which is annexed to the affidavit of Mr Smith. By that Order the Doomadgee Mission was placed under the management and control of the Committee for the Doomadgee Aboriginal Mission pursuant to The Aboriginals Preservation and Protection Act of 1939 (Qld). I understand that the Committee for the Doomadgee Aboriginal Mission was constituted by members of the Christian Brethren. In 1958, Mr Allan Hockey was appointed Acting Superintendent of the Doomadgee Aboriginal Mission Reserve and Protector of Aboriginals assigned to the Aboriginal District comprising the Petty Sessions District of Burke, as from 1 November 1958. Mr Hockey was a member of the Christian Brethren. I understand that Mr Hockey remained in a senior management position until he left Doomadgee on 6 April 1983. Mr Smith has deposed in his affidavit affirmed 22 May 2006 that, following Queensland Government Cabinet Decision 40190 dated 10 May 1983, a progressive take-over commenced by the State of Queensland, of staffing, administration, accountability, servicing and responsibility for the material wellbeing of the Doomadgee Aboriginal Community, from the Christian Brethren. Mr Smith has further deposed that Cabinet Decision 40190 has not yet been released for public scrutiny and is the subject of the privilege afforded cabinet papers. However I do not understand this evidence to be in contention. I note that, as from 1 July 1986, employees of the Department of Community Services at Doomadgee were transferred to the Doomadgee Aboriginal Council.Claims of the applicants In early 2003 FAIRA Aboriginal Corporation lodged complaints on behalf of the applicants with the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (‘HREOC’). A delegate of the President of HREOC terminated the complaint pursuant to s 46PH(2) of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (‘the HREOC Act’). In the substantive matters the applicants have applied under s 46PO HREOC Act for orders including a declaration that the respondent discriminated against each of the applicants pursuant to s 9 and s 15 Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) (‘the Act’); an apology, $500 000 in damages, interest and costs. Their claims relate to the period 1975-1986 when they were allegedly paid wage rates lower than other employees at the time, or lower than the award. The applicants claim that the reason for those lower payments was that they were Aboriginal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Key questions of evidence before the Court, for the purposes of this analysis, may be summarised as follows:1. What is the likelihood of Mr Allan Hockey giving evidence?2. To paraphrase Bryson JA in Batistatos, is there useful evidence available upon which to conduct a trial, or is the position that a trial of the proceedings could not rise above a debate about the effect of scraps of information with the result that no more than a formal enactment of the process of hearing and determining the plaintiff’s claim could take place? This second question should be particularly considered in light of evidence to which the applicants refer, including:a) Records before the Court, as contained in the affidavit of Mr David Sutton sworn 22 November 2005, and the further evidence given by Mr Sutton arising from cross-examination on 17 July 2006.b) The affidavit of Mr Patrick Killoran sworn 12 May 2006.c) Affidavits of Sir Llewellyn Edwards, Hugh Lionel Fawsett and Sir Leo Arthur Hielscher.d) Queensland Government Cabinet documents from the relevant period.e) Affidavits of Bernadette Irene Albert, Evelyn May Barker, Shane Arthur O’Connor, Eric Michael Porter, Maxwell Athol Smith and Paul Toolis.1. WHAT IS THE LIKELIHOOD OF MR ALLAN HOCKEY GIVING EVIDENCE? It is clear that obtaining evidence from Mr Hockey would be very important to the conduct of this case from the perspective of both the applicants and the respondents. Mr Hockey was appointed Acting Superintendent of the Doomadgee Aboriginal Mission Reserve from 1 November 1958. I understand he remained in that management position until some time in 1983, and that he eventually left Doomadgee on 6 April 1983. His management role means that he would be able to give key evidence as to the role of the respondent in the conduct of the Doomadgee Mission over that period, and to explain relevant documents and records from that period. The importance of that evidence is enhanced by the fact that a number of key witnesses involved in the management of Doomadgee mission, and liaison between the Doomadgee Mission and the respondent during the relevant period have died (for example, Mrs Hockey and Mr Bedford), or are elderly, frail and unable to give evidence (for example, Mr Killoran). It is clear however that Mr Hockey himself is now elderly, and in frail health. At the hearing on 14 July 2006 the ability of Mr Allan Hockey to give evidence at a hearing of the substantive matter was in dispute. Counsel for the applicants indicated that he had spoken with a third party who had been in contact with acquaintances of Mr Hockey, and was able to provide evidence that Mr Hockey was capable of giving evidence relevant to the issues in dispute. I indicated that, if this were the case, the best evidence would be that from Mr Hockey himself. I adjourned the hearing to allow the parties the opportunity to contact Mr Hockey and ascertain his ability to give evidence, whether at the hearing itself, by a preservation of evidence hearing, by affidavit or otherwise.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
For these reasons I am also satisfied that it would be an abuse of the process of the Court to allow this part of the claim to proceed.CONCLUSION The respondent in this case has sought a permanent stay of the applicants’ claims in their entirety. However, the submissions of the respondent in respect of these notices of motion have addressed the claimed ‘indirect’ relationship of employment between the respondent and the applicants for the period 1975-1983. This is somewhat curious, given that the claim of the applicants is for the period 1975-1986. I note that from August 1983 there was a transition period during which control of management functions passed from Doomadgee Mission to the Department and then to the Doomadgee Aboriginal Council (Affidavit of Maxwell Athol Smith 22 May 2006 pars 69-72). The respondent has also stated that it ceased paying grants to the Christian Brethren in relation to the conduct of the Doomadgee Mission in August 1983 (Defence par 7(f)). In light of the submissions and the evidence which could be available at trial, it would not be appropriate to permanently stay such of the applicants’ claims as relate to discrimination by the respondent against the applicants in their ‘direct’ employment with the respondent between 1975 and 1986. I do not understand that, given the record-keeping facilities of the State of Queensland and the records which have already been tendered in evidence, effluxion of time would result in a trial on this matter being an abuse of process as articulated in Batistatos. Accordingly, I am not prepared to stay the claimants’ applications to the extent that they claim that the respondent discriminated against each of the applicants pursuant to s 9 and s 15 in their ‘direct’ employment with the respondent between 1975 and 1986. However, for the reasons I have already given, in my view it is appropriate to order a permanent stay of applications in QUD 279/04 and QUD 389/05 to the extent that the applicants are claiming that the respondent discriminated against each of them pursuant to s 9 and s 15 of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) through the respondent’s payment to the Christian Brethren of grants for the payment of the applicants’ wages that were based on race and resulted in the applicants receiving wages which were at a rate less than that to which they were entitled.THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1.The proceedings brought by each of the applicants in QUD 279 of 2004 and QUD 389 of 2005 be permanently stayed to the extent that the applicants are claiming that the respondent discriminated against each of them pursuant to s 9 and s 15 of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) through the payment by the respondent to any manifestation of the Christian Brethren, including the Christian Brethren of Australia Inc of grants for the payment of the applicants’ wages that were based on race and resulted in the applicants receiving wages which were at a rate less than that to which they were entitled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

Full text does not contain this section.