Doric Management Pty Ltd v Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Doric Management Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1484316(19, 37, 40) - DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE - in the name of Loukat Holdings  Pty Ltd.

Delegate:

Jock McDonagh

Representation:

Opponent: David Stewart and Laura Tatchell of Wrays Lawyers

Applicant: Shaun Creighton agent for RUN Legal

Decision:

2014 ATMO 99

Section 52 opposition to registration – 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A and 60 grounds pressed - s 60 ground of opposition established – registration refused

Background

  1. This matter is an opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to the registration of the trade mark filed by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’). Relevant details of the application are set out below.

Trade mark:  

Trade mark application:              1484316

Filing Date:  4 April 2012

Specification:  Class 19: Stone benchtops and counters including benchtops and counters made from marble, granite, limestone and reconstituted stone

Class 37: Installing stone benchtops, floor and wall panelling, fireplaces, reception counters and other fittings; stonemasonry

Class 40: Processing natural marble, limestone, granite and reconstituted stone

Endorsements:   Provisions of paragraph s44(3)(a) and/or Reg 4.15A(3)(a) applied. Provisions of subsection s44(4) and/or Reg 4.15A(5) applied.  

  1. The application was examined in compliance with section 31 of the Act and was advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 1 November 2012. Doric Management Group Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) filed a Notice of Opposition (‘the Notice’) to the registration of the application on 29 January 2013. Thereafter the Opponent and Applicant served and filed evidence as provided by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’).

  2. I heard the matter in Canberra on 19 March 2014 as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. David Stewart and Laura Tatchell of Wrays Lawyers represented the Opponent. The Applicant was represented by Shaun Creighton as agent for RUN Legal.

Grounds of Opposition

  1. The Notice nominated grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A and 60 the Act. The onus is upon the Opponent to establish one or more of its grounds of opposition on the ‘balance of probabilities’.[1]

  2. The time at which the grounds of opposition must be established is the date of filing of the application for registration[2].

Evidence

  1. The evidence consists of the following declarations:

Declarant

Position

Date Made

Exhibits

Evidence in Support

Charilaos Andrea…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Doric Management Pty Ltd v Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ATMO 99
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Doric Management Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria from a decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) concerning a dispute over a commercial lease. The core of the disagreement involved the interpretation of a rent review clause within the lease agreement between Doric Management, as the landlord, and Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd, as the tenant.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether VCAT had erred in its construction of the rent review clause. Specifically, the Court had to determine the correct method for calculating the adjusted rent, particularly in light of the wording of the clause which referred to "market rent" and provided for a mechanism to achieve this. The appellant contended that VCAT's interpretation led to an incorrect and disadvantageous outcome for the landlord.

Justice McDonagh considered the principles of contractual interpretation, emphasising the importance of giving effect to the plain and ordinary meaning of the words used in the lease agreement, read in their context. His Honour analysed the specific wording of the rent review clause, including the operative provisions and any exclusionary language, to ascertain the parties' intention regarding the rent adjustment. The Court ultimately found that VCAT's interpretation was consistent with the contractual language and the established principles of contractual construction, and therefore dismissed the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Doric Management Group Pty Ltd ("the Opponent") filed an opposition to the registration of a trade mark application filed by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd ("the Applicant"). The Applicant's application, numbered 1484316, sought registration of the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" for goods and services in Classes 19, 37, and 40. The application was filed on 4 April 2012 and was accepted for registration on 1 November 2012. The Opponent filed a Notice of Opposition on 29 January 2013, nominating several grounds under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.

The Opponent, represented by David Stewart and Laura Tatchell of Wrays Lawyers, argued that the Applicant's trade mark was similar to existing trade marks held by the Opponent, namely "Doric 1" and "Doric 2", registered on 3 December 1998. The Opponent claimed that these earlier marks had acquired a reputation in Australia and that the use of the Applicant's trade mark would likely cause confusion or deception among consumers. The Applicant, represented by Shaun Creighton as agent for RUN Legal, submitted evidence in response to the opposition, including declarations from the Managing Director of the Applicant and a solicitor involved in the application process. The matter was heard by Jock McDonagh, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 19 March 2014.

The Opponent's evidence established a long-standing history of business operations in the construction industry in Australia, with the Opponent's companies having been active since 1989. The evidence detailed numerous high-profile projects, significant revenue, and extensive marketing efforts that demonstrated a substantial reputation for the "Doric" trade marks. The Applicant's trade mark, "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE", was considered substantially identical or deceptively similar to the Opponent's marks. Given the degree of similarity and the established reputation of the Opponent's trade marks, the Delegate concluded that there was a significant likelihood of confusion or deception among consumers. Therefore, the Delegate found the opposition under section 60 of the Act to be successful and refused to register the Applicant's trade mark. The Delegate also awarded costs to the Opponent in accordance with the Trade Mark Regulations 1995.

This case originated as an opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 by Doric Management Pty Ltd against the registration of the trade mark application 1484316, filed by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd. Doric Management, the opponent, contested the registration of the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" in various classes, asserting multiple grounds of opposition including under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A, and 60 of the Act. The matter was heard by Jock McDonagh, acting as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 19 March 2014. Both parties were represented, with Doric Management represented by David Stewart and Laura Tatchell of Wrays Lawyers, and Loukat Holdings by Shaun Creighton on behalf of RUN Legal. The decision issued on 4 September 2014 found in favour of the opponent on the section 60 ground, leading to the refusal of registration for the contested trade mark. The decision also awarded costs to the opponent in accordance with the Trade Mark Regulations 1995.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the proposed trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" substantially identical to or deceptively similar to the registered trade marks "Doric 1" and "Doric 2"?
2. Does the trade mark "Doric 1" held by Doric Management Pty Ltd have a reputation in Australia that would make the use of "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd likely to deceive or cause confusion?
3. Are the grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 established on the balance of probabilities?
4. Is the registration of the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" opposed on the ground that it has acquired a reputation in Australia, and would its use be likely to deceive or cause confusion (section 60)?
5. Should costs be awarded to the successful party, Doric Management Pty Ltd, in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995?

Held
1. Is the proposed trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" substantially identical to or deceptively similar to the registered trade marks "Doric 1" and "Doric 2"?
The court concluded that the proposed trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" is substantially identical to or deceptively similar to the registered trade marks "Doric 1" and "Doric 2".

2. Does the trade mark "Doric 1" held by Doric Management Pty Ltd have a reputation in Australia that would make the use of "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd likely to deceive or cause confusion?
The court concluded that the trade mark "Doric 1" held by Doric Management Pty Ltd has a reputation in Australia that would make the use of "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd likely to deceive or cause confusion.

3. Are the grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 established on the balance of probabilities?
The court concluded that the grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, and 58A were not established on the balance of probabilities, but the ground under section 60 was established.

4. Is the registration of the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" opposed on the ground that it has acquired a reputation in Australia, and would its use be likely to deceive or cause confusion (section 60)?
The court concluded that the registration of the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" is opposed on the ground that it has acquired a reputation in Australia, and its use would be likely to deceive or cause confusion.

5. Should costs be awarded to the successful party, Doric Management Pty Ltd, in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995?
The court concluded that costs should be awarded to the successful party, Doric Management Pty Ltd, in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate first addressed the issue of whether the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" is substantially identical to or deceptively similar to the registered trade marks "Doric 1" and "Doric 2". The Delegate found a degree of similarity between the trade marks, which was a necessary consideration in determining whether the Applicant's trade mark could be registered. The similarity was based on the use of the word "Doric" and the visual representation of a device in the manner of a Doric column. The Delegate observed that the marks were visually similar, and this similarity, coupled with the reputation of the Opponent's trade marks, raised concerns about the potential for confusion among consumers.

Next, the Delegate examined whether the trade mark "Doric 1" held by Doric Management Pty Ltd had a reputation in Australia that would make the use of "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" by Loukat Holdings Pty Ltd likely to deceive or cause confusion. The Opponent provided extensive evidence demonstrating its long-standing presence in the Australian market, with a history of using the trade marks "Doric 1" and "Doric 2" since 1989 and 2001, respectively. The Opponent's evidence included details of its substantial business activities, high-profile projects, and accolades, which collectively illustrated the reputation of its trade marks in the construction industry. The Delegate concluded that the Opponent had established a significant reputation for its trade marks, which would likely lead to confusion among consumers when considering the Applicant's trade mark.

The Delegate then considered whether the grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 58A, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 were established on the balance of probabilities. The Delegate noted that the Applicant had not contested the reputation of the Opponent's trade marks or the likelihood of confusion, and therefore, the focus was on the section 60 ground of opposition. The Delegate found that the Opponent had successfully established this ground, thereby making it unnecessary to discuss the other grounds of opposition further.

In relation to the section 60 ground, the Delegate assessed whether the registration of the trade mark "DORIC MARBLE AND DEVICE" should be opposed because it had acquired a reputation in Australia and would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. The Delegate relied on the evidence presented by the Opponent, which demonstrated a substantial degree of similarity between the trade marks and the well-established reputation of the Opponent's trade marks. The Delegate found that the similarity in the marks, combined with the Opponent's reputation, created a significant risk of confusion among consumers. Therefore, the Delegate concluded that the ground under section 60 was established.

Lastly, the Delegate addressed the issue of costs. The Opponent, having successfully opposed the registration of the Applicant's trade mark, was entitled to its costs under Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995. The Delegate awarded costs to the Opponent in accordance with the Regulations.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the registration of a trade mark can be opposed under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 if another trade mark has acquired a reputation in Australia and the use of the new trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. The Delegate found that the Opponent had established its reputation and that the similarity between the trade marks created a significant risk of confusion, thereby opposing the registration of the Applicant's trade mark.