DNTV and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DNTV and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 2273 (5 July 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2023/8026          

Re:DNTV

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndVMJL

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:5 July 2024

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

...[SGD].........................................................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – revocation of existing care percentage determinations – care period – pattern of care – actual care – delegated physical care – responsible person - no change in the care of the Children – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 37,43

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 ss 4, 35, 49, 50, 54A, 54D, 54F, 54G, 54H

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 ss 16, 96A

Cases

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
P v Child Support Registrar [2012] FCA 1398

Secondary Materials

Child Support Guide

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

5 July 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, DNTV (the Father), and the Other Party, VMJL (the Mother), are the separated parents of two children (Children). From January 2020, the Child Support Agency (Agency) determined that the Father had 11% care of the Children and that the Mother had 89% care of the Children.[1] The determination of the percentage of care is one of the requisite steps in assessing the rate of any child support payable by one parent to the other under the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Assessment Act).

    [1] Exhibit 1, pages 380 and 384.

  2. In February 2023, the Agency rejected the Father’s change in care notification that he would have 100% care of the Children from 13 November 2022 to 24 January 2023.[2] The Father objected to that determination, which was allowed by an authorised officer who decided that the Father had 14% of the Children during the abovementioned period in late 2022 and early 2023. As a result, the Mother applied to the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT1) for review of that objection decision.[3]

    [2] Ibid., pages 170 and 310-11.

    [3] Ibid., pages 105-135.  

  3. The AAT1 set aside the objection decision and found that, despite the Father having an increased percentage of care during the 2022-2023 school holidays, the overall pattern of care that the Father provided for the Children was 11%, such that there was no change in care from the existing care determinations. The Father applied for review of the AAT1 decision by the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal).[4]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DNTV and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2273
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review by the Tribunal of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding the percentage of care provided by the Father and Mother to their Children. The dispute arose from the Father’s notification to the Child Support Agency of a claimed change in care arrangements from 13 November 2022, which the Mother disputed. Existing care percentage determinations had previously established that the Father provided 11% care and the Mother 89% care.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the existing care percentage determinations should be revoked, and if so, what percentages of care should be attributed to each parent for an appropriate care period, and from what date any new percentages should take effect. The central question was whether the care arrangements had changed from 13 November 2022, necessitating a revocation of the existing determinations.

The Tribunal considered the evidence regarding the actual care provided by each parent. It noted that the AAT had found that the Father had 31 out of 58 nights of care between 13 November 2022 and 2 January 2023. However, the Tribunal also considered the established pattern of care, which involved the Father having half of the school holidays each year, equating to approximately 42 nights annually. The Tribunal determined that the relevant care period for its consideration was from 13 November 2022 to 16 September 2023, a period of 307 nights. Based on the agreed and established care arrangements, the Tribunal found that the Children spent 45 nights with their Father during this period, which equated to 14.65% of care.

The Tribunal ordered that the existing care percentage determinations be revoked. It determined that the Father provided 14.65% care and the Mother provided 85.35% care for the period from 13 November 2022 to 16 September 2023. These percentages were to be rounded in accordance with section 54D of the Assessment Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues for the Tribunal to determine in this proceeding were:(a)whether the existing care percentage determinations should be revoked pursuant to sections 54F, 54G or 54H of the Assessment Act;(b)if so, what percentages of care should be attributed to the Father and to the Mother under sections 49 and/or 50 of the Assessment Act during an appropriate care period; and(c)from what date should any new percentages of care take effect.BACKGROUND In March 2017, a child support case was first registered in relation to the Children.[5][5] Ibid., page 366. From 24 January 2020, the administrative assessment of child support was that the Father provided 11% care of the Children and the other party provided 89% care (Existing Care Percentage Determinations).[6][6] Ibid., pages 380 and 384. On 28 November 2022, the Father informed the Agency that care for the Children had changed, and that from 13 November 2022 to 24 January 2023, he would have 100% care of them.[7] The Mother disputed this claimed change in care of the Children and told the Agency that the Existing Care Percentage Determinations remained unchanged from 13 November 2022.[8] [7] Ibid., page 170. [8] Ibid., pages 196-197. In February 2023, an authorised officer of the Agency decided to reject the Father’s change in care notification such that the Existing Care Percentage Determinations remained in place (Original Decision).[9] [9] Ibid., pages 310-313. In April 2023, following the Father’s objection to the Agency’s Original Decision, another authorised officer of the Agency allowed his objection and decided that the Father provided 14% care of the Children from 13 November 2022 and that the Mother provided 86% care (Objection Decision).[10] During that review, the Father informed the Agency that he had not intended to claim that he had 100% care of the Children, but rather had 14% care from November 2022.[11] [10] Ibid., pages 316-318 and 343-362. [11] Ibid., pages 316 and 345-346. In May 2023, the Mother applied to the AAT1 for review of the Objection Decision.[12] [12] Ibid., pages 105-135. On 14 September 2023, the AAT1 set aside the Objection Decision and, in substitution, decided that there had been no change in the care of the Children as set out in the Existing Care Percentage Determinations, being 11% by the Father and 89% by the Mother.[13] The Tribunal relevantly found that:[14] (a)the Children were in the care of the Mother, with the exception of half of the school holidays after Terms 1, 2 and 3 in 2023 (with an averaging effect between the 2022 and 2023 years with regard to the school holidays after Term 3);(b)for the period from 13 November 2022 to 2 January 2023, the Father had 31 out of 58 nights of care of the Children (or 53%);(c)while the Father ‘may have had four additional nights over one part of the 2022/23 summer holidays’, the pattern of care that the Father has of the Children, according to the evidence of the parents, is half of the school holidays each year, meaning that the Father has six weeks of care per year, or 42 nights care of the Children on an annual basis; and(d)the Mother’s percentage of 323 nights out of 365 nights (88.49%) is to be rounded up to 89% and the Father’s care percentage of 42 nights out of 365 nights (11.51%) is to be rounded down to 11% under section 54D of the Act. [13] Ibid., pages 4-9. [14] Ibid.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In April 2023, following the Father’s objection to the Agency’s Original Decision, another authorised officer of the Agency allowed his objection and decided that the Father provided 14% care of the Children from 13 November 2022 and that the Mother provided 86% care (Objection Decision).[10] During that review, the Father informed the Agency that he had not intended to claim that he had 100% care of the Children, but rather had 14% care from November 2022.[11] [10] Ibid., pages 316-318 and 343-362. [11] Ibid., pages 316 and 345-346. In May 2023, the Mother applied to the AAT1 for review of the Objection Decision.[12] [12] Ibid., pages 105-135. On 14 September 2023, the AAT1 set aside the Objection Decision and, in substitution, decided that there had been no change in the care of the Children as set out in the Existing Care Percentage Determinations, being 11% by the Father and 89% by the Mother.[13] The Tribunal relevantly found that:[14] (a)the Children were in the care of the Mother, with the exception of half of the school holidays after Terms 1, 2 and 3 in 2023 (with an averaging effect between the 2022 and 2023 years with regard to the school holidays after Term 3);(b)for the period from 13 November 2022 to 2 January 2023, the Father had 31 out of 58 nights of care of the Children (or 53%);(c)while the Father ‘may have had four additional nights over one part of the 2022/23 summer holidays’, the pattern of care that the Father has of the Children, according to the evidence of the parents, is half of the school holidays each year, meaning that the Father has six weeks of care per year, or 42 nights care of the Children on an annual basis; and(d)the Mother’s percentage of 323 nights out of 365 nights (88.49%) is to be rounded up to 89% and the Father’s care percentage of 42 nights out of 365 nights (11.51%) is to be rounded down to 11% under section 54D of the Act. [13] Ibid., pages 4-9. [14] Ibid. On 1 November 2023, the Father applied to the Tribunal for review of the AAT1 decision.[15][15] Ibid., pages 1-3. In May 2024, in a related matter, an authorised officer of the Agency decided to reject the Father’s change in care notification in respect of a change claimed to have occurred on 17 September 2023. That decision was not before the Tribunal in this proceeding. On 14 June 2024, the Tribunal held a hearing by the videoconferencing facility Microsoft Teams with all parties in attendance. While the Registrar provided detailed submissions in relation to the facts and applicable legislation in the proceeding, it adopted a neutral position regarding the evidence and contentions of the Father and the Mother and made no submissions or contentions regarding the correct or preferable decision of the Tribunal. The Tribunal records its appreciation for the assistance it received from the Registrar and its legal representative through the Registrar’s submissions and during the course of this proceeding. LEGISLATION & POLICY Section 35 of the Assessment Act sets out the applicable formula to determine the rate of child support payable for the Children. Step 4 in the formula is to ‘Work out each parent’s percentage of care for the child’. The determination of the percentage of care for a child during a care period can be made under sections 49 or 50 of the Assessment Act, depending on whether there has been a ‘pattern of care’ for the child provided by a ‘responsible person’, being a parent or non-parent carer.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For completeness, the Tribunal notes that, pursuant to subsections 96A(b) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988, an application may be made to the General Division of the Tribunal for review of a care percentage decision by the AAT1. The Tribunal therefore has jurisdiction in relation to the Father’s application for review of the AAT1 decision that there was no change in the percentage of care of the Children from November 2022. CONSIDERATION The task of the Tribunal in this proceeding was to determine the percentage of care that the Father and the Mother each provided to the Children from 13 November 2022. As stated above in these reasons, the Existing Care Percentage Determinations were that, from 24 January 2020, the Father had 11% care of the Children and that the Mother had 89% care of the Children.[19] This remained unchanged up until the present dispute between the Father and the Mother that arose from November 2022, when the Father informed the Agency of a claimed change in the parents’ respective percentages of care for the Children. The Father and the Mother disagreed as to whether care of the Children changed from 13 November 2022 and therefore disagreed about the amount of actual care they each had of the Children from that date.[19] Ibid., pages 380 and 384. The first issue for the Tribunal to decide in this proceeding, which determines whether further issues must be resolved, was whether the Existing Care Percentage Determinations should be revoked. This would occur if the Tribunal found that from 13 November 2022 the care of the Children provided by each parent changed from that set out in the Existing Care Percentage Determinations. As the AAT1 set out in its reasons, the Father and the Mother both agreed that the Father had 31 nights of care of the Children in the 58 night period from 13 November 2022 to 9 November 2023.[20] The Tribunal at the hearing in this proceeding confirmed that the parents agreed with this position. The parents also agreed at the Tribunal hearing, as they had before the AAT1, that after this summer holiday period, the Father provided 7 nights of care for the Children in the April 2023 school holidays and another 7 nights of care in the mid-2023 school holidays.[21] [20] Ibid., page 6. [21] Ibid., pages 3 and 8. A ‘care period’ does not have any fixed duration and the Child Support Guide provides that it would ‘generally be the 12-month period from the day on which the actual care of a child began or changed’. The care period does not necessarily have to be based on the calendar year or the average care provided by a parent during a particular period of time, such as school holidays. The Guide further provides that the same care arrangements will be assumed to apply for the subsequent 12-month period, unless otherwise advised. As set out above, the Agency made a decision in May 2024, while this proceeding was before the Tribunal, regarding care of the Children from 17 September 2023 onwards. That decision was not before this Tribunal. As a result, the Tribunal accepts that it is not open for the Tribunal to identify a care period beyond 16 September 2023 in relation to the issues before this Tribunal. Therefore, the Tribunal finds that the relevant care period before the Tribunal in this proceeding was from 13 November 2022 to 16 September 2023, being a period of 307 nights. Based on the accepted evidence, the Tribunal is satisfied that the Children spent 45 nights with their Father in this 307 night period, equating to 14.65%.