Douglas and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Douglas and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2022] AATA 2415 (1 August 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/4716

Re:Donald Douglas

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Date:1 August 2022

Place:Sydney

The 7 June 2022 stay application is refused

.....................................[Sgd]...................................

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Catchwords

Self Managed Superannuation Fund – non-compliance with relevant standards – disqualification as approved Self Managed Superannuation Fund auditor – stay of disqualification decision pending appeal

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth)
Corporate Law Economic Reform Program (Audit Reform and Corporate Disclosure) Act 2004 (Cth)
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCAFC 185; (2009) 181 FCR 130
Re Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798; (2009) 51 AAR 114
Levi v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board  [2013] FCA 719
Secretary Department of Social Services and McNamara [2016] AATA 189

Allied Asia Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2002] FCA 566

Secondary Materials

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994

Guidance Statement “GS 009 Auditing Self Managed Superannuation Funds”, September 2015

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

1 August 2022

  1. Mr Douglas became registered as an approved Self Managed Superannuation Fund (“SMSF”) auditor in August 2013. On 24 February 2022, in the exercise of the power conferred by s 130F(2) of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (the “SIS Act”), ASIC disqualified Mr Douglas from being an approved SMSF auditor. The disqualification decision took effect from 3 March 2022. On 26 April 2022, after an internal review process, ASIC confirmed its disqualification decision.

  2. ASIC’s disqualification decision was principally, though not exclusively, based on criticism of Mr Douglas conduct in relation to the audit of three SMSFs.  ASIC’s determinative findings are outlined later in these reasons:-  see paragraphs ‎23 to ‎28 below.

  3. On 7 June 2022 Mr Douglas lodged his review application with the Tribunal.  At the same time, he sought an extension of time, and a stay of the disqualification decision.  ASIC does not dispute the appropriateness of extending time to regularise Mr Douglas’ review application, but it does oppose any stay of its disqualification decision.

    THE TRIBUNAL’S STAY POWER

  4. The Tribunal has the power to stay the operation or implementation of a reviewable decision, to the extent that it considers appropriate, “for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review”:-  Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (“AAT”) s 41(2).  The power permits the Tribunal to impose conditions upon, and to determine the period of any stay:-  AAT Act s 41(6). Exercise of the discretionary power is preconditioned on the Tribunal taking into account “the interests of any persons who may be affected by the review”.

  5. The determinative criterion for the exercise of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Douglas and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Douglas for a stay of a decision by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to disqualify him as an approved Self-Managed Superannuation Fund (SMSF) auditor. The dispute arose from ASIC's criticisms of Mr Douglas' audit conduct, which included allegations of inadequate planning, insufficient documentary substantiation, and a lack of awareness or compliance with current accounting standards. Mr Douglas sought the stay pending his appeal against the disqualification decision.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether to grant a stay of ASIC's disqualification decision. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the grounds advanced by Mr Douglas, primarily financial hardship, were sufficient to enliven the stay power under section 41 of the AAT Act. The Tribunal also had to assess whether, in the exercise of its discretion, a stay was desirable, taking into account the public interest and the likely imminence of the substantive hearing.

The Tribunal noted that Mr Douglas had implicitly acknowledged some of ASIC's criticisms, having indicated in prior responses that he was establishing permanent files for audit clients and relying on an outdated accounting publication. However, the Tribunal found that Mr Douglas had provided no substantial explanation for several other specific criticisms, including the absence of audit file confirmations, failure to obtain trustee representation letters or signed financial statements, and non-compliance with reporting requirements. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Douglas' grounds for seeking a stay were insubstantial and unpersuasive.

The Tribunal therefore refused to grant the stay of the disqualification decision, finding that the application was not supported by sufficient grounds and that it was not desirable to grant a stay in the circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The procedural reforms on which Mr Douglas relies appear to be (i) the establishment of a “permanent” file for each audit client (see paragraph ‎36 below), (ii) the implementation of “checklists” to ensure compliance with audit standards. (The former assertion was part of Mr Douglas’ March 2020 submissions to the ATO. The latter assertion was made (apparently for the first time) in Mr Douglas’ June 2022 affidavit.)ASIC’S OPPOSITION TO A STAY OF THE DISQUALIFICATION DECISION ASIC interprets Mr Douglas stay submissions as effectively limited to reliance on the asserted financial hardship said to be occasioned by the continued operation of the disqualification decision. On that basis, ASIC disputes that the stay power in AAT Act s 41 has been enlivened. Alternatively, ASIC submits that the limited evidence and submissions advanced by Mr Douglas do not conduce to satisfaction that a stay is “desirable”. ASIC contends that the discretionary stay power should be exercised, in the circumstances of the present matter (including the likely imminence of a substantive hearing) with primary regard to the public interest.CONSIDERATION One aspect of ASIC’s criticisms of Mr Douglas’ audit conduct relate to inadequate planning for, and documentary substantiation of the audit process. Mr Douglas must be taken to have implicitly acknowledged the appropriateness of at least part of those criticisms. This is because his March 2020 responses to the ATO’s “Position Paper” asserted he was in the process of establishing a “permanent file” for each SMSF audit client. The contents of each permanent file would include the essential details of each fund (including the trust deed and a history of members entitlements) together with a summary of relevant statutory and accounting requirements. Another aspect of ASIC’s criticisms was Mr Douglas’ lack of awareness, or at least lack of compliance with, current accounting standards. Mr Douglas must also be taken to accept the validity of that criticism. This is because, in his March 2020 responses, he indicated that he relied on a publication of the Australian Accounting Research Foundation. That 1997 publication could not have referred to the statutorily stipulated accounting standards applicable during the period from 2013 to 2022 (ie., the duration of Mr Douglas’s SMSF auditor registration) and appears (because of its date) unlikely to have provided an “acceptable” equivalent prescription. Apart from the limited concessions that are implicit in Mr Douglas’ March 2020 responses, and the asserted availability of material additional information, Mr Douglas has provided no explanation of, or for, some aspects of the conduct underlying ASIC’s criticisms. Those aspects include:-(a)The absence of audit file confirmation of enquiries sufficient to establish the SMSF eligibility of the three audited funds(b)The failure to obtain trustee representation letters or signed financial statements for the three SMSF’s(c)The failure to provide an audit report in the approved form(d)The failure to obtain (or at least document) market valuations(e)The failure to obtain the investment strategy of each SMSF(f)The failure to obtain (or at least to record examination of) the SMSF minutes.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

ASIC interprets Mr Douglas stay submissions as effectively limited to reliance on the asserted financial hardship said to be occasioned by the continued operation of the disqualification decision. On that basis, ASIC disputes that the stay power in AAT Act s 41 has been enlivened. Alternatively, ASIC submits that the limited evidence and submissions advanced by Mr Douglas do not conduce to satisfaction that a stay is “desirable”. ASIC contends that the discretionary stay power should be exercised, in the circumstances of the present matter (including the likely imminence of a substantive hearing) with primary regard to the public interest.CONSIDERATION One aspect of ASIC’s criticisms of Mr Douglas’ audit conduct relate to inadequate planning for, and documentary substantiation of the audit process. Mr Douglas must be taken to have implicitly acknowledged the appropriateness of at least part of those criticisms. This is because his March 2020 responses to the ATO’s “Position Paper” asserted he was in the process of establishing a “permanent file” for each SMSF audit client. The contents of each permanent file would include the essential details of each fund (including the trust deed and a history of members entitlements) together with a summary of relevant statutory and accounting requirements. Another aspect of ASIC’s criticisms was Mr Douglas’ lack of awareness, or at least lack of compliance with, current accounting standards. Mr Douglas must also be taken to accept the validity of that criticism. This is because, in his March 2020 responses, he indicated that he relied on a publication of the Australian Accounting Research Foundation. That 1997 publication could not have referred to the statutorily stipulated accounting standards applicable during the period from 2013 to 2022 (ie., the duration of Mr Douglas’s SMSF auditor registration) and appears (because of its date) unlikely to have provided an “acceptable” equivalent prescription. Apart from the limited concessions that are implicit in Mr Douglas’ March 2020 responses, and the asserted availability of material additional information, Mr Douglas has provided no explanation of, or for, some aspects of the conduct underlying ASIC’s criticisms. Those aspects include:-(a)The absence of audit file confirmation of enquiries sufficient to establish the SMSF eligibility of the three audited funds(b)The failure to obtain trustee representation letters or signed financial statements for the three SMSF’s(c)The failure to provide an audit report in the approved form(d)The failure to obtain (or at least document) market valuations(e)The failure to obtain the investment strategy of each SMSF(f)The failure to obtain (or at least to record examination of) the SMSF minutes. Against the background of the substance of ASIC’s criticisms, the concessions that are implicit in Mr Douglas’ (to date) limited responses, and the absence, in the presently available material, of any substance response to ASIC’s criticisms, Mr Douglas’ stay application relies on insubstantial and unpersuasive grounds. In those circumstances it is not necessary, and hence not desirable, to express a concluded view about ASIC’s contention that the Tribunal’s stay power has not even been enlivened by the matters (principally the assertion of financial hardship) on which Mr Douglas has relied.