Dos Santos v C Morris Painting & Decorating & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      DOS SANTOS v C MORRIS PAINTING & DECORATING & ANOR [2006]  NSWCA 54

FILE NUMBER(S):
40980/2004

HEARING DATE(S):               9 December 2005

DECISION DATE:     24/03/2006

PARTIES:
Wagner DOS SANTOS
C MORRIS PAINTING & DECORATING & Anor

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Giles JA McColl JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 4718/2003

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Garling DCJ

COUNSEL:
Appellant: H Kelly SC/ D Shoebridge
Respondents: K P Rewell SC

SOLICITORS:
Appellant: Taylor & Scott
Respondents: Dibbs Barker Gosling

CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE – Motor vehicle accidents – Failure to indicate when changing lanes – Driver thereby negligent.
NEGLIGENCE – Contributory negligence – Motor vehicle accidents – Cyclist riding in clearway during parking times – Collision with motor vehicle looking for parking space – Cyclist guilty of contributory negligence.  (D) 

LEGISLATION CITED:
Australian Road Rules 46
Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999, s 138

DECISION:
Appeal and cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40980/2004

MASON P
GILES JA
McCOLL JA

Friday 24 March 2006

Wagner DOS SANTOS v C MORRIS PAINTING & DECORATING & Anor

NEGLIGENCE – Motor vehicle accidents – Failure to indicate when changing lanes – Driver thereby negligent

NEGLIGENCE – Contributory negligence – Motor vehicle accidents – Cyclist riding in clearway during parking times – Collision with motor vehicle looking for parking space – Cyclist guilty of contributory negligence

HELD:

(1)There will be occasions when it is not reasonable, in regard to one’s own safety, to allow no margin of safety for the mistakes or carelessness of others (at [43]).

Municipal Tramways Trust v Ashby [1951] SASR 61 at 64, applied.

(2)What is unreasonable is a question of fact dependent on the particular circumstances (at [43]).

Sibley v Kais (1967) 118 CLR 424, applied.

(3)(Per Mason P and Giles JA; McColl JA dissenting) The cyclist was guilty of contributory negligence.

ORDERS:            Appeal and cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40980/2004

MASON P
GILES JA
McCOLL JA

Friday 24 March 2006

Wagner DOS SANTOS v C MORRIS PAINTING & DECORATING & Anor

JUDGMENT

  1. MASON P:           The appellant was riding his bicycle westerly along Foveaux Street, Surrey Hills at about 2:30 pm on 29 July 2000.  Weather conditions were fine.  Approximately 50 metres west of the intersection of Foveaux Street and Riley Street, he collided with a Ford utility with a canopy on the back that was owned by the first respondent and driven by the second respondent.

  2. Proceedings in the District Court heard by Garling DCJ resulted in a verdict for the appellant.  Damages were assessed at $484,571, there being a reduction of 20 per cent for contributory negligence.

  3. The appellant has appealed against the finding of contributory negligence.  The respondents have cross-appealed against the finding of negligence, contending in the alternative that the 20 per cent reduction for contributory negligence was manifestly inadequate.

  4. Foveaux Street has four lanes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dos Santos v C Morris Painting & Decorating & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal and cross-appeal arising from a motor vehicle accident involving a cyclist, the appellant, and a driver, the second respondent, employed by the first respondent. The dispute centred on the circumstances of a collision between the cyclist and the driver, who was seeking a parking space. The case was heard in the appellate court, reviewing the findings of the primary judge.

The legal issues before the court were whether the driver was negligent in failing to indicate when changing lanes and whether the cyclist was guilty of contributory negligence by riding in a clearway during parking times and colliding with the driver's vehicle. The court was required to determine if the primary judge's findings of negligence and contributory negligence were justified based on the established facts.

The court upheld the primary judge's findings. It reasoned that the driver was negligent for failing to indicate before changing lanes, failing to keep a proper lookout for cyclists in the left-hand lane, and executing an unsafe lane change. The court also found the cyclist contributorily negligent, assessing their contribution at 20 per cent. This finding was based on the cyclist's decision to ride in the left-hand lane, where cars were parked, at a speed of approximately 20 km/h, while a vehicle ahead was clearly looking for parking. The court held that in such circumstances, the cyclist should have been aware that the vehicle might turn into a parking spot without indicating, and therefore had an obligation to take greater care for their own safety. The appeal and cross-appeal were dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal and cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The primary findings relevant to both negligence and contributory negligence included (Red 30-1, 33):(i)The appellant was riding along the edge of the number one lane travelling at about 20 km/h at the time of the accident;(ii)The second respondent was travelling slowly in the number 2 lane looking for a parking spot;(iii)The second respondent turned from lane 2 into lane 1 to enter a parking spot not expecting there to be a bike travelling in the left-hand lane where there were parked cars and without first checking if a cyclist was in lane 1;(iv)When the second respondent turned into lane 1 the appellant was less than 3 metres from the defendant’s vehicle and it was too late to take evasive action; and(v)The second respondent failed to indicate before moving from lane two to lane one.Trial judge’s conclusions as to negligence and contributory negligence Judge Garling proceeded from the primary findings to the inferred or evaluative conclusion that the second respondent was negligent. The conclusion of negligence was based on the respondent’s failure to signal before he changed lanes; his failure to keep a proper lookout for vehicles travelling in the first lane, including bikes, who were entitled to be there; and his failure to change lanes safely. His Honour explained the finding of contributory negligence in the following terms:If a bike rider, in my view, wishes to ride down the left-hand lane of four where there are cars parked in that lane at a speed of about 20 kilometres per hour where a vehicle in front of him is travelling slowly and clearly looking for a parking place then that bike rider, in my view, should be aware that the vehicle may turn into a parking place and may turn without indicating because the driver would not have suspected that a bike rider would be coming down a left lane which had cars parked on it. That, in my view, puts an obligation upon the bike rider to take care for his own safety and to ride in a safe manner. I do not believe he did it on this occasion and I believe he contributed to this accident and I assess that contribution at twenty per cent.Cross-appeal as to negligence finding It is convenient to address the cross-appeal first. The respondents submit that a finding of negligence was unjustified, especially since the correct finding of primary fact should have been that the left indicator was displayed. The cross-appeal seeks to build on the finding as to contributory negligence that the van was “travelling slowly and clearly looking for a parking space”. [This inference as to the clearly apparent intentions of the second respondent is squarely challenged in the appeal itself, but I shall for the moment assume its correctness.] Next, the cross-appellant challenges as “glaringly improbable” the trial judge’s rejection of aspects of Sergeant Keir’s evidence. In part, the challenge relates to matters of detail concerning the exact point of impact on the van; whether the second respondent had stopped at the lights in the group that included the appellant and Sergeant Keir; and whether the second respondent got well ahead of the appellant before the appellant caught up with him and collided. These were ultimately peripheral matters, as the trial judge effectively acknowledged at Red 30. After all, the collision did occur, and at a point only about 50 metres down from the Riley Street intersection. These details do not bear upon the primary facts that were found and that, with one exception, are not in issue in the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.