Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 853

File number: NSD 516 of 2016
Judge: ROBERTSON J
Date of judgment: 29 July 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – breach of confidence claims – interlocutory confidentiality regime – whether orders should be made preventing access by certain employees of cross-respondents, either at all or until their affidavits are filed, to certain schedules to the statement of cross-claim – balancing the risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure against the benefits of a party having access to relevant information so that appropriate advice can be given to the client and informed instructions received from the client – whether a certain mp4 video file should be the subject of the confidentiality regime at all
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37P

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 128

Cases cited:

Aquaculture Corporation v New Zealand Green Mussel Co Limited (1985) 5 IPR 353

AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 549

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Industries [2006] FCA 136

Broadwater Taxation & Investment Services Pty Ltd v Hendriks (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Santow J, 9 September 1993)

Halpin v Lumley General Insurance Ltd [2009] NSWCA 372; 78 NSWLR 265

Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36; 235 CLR 125

Markus v Provincial Insurance Co Ltd (1983) 25 NSWCCR 1

Morton v Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd [2013] FCA 681

Date of hearing: 25 July 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents & Associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 50
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr T Cordiner
Solicitor for the Applicant: DLA Piper Australia
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr PW Flynn with Dr A Hughes
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Cross-Claimant: Mr PW Flynn with Dr A Hughes
Solicitor for the Cross-Claimant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Second Cross-Respondent: Mr C Dimitriadis SC with Ms L Thomas
Solicitor for the Second Cross-Respondent: DibbsBarker

ORDERS

NSD 516 of 2016
BETWEEN:

DOMINO’S PIZZA ENTERPRISES LIMITED (ACN 010 489 326)

Applicant

AND:

PRECISION TRACKING PTY LTD (ACN 133 616 369)

First Respondent

VLADIMIR LASKY

Second Respondent

NATHAN PARROTT (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

PRECISION TRACKING PTY LTD (ACN 133 616 369)

Cross-Claimant

AND:

DOMINO’S PIZZA ENTERPRISES LTD (and others named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 JULY 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

On the amended interlocutory application by Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited:

1.Subject to a signed confidentiality undertaking in the form annexed to the interlocutory application filed 11 July 2016 being provided to the first respondent/cross-claimant’s solicitors by each of the following persons, each such person shall be permitted to receive schedules 1, 2 and 3 to the statement of cross-claim and the mp4 video file attached to the email from Odette Gourley of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, solicitors for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 853
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited v Precision Tracking Pty Ltd involved a dispute regarding the confidentiality of certain documents and a video file in the context of a broader legal battle between Domino's Pizza Enterprises Limited (Domino's) and Precision Tracking Pty Ltd (Precision Tracking). Precision Tracking filed a cross-claim against Domino's and Navman Wireless, alleging wrongful actions and patent infringement related to a pizza tracking system. The central issue in the interlocutory applications was whether certain employees of Domino's and Navman Wireless should be granted access to specific schedules of the cross-claim and an mp4 video file, subject to confidentiality undertakings.

The court was required to balance the risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure of confidential information against the need for the parties to have access to relevant information for providing appropriate legal advice and receiving informed instructions from their clients. The legal principles involved a balancing exercise, considering factors such as the nature of the confidential information, the professional attributes of the individuals seeking access, and the security measures in place to protect the information.

The court concluded that while schedules 1, 2, and 3 of the cross-claim contained confidential information, the risk of disclosure was mitigated by the fact that some of the employees had already seen the material. The court decided that allowing certain employees of Domino's and Navman Wireless to access the schedules, provided they signed confidentiality undertakings, would not significantly increase the risk of disclosure and would allow for efficient and economical litigation. However, the court declined to include the mp4 video file in the confidentiality regime, as there was insufficient evidence to determine its contents and the extent of prior disclosure.

The final orders granted specific employees of Domino's and Navman Wireless access to the schedules and the mp4 video file, subject to confidentiality undertakings. Precision Tracking was ordered to pay 90% of the costs of each interlocutory application, reflecting the unsuccessful attempts by Domino's and Navman Wireless to exclude the video file from the confidentiality regime. The court also allowed for further applications if any difficulties arose regarding the provision of documents under the confidentiality regime.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the amended interlocutory application by Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Limited:

1. Subject to a signed confidentiality undertaking in the form annexed to the interlocutory application filed 11 July 2016 being provided to the first respondent/cross-claimant’s solicitors by each of the following persons, each such person shall be permitted to receive schedules 1, 2 and 3 to the statement of cross-claim and the mp4 video file attached to the email from Odette Gourley of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, solicitors for the first respondent/cross-claimant, to Liam Prescott of DLA Piper, solicitors for the applicant/first cross-respondent, dated 18 July 2016:

1.1 Mr Craig Ryan, General Counsel, Company Secretary of the applicant/first-cross respondent;

1.2 Mr Wayne McMahon, Group Chief Information Officer of the applicant/first cross-respondent;

1.3 Mr Phillip Harrys, Group Director Digital Development of the applicant/first cross-respondent;

1.4 Mr Nicholas Knight, Chief Executive Officer for Australia and New Zealand of the applicant/first cross-respondent;

1.5 Ms Renee Rametta, Business Analyst of the applicant/first cross-respondent; and

1.6 such other persons as are reasonably required by the applicant/first cross-respondent, following a request by the solicitors for the applicant/first cross-respondent to the solicitors for the first respondent/cross-claimant for consent, which shall not be unreasonably withheld, for that person to be permitted access.

2. Precision Tracking Pty Ltd pay 90% of Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Ltd’s costs of the interlocutory application.

3. Liberty to apply on three days’ notice, including in respect of order 1.6 above.

On the amended interlocutory application by Navman Wireless Australia Pty Ltd:

4. Subject to:

(a) a signed confidentiality undertaking in the form annexed to the interlocutory application filed 11 July 2016 being provided to the first respondent/cross-claimant’s solicitors by each of the following persons; and

(b) General Counsel of the second cross-respondent personally explaining to each of those persons the serious ramifications of any breach of the undertaking and explaining to each of them the implied undertaking given to the Court that any document provided to the Court may only be used by the receiving party for the purposes of the proceeding and no other purpose;

each such person shall be permitted to receive schedules 1, 2 and 3 to the statement of cross-claim and the mp4 video file attached to the email from Odette Gourley of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, solicitors for the first respondent/cross-claimant, to Chelsea Parker of DibbsBarker, solicitors for the second cross-respondent, dated 20 July 2016:

4.1 Mr Mark Schwarz, General Counsel of the second cross-respondent;

4.2 Mr Daron Brinsdon, National Integration Solutions Manager of the second cross-respondent;

4.3 Mr Andrew Franchuk, independent consultant of the second cross-respondent;

4.4 Mr Chris Parkhurst, Software Development Manager of the second cross-respondent;

4.5 Mr Zane Thompson, Global Account Director (Domino’s) of the second cross-respondent; and

4.6 such other persons as are reasonably required by the second cross-respondent, following a request by the solicitors for the second cross-respondent to the solicitors for the first respondent/cross-claimant for consent, which shall not be unreasonably withheld, for that person to be permitted access.

5. Precision Tracking Pty Ltd pay 90% of Navman Wireless Australia Pty Ltd’s costs of the interlocutory application.

6. Liberty to apply on three days’ notice, including in respect of order 4.6 above.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

By cross-claim, in broad terms, Precision Tracking claims that in developing its pizza tracker system with Navman Wireless (the second cross-respondent), Domino’s (the first cross-respondent) acted wrongfully. Part of the case brought by Precision Tracking is that Domino’s and Navman Wireless have installed and maintained a system which substantially replicates the Precision Tracking system or systems. Precision Tracking also claims that this involved Domino’s and Navman Wireless in unauthorised use and disclosure of confidential information of Precision Tracking, where duties of confidentiality were owed by them to Precision Tracking, and infringement of innovation patents and copyright in certain works owned by Precision Tracking.Background The background to the present interlocutory applications is as follows. On 8 April 2016, Domino’s commenced the proceeding by claim and statement of claim against the respondents: Precision Tracking and each of its three directors, Mr Vladimir Lasky, Mr Nathan Parrott and Dr Alexander Green. The originating application included claims that Precision Tracking had made “unjustified” threats contrary to s 128 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) and claims of misleading and deceptive conduct by making representations. A confidentiality regime was put in place with respect to some of the documents referred to in the statement of claim. Under that arrangement the documents the subject of the undertaking were not provided to the respondents but were provided to the respondents’ solicitors and counsel who provided confidentiality undertakings. On 17 June 2016, the respondents filed a defence in response to Domino’s claim and statement of claim, and a cross-claim and statement of cross-claim was filed by Precision Tracking alone against Domino’s and Navman Wireless. Precision Tracking’s statement of cross-claim attached three schedules, schedules 1, 2 and 3, which Domino’s contends, and I find, are referred to throughout the statement of cross-claim and form part of those pleadings. Precision Tracking claims that schedules 1, 2 and 3 are confidential. A number of confidentiality undertakings have been given by Domino’s representatives to Precision Tracking, which have been accepted by it. Those confidentiality undertakings have been given by Kathryn Clarke, Hadley Hickson, Liam Prescott and Ellen Corrigan, each of DLA Piper, solicitors for Domino’s in the proceeding, by Regan Gourley of Cullens Pty Ltd (patent and trademark attorneys), and by Mr AP Coleman SC and Mr Tom Cordiner of counsel. However Domino’s has requested that certain of its representatives be given access to schedules 1, 2 and 3, those representatives having provided or being prepared to provide confidentiality undertakings. Navman Wireless’ representatives have also given confidentiality undertakings to Precision Tracking, which have been accepted by it. These confidentiality undertakings have been given by Melissa Anne McGrath, Chelsea Parker and Lisa Hopkins (each of DibbsBarker). Navman Wireless has also requested that certain of its representatives should be given access to schedules 1, 2 and 3 on the giving of confidentiality undertakings. Domino’s interlocutory application

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Navman Wireless also relies on a further affidavit of Ms McGrath sworn 22 July 2016. Ms McGrath gives evidence regarding the decision-making roles of Navman Wireless’ representatives seeking access to the confidential information and regarding Mr Schwarz’s lack of technical skills and his need to seek further instructions from these representatives. Precision Tracking’s evidence The affidavits on behalf of Precision Tracking are those of Odette Margaret Gourley sworn 18 July 2016 and a further affidavit by her sworn 21 July 2016. In her first affidavit, Ms Gourley referred to schedules 1, 2 and 3 to the statement of cross-claim and set out the concerns of Precision Tracking and its directors. Emphasis was placed on the assembling of the detail in the schedules over several weeks by the directors of Precision Tracking to result in single, ordered “blueprints” of the confidential information developed by Precision Tracking and on which it relies in these proceedings. This first affidavit stated that confidential schedules 1 and 2 contained references to computer code, scripts and files from Precision Tracking’s systems that were available for inspection. Schedule 3 identified the works, copyright in which was alleged to subsist and to be owned by Precision Tracking and provided particulars of infringement by reference to the requirements document alleged by Precision Tracking to have been prepared by reference to its system and supplied by Domino’s to Navman Wireless. In her second affidavit, Ms Gourley provided more information about confidential schedules 1, 2 and 3. It appears from [10] of that affidavit that the information in the schedules was developed by Precision Tracking and provided to Domino’s pursuant to the pleaded arrangements with Domino’s, including under the terms of a March 2013 mutual non-disclosure agreement between the parties. There are other affidavits but they are relevant to an application by Navman Wireless that Precision Tracking provide security for costs. That application has been stood over by consent. The parties’ submissions Each of the contesting parties filed short written submissions. From those submissions it appeared that the relevant principles were not in dispute. Domino’s submitted that the applicable considerations were summarised in AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 549 at [10] per Besanko J. Domino’s referred also to Gram Engineering Pty Ltd v Bluescope Steel Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 452 at [21] per Jagot J. In the former case, Besanko J said, at [10]:The relevant legal principles are as follows:(1)The onus of establishing a claim for confidentiality is on the party making the claim.(2)The question of whether a claim for confidentiality should be upheld or refused involves a balancing exercise in which the competing considerations are the risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure on the one hand, and the benefits of a party having access to relevant information so that appropriate advice can be given to the client and informed instructions received from the client, on the other.(3)In determining where the balance lies in a particular case, a number of matters are relevant, including the following:(i)the nature and content of the confidential information;(ii)the extent to which, if the confidential information is disclosed to a particular person, that person will have occasion to use the information to further a party’s commercial interests. In this context, involvement or lack of involvement in competitive decision‑making will be relevant. It will also be relevant to consider whether the person to whom it is proposed to disclose the information owes or may owe contractual, statutory or fiduciary duties to their principal in relation to competitive decisions;(iii)the professional attributes of the persons to whom it is proposed to disclose the information and the extent to which they have participated in confidentiality clubs in the past;(iv)the extent to which the Court can be satisfied that, if confidential information is released to a person, that person, or the organisation for which the person works, has in place a security system that will protect the confidentiality of the information;(v)undertakings given by the proposed recipient of the confidential information or the party seeking disclosure to meet any loss caused by inadvertent or accidental disclosure;(vi)although the above five matters are directed, primarily at least, to the risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure of the confidential information and the likely loss if that occurs, on the other side of the equation, it is relevant to consider the extent to which a party’s ability to seek advice and provide instructions may be hampered if a claim for confidentiality is upheld. In this context, it is worth noting that a claim for confidentiality in relation to certain persons is not necessarily to be upheld because there is already one person able to seek advice and provide instructions. It may be appropriate for a number of people from within an organisation to have access to confidential information in order to seek appropriate advice and provide informed instructions, particularly in the case of a large organisation and complex litigation. Whether that is so or not depends on the outcome of weighing the relevant factors.(Citations omitted.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the video file, there is the evidence of Ms Clarke in her affidavit sworn 20 July 2016. I do not accept the submissions on behalf of Domino’s and Navman Wireless that I should form a concluded view on whether that material is confidential. Although it is sufficiently clear that the video file was available on the Internet for nearly three years, time did not permit full evidence or submissions as to what the video discloses. However I note that counsel for Domino’s submitted that the video disclosed elements of the confidential schedule. I also bear in mind the distinction in Aquaculture Corporation v New Zealand Green Mussel Co Limited (1985) 5 IPR 353 at 378-379 between the concept of patent law whereby novelty is lost as against the question whether the information, originally confidential, has become freely available to the public. It should therefore be the subject of the confidentiality regime.Conclusion and orders For these reasons, and subject to the matter I next deal with, I make orders in terms of the short minutes propounded by the cross-respondents. In respect of the amended interlocutory application by Navman Wireless that the documents not be limited to schedules 1, 2 and 3 and the mp4 video file and include documents provided in the confidentiality undertaking, I do not make that broader order as there is presently no evidence as to what those other documents might be. If there is any difficulty on the part of any of the parties in that respect or generally in respect of the provision of documents under the confidentiality regime, each party has liberty to apply on three days’ notice. Precision Tracking should pay 90% of the costs of each interlocutory application. In fixing that percentage I take into account that Domino’s and Navman Wireless failed on their application that the mp4 video file not be subject to any confidentiality regime. But I decline to order that those costs be paid forthwith. An order of that kind should generally be reserved for interlocutory applications which stand outside the ordinary course of preparing a matter for trial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Precision Tracking submitted that the video was confidential information and that the information in question being obtained by lawyers making targeted searches on the Internet did not prove lack of confidentiality or relative confidentiality. Consideration Section 37P(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) provides that in a civil proceeding before the Court, the Court or a judge may give directions about the practice and procedure to be followed in relation to the proceeding, or any part of the proceeding. It was common ground that the Court had the discretionary power to make the orders sought by Domino’s and Navman Wireless on the one hand and by Precision Tracking on the other. I accept for present purposes that schedules 1, 2 and 3 contain confidential information. I do not find it necessary or appropriate for present purposes to make a final determination of that issue. As I understand it Domino’s and Navman Wireless were content to proceed on the assumption that there might be something confidential in the schedules. As I have said, all parties accepted that a balancing exercise is involved in deciding the appropriate order. As stated by Besanko J in AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd, the competing considerations are the risk of inadvertent or accidental disclosure on the one hand, and the benefits of a party having access to relevant information so that appropriate advice can be given to the client and informed instructions may be received from the client on the other hand. I understand from the evidence the concerns of Precision Tracking and its directors and I raised for the parties’ consideration whether or not it would be appropriate for the relevant parties to give an undertaking in the form ordered by Besanko J in AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd, that is, that the cross-respondents give an undertaking to be liable for any direct or indirect loss, damages, costs or expenses to or suffered by Precision Tracking in the event of disclosure of the confidential information by any of the persons referred to in the confidentiality orders other than a person the subject of those confidentiality orders. No party took up the suggestion and I put it to one side. In my opinion, the balancing exercise in this case must take into account two significant elements. First, I accept the evidence on behalf of Domino’s and Navman Wireless that, in order to plead to the statement of cross-claim, it is necessary to obtain instructions from the persons identified. The procedure envisaged by Precision Tracking is in effect that a defence to the cross-claim be put on without the benefit of those instructions, then in due course the cross-respondents’ would file and serve their affidavit evidence, and then the cross-respondents would amend their defences to the statement of cross-claim with the benefit of instructions. However, I do not regard this as a course which is consistent with economy or efficiency or one necessary to do justice between the parties. The potential detriment to Precision Tracking was, in my opinion, shadowy. This is in large part by reason of the second element to which I refer, that is on Precision Tracking’s case the employees have already seen the claimed confidential material. I also take into account that on the present applications Domino’s and Navman Wireless do not seek access to the material referred to in schedules 1, 2 and 3 but to the schedules themselves.