Donohoe -v- Havelock Housing Association

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

Donohoe v Havelock Housing Association; McGough v Havelock Housing Association

[2007] ACTRTT 1

CATCHWORDS:

Market rent

Rebated rent

Rent increases

Capacity to pay

Community Housing

ISSUES:

Whether “rent” is the rebated rent or the market rent.

Tenants capacity to pay as a relevant factor in rent increases

Community Housing, its history and role in rent increases

LEGISLATION:

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 sections 3A, 68(3)

Prescribed terms:35

Housing Assistance Act 1987 section 11A, 11B, 12, 15

Public Housing Rental Assistance Program.

Residential Tenancies Act 1987 (NSW) section 47A, 48

CASES CITED:

Progressive Mailing House P/L v Tabali 1985 157 CLR 17;In the Estate of Tanya Humphries v Commissioner for Housing 2003 ACTSC 40

Kilpatrick v Gresser (unreported SC NSW 13 May 1987)

Residential Tenancy Law and Practice (1983) Bradbrook, MacCallum and Moore pp119-122; Residential Tenancies laws and Practice Lang 2nd ed pp1-4

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:     RT 1772 of 2005

Donohoe -v- Havelock Housing Association

RE: Premises at 79 Wakefield Gardens AINSLIE ACT 2602

________________________________________________________________________

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:     RT 1774 of 2005

McGough -v- Havelock Housing Association

RE: Premises at 10a Suttor Street AINSLIE ACT 2602

IN THE RESIDENTIAL       )            

TENANCIES TRIBUNAL    )  ACTRTT1 [2007]

OF THE AUSTRALIAN       )  

CAPITAL TERRITORY       )

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:     RT 1772 of 2005

Donohoe -v- Havelock Housing Association

RE: Premises at 79 Wakefield Gardens AINSLIE ACT 2602

________________________________________________________________________

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:     RT 1774 of 2005

McGough -v- Havelock Housing Association

RE: Premises at 10a Suttor Street AINSLIE ACT 2602

CORRECTION OF ERROR

Member:         Allan Anforth

Date:                 24 January 2007

Correction:

Pursuant to section 102(2)(c) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 the decision of the Tribunal in these proceedings dated 10 January 2007 is amended as follows:

Order 1 should read:

1.In the case of Brigid Donohoe, both the market rent and the rebated rent are fixed at $242.50 per week commencing 1 January 2006;

Member

Residential Tenancies Tribunal

DECISION

ORDERS

  1. In the case of Brigid Donohoe, both the market rent and the rebated rent are fixed at $242.50 per week;

  2. In the case of Janie McGough the application is dismissed.

Member:           A. Anforth

Date:                  10 January 2007

REASONS FOR DECISION

The matter of Brigid Donohoe:

  1. Ms Donohoe is the tenant of 79 Wakefield Gardens in the ACT. Havelock Housing Association (HHA) is the immediate landlord of Ms Donohoe. The house is a 2 bedroom fibro house. It is one of 7 co-located houses forming the Juno Women’s Housing Co-Operative (Juno). The houses share a driveway, garage, clothes line and garden. There are no fences dividing the houses.

  1. The houses at Juno are the property of the ACT Government and are the subject of a 20 year lease commencing 24 November 1999 to Community Housing Canberra Ltd (CHC), who in turn sub-let the premises to HHA under a 10 year lease commencing on 1 December 1999. A convenient summary of the historical relationship between Juno, HHA, CHC and the ACT is set out in paragraph 33 below as part of the submission prepared for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Donohoe -v- Havelock Housing Association and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ACTRTT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves two applications brought by Brigid Donohoe and Janie McGough, tenants of Havelock Housing Association (HHA) in Ainslie, ACT, to the Residential Tenancies Tribunal. The applications sought a review of proposed rent increases, arguing that they were excessive under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. The Tribunal had to decide whether the rent increases were excessive, considering factors such as the size of the increase, the tenants' capacity to pay, and the special nature of community housing. The Tribunal also had to determine whether the relevant "rent" for the purposes of the Act was the market rent or the rebated rent.

The Tribunal concluded that the relevant "rent" for the purposes of the Act was the rebated rent, which is the contractual obligation of the tenant. The Tribunal found that the increase in the market rent in Ms Donohoe's case led to an increase in her rebated rent, giving the Tribunal jurisdiction to review the increase. However, the Tribunal found that the increase in the market rent in Ms McGough's case had not affected her rebated rent, so her application was dismissed. The Tribunal also found that the tenants' capacity to pay and the special nature of community housing were relevant factors in determining whether the rent increase was excessive.

The Tribunal fixed the market rent and the rebated rent at $242.50 per week for Ms Donohoe, while dismissing Ms McGough's application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established