Dooley and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Dooley and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department [2022] AATA 3027 (15 September 2022)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2021/5561

Re:Gerard Anthony Dooley

APPLICANT

AndSecretary, Attorney-General's Department

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

Date:15 September 2022

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Secretary for recalculation of Mr Dooley’s redundancy entitlement in accordance with paragraph 57 of these reasons.

..................................[sgd].................................

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

Catchwords

Redundancy payment – employee termination by insolvency – governing instrument – enterprise agreement – separate agreements governing rates of redundancy pay – so-called Grand Chapel Agreement - whether consistent with existing enterprise agreement – governing instrument found to be enterprise agreement, subject to Grand Chapel Agreement – decision under review set aside and remitted

Legislation

Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Cases

Hill, in the matter of Ovato Limited (Administrators Appointed) [2022] FCA 903
In the matter of Ovato Print Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1882

REASONS FOR DECISION

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

15 September 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth) (the FEG Act) provides financial assistance in the form of a monetary advance to eligible employees who have lost their employment because of the insolvency or bankruptcy of their employer, and who are owed employee entitlements which are not able to be paid by their employer or from other sources. Mr Dooley is such a person.

  2. Mr Dooley was employed by Ovato Print Pty Ltd (Ovato Print),[1] a company in the Ovato Group (Ovato), one of two major integrated printing and distribution businesses in Australia and New Zealand.[2] Ovato Print was one of the four Ovato companies[3] wound up on 29 December 2020, pursuant to a creditors and members’ scheme of arrangement approved by the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 21 December 2020.[4] The scheme anticipated that the liquidation of Ovato Print would leave insufficient funds to cover employee entitlements, because assets were to be transferred to other companies in Ovato as part of the scheme.

    [1] Ovato Print was previously called PMP Print Pty Ltd (PMP Print), and changed its name on 6 February 2019, having merged with the printing businesses of IPMG in 2017: T10, 397. Public source information suggests that PMP merged with the Hannan family company IPMG in 2017, which was then rebranded Ovato, and the Hannans became the largest shareholder: Print 21, ‘Hannans to up stake in Ovato’ (Web page) 22 May 2019 <

    [2] Ovato provides services including the printing of catalogues for well-known national businesses, the printing of promotional materials, custom product packaging and direct marketing: Hill, in the matter of Ovato Limited (Administrators Appointed) [2022] FCA 903, per Stewart J at [2].

    [3] The scheme foreshadowed the winding up of Ovato Print; Hannanprint NSW Pty Ltd; Hannanprint Victoria PtyLtd; and Inprint Pty Ltd: In the matter of Ovato Print Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dooley and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 3027
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Dooley against a decision by the Secretary of the Attorney-General's Department regarding his redundancy payment. The dispute arose from the termination of Mr Dooley's employment due to insolvency, and the interpretation of the governing instrument for his redundancy pay. The case was heard by Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the correct governing instrument for calculating Mr Dooley's redundancy entitlement. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether a separate agreement, referred to as the "Grand Chapel Agreement" (GCA), was consistent with and should be applied in conjunction with the existing enterprise agreement. The Tribunal also needed to assess the evidence presented regarding the existence and terms of the GCA.

The Tribunal found that the GCA was indeed a relevant and binding agreement, intended to improve the financial position of the company and its employees during a period of corporate restructuring. The Senior Member rejected the suggestion that there was insufficient evidence of the GCA, relying on minutes filed by the Respondent which detailed specific agreed points concerning staff entitlements, including redundancy calculations. The Tribunal reasoned that the purpose of the scheme of arrangement and the enterprise agreement was to reduce employee entitlements to make the company more viable, and that the GCA represented an explicit promise made to the workforce.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review. The matter was remitted to the Secretary for a recalculation of Mr Dooley's redundancy entitlement, to be conducted in accordance with paragraph 57 of the Tribunal's reasons, which incorporated the principles derived from the GCA.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In approving the scheme of arrangement, Black J. anticipated that a heavy burden would fall on the FEG scheme. These findings will not alleviate that load. I am however certain that a reasonable taxpayer would not complain about shouldering such a burden, if fully acquainted with the explicit promise made to the workforce of which Mr Dooley was a part. I also recognise that this decision will give Mr Dooley less than he claims but more than the Respondent concedes. CONCLUSION The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Secretary for recalculation of Mr Dooley’s redundancy entitlement in accordance with paragraph 57 of these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the same document he rejected the suggestion that there was insufficient evidence of the GCA, noting the minutes filed by the Respondent in these proceedings which states: ‘The Grand Chapel appreciated the update then we moved onto NSW specific issues. To help deal with concerns around staff waiting for answers about their future and to assist them with their decisions, The Chapel requested staff be provided a note from Lorraine Cassin and Adrian O’Connor covering the following;1There will be no change to hourly rates for staff moving from MK to a like role at WF. (Agreed)2Any MK staff that move to WF will have their redundancy calculation at the time of transfer grandfathered. This was designed to deal with staff who had worked on night shift for many years at MK and changed shift when moving to WF which would reduce value of redundancy (Agreed)3The company only take volunteers for the first phase of redundancies when Press F closes, i.e. no forced redundancies for phase 1 provided there are enough volunteers. (Not agreed – we would need to consider the volunteers and potential skills lost before confirming)4If WF staff are asked to move temporarily to MK to backfill positions, the company commit to not forcing redundancies on these staff within the scope of this restructure. (Agreed)5The company will provide staff with detail on phase 2 by June 30, 2019. This will include: what position and shift they will have and if no position is available, an understanding of when the redundancy is likely to take place. (Information agreed, date it can be made available to be confirmed).Next steps are for the AMWU to draft the above for comment and review before we share more widely. Please therefore keep this confidential until this has occurred.’[46][46] T18.2, 483.CONSIDERATION There seems little doubt that the whole purpose of the scheme of arrangement and the 2020 EA was to improve the financial position of the scheme companies and Ovato as a whole, by a reduction of debt and employee entitlements, making Ovato financially viable or, at the least, a more attractive proposition for potential buyers of the group entities, whether sold together or in separate bits. The scheme was intended to save a large corporate enterprise that was in danger of collapse. Unfortunately, the measures taken in 2020-21 were not sufficient, and on 21 July 2022, Ovato Limited (the group holding company) was placed into voluntary administration.[47] It is an unfortunate outcome for a major ASX listed company, especially for those employees who might lose their jobs or were previously made redundant. [47] See Hill, in the matter of Ovato Limited (Administrators Appointed) [2022] FCA 903, per Stewart J, at [3]. The corporate restructure had the specific purpose of excising parts of the business and placing accumulated liabilities such as employee entitlements onto the taxpayer via the FEG Act. The Supreme Court’s rationale in approving the scheme is that it was the lesser of two evils.