Douglas Ryan, Gary Stuart Heyden & Kenneth Allan Mackenzie v Supreme Protector Ireland Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

ABSTRACTS OF DECISIONS

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 2002213674 in the name of DOUGLAS RYAN, GARY STUART HEYDEN and KENNETH ALLAN MACKENZIE

Title:          Stabilisation of Particulate Material Using Wool Grease

Action:          Request under Section 36 by SUPREME PROTECTOR IRELAND PTY LTD for a declaration regarding entitlement to an invention disclosed.

Decision:          Issued 21 October 2005

Abstract

Request unsuccessful.

Evidence did not establish that the invention of using a surfactant in a wool grease composition came solely from John Shortis (for the requestor) rather than the currently named inventors.  Evidence suggested that at least one of the inventors knew of mixing surfactants and wool grease before contact with Shortis.  While there may be another invention in the actual methods Shortis used in creating the wool fat/surfactant mixtures, this is not relevant to this case.

A suggestion by the requestor to follow the approach advocated in Brisalebe Ltd v Bronwyn Searle [1994] APO 36 and allow an independent party from the Patent Office staff to inspect an earlier, identically-titled provisional application by the same applicants to ascertain whether it contained any reference to surfactants was not followed. If the use of a surfactant was not exemplified in the provisional this does not detract from applicant’s cases, because it is possible that the applicant could not put their inventive idea of using wool fat and a surfactant into practice at that point. While there may be a separate invention in the practical implementation of the idea, the present application concerns the idea itself which properly belongs to the applicant.

Costs according to schedule 8 awarded against Supreme Protector Ireland Pty Ltd.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 2002213674 by DOUGLAS RYAN, GARY STUART HEYDEN and KENNETH ALLAN MACKENZIE and Request under Section 36 by SUPREME PROTECTOR IRELAND PTY LTD for a declaration regarding entitlement to an invention disclosed.

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 2002213674 in the name of Douglas Ryan, Gary Stuart Heyden and Kenneth Allan Mackenzie (hereafter collectively referred to as “RHM”) was filed as PCT application PCT/AU01/01437 on 8 November 2001, claiming no priority.  The application entered the national phase on 7 June 2004.  A request under Section 36 was filed by Supreme Protector (Ireland) Limited (hereafter referred to as “Supreme”) on 28 July 2004.  Following the filing of better and further particulars by Supreme on 28 October 2004, evidence in support was filed by RHM and Supreme by 5 January 2005.  Following exchange of this evidence, evidence in response from each party was received by 8 April 2005, following a one-month extension being given to Supreme.

  2. The hearing was held in Brisbane on 22 July 2005.  Supreme was represented by Bill Anderson, patent attorney of Ahearn Fox, Brisbane.  RHM was represented by Dimitrios Eliades of counsel, assisted by Brendan Nugent, patent attorney of Griffith Hack, Brisbane.

    THE EVIDENCE

  3. The supporting evidence for Supreme (the requestor) consists of a statutory declaration by John Shortis…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Douglas Ryan, Gary Stuart Heyden & Kenneth Allan Mackenzie v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] APO 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian court was tasked with resolving a dispute between the named inventors, Douglas Ryan, Gary Stuart Heyden, and Kenneth Allan Mackenzie, and Supreme Protector Ireland Limited regarding the entitlement to an invention disclosed in a patent application. The patent application, No. 2002213674, concerns a composition for stabilizing particulate material using wool grease and a surfactant. The central issue was whether John Shortis, who was not named as an inventor, was the true inventor of the composition or if the current inventors had independently conceived the idea before any contact with Shortis. The court had to decide if the use of a surfactant in a wool grease composition was solely from Shortis or if it was known to the applicants prior to any interaction with him.

The court meticulously examined the evidence presented by both parties, including declarations and experimental notes, to determine the timeline and origin of the inventive concept. The court found that while Shortis had experience in creating emulsions with wool grease, there was no credible evidence that he was the first to suggest the use of a surfactant in such a composition. The applicants' evidence, particularly from Heyden, indicated that he had been experimenting with wool grease and surfactants well before any interaction with Shortis. The court concluded that the idea for the composition, which was the subject of the patent application, originated with the applicants, not Shortis.

The court also considered whether Supreme's request to inspect an earlier provisional application filed by the applicants could be relevant. However, the court ruled that the content of the provisional application was not pertinent to the determination of who conceived the idea for the composition disclosed in the current application. The court emphasized that the invention in question was the idea itself, not the practical implementation of that idea.

The court's decision was that Supreme Protector Ireland Limited's request for a declaration of entitlement to the invention was unsuccessful. The evidence did not support the claim that Shortis was the originator of the inventive concept. Consequently, the court awarded costs against Supreme Protector Ireland Limited as per the schedule.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established