DMS Shipping & Trading Co Ltd v Lionheart Asia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[1995] QCA 448

COURT OF APPEAL

McPHERSON JA
THOMAS J
WILLIAMS J

Appeal No 171 of 1995

DMS SHIPPING & TRADING CO LIMITED  Respondent/Plaintiff

v

LUKE BUTLER  First Defendant

COMMERCIAL TRADING & FINANCE PTY LTD  Second Defendant

LIONHART ASIA LIMITED  Applicant/Third Defendant

BRISBANE

DATE 30/08/95

JUDGMENT

McPHERSON JA:  The plaintiff, which is a Russian corporation based in Vladivostok, has brought this action against the third defendant, which is a commodity broker or dealer, to recover a sum of US$162,500 paid as a deposit under a contract between those parties.

The contract in question was one for the supply of some 100,000 tonnes of sugar for shipment to the plaintiff.  The deposit of the sum of $162,500 was by the contract required to be paid by the plaintiff to the defendant and it was, in fact, so paid.  Thereafter disputes broke out between the parties and it is now accepted on both sides of the record that the contract has been determined.

The plaintiff applied to a Judge in Chambers for summary judgment for the amount of US$162,500 plus interest thereon.  The Judge having heard submissions on both sides came to the conclusion that there was a triable issue with respect to the meaning of a clause in the contract, namely article 12.4, which refers to the seller submitting "proof of product".

In dealing with the question which it raised, his Honour said that he found the construction for which the third defendant contended an unattractive one, but nevertheless considered that it should not prevent the matter from going to trial.

He accordingly said that he proposed to give the defendant leave to defend.  Having said that, he went on to impose conditions on that leave and he ordered that the third defendant pay into Court the sum of US$162,500 as a condition of being given leave to defend.  He also ordered that if the sum was not so paid, the plaintiff should be at liberty to sign judgment against the third defendant in the Australian equivalent of that sum with interest.  The third defendant has now appealed against that decision in so far as it imposes conditions on the third defendant's right to defend the action.

The appeal before us is, of course, one that challenges the exercise of a discretionary judgment in the Court below.  It is therefore necessary for the third defendant as appellant to demonstrate that his Honour committed some error of law in the course of exercising his discretion, or that he failed to take account of relevant matters, or left some such matter out of account.  In the submissions before us, counsel for the third defendant seems to me to approach the question of summary judgment essentially on the basis that once a triable issue is raised, it has the right to unqualified leave to defend; and that the Judge, at any rate in a case where the question is one of law rather than of fact or credit, is not at liberty to impose…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DMS Shipping & Trading Co Ltd v Lionheart Asia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] QCA 448
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of DMS Shipping & Trading Co Ltd v Lionheart Asia Ltd, the plaintiff, a Russian corporation based in Vladivostok, sought to recover a deposit of US$162,500 paid under a contract for the supply of 100,000 tonnes of sugar. The defendant, a commodity broker, was the third party to the contract. The dispute arose from the interpretation of a clause in the contract, article 12.4, concerning the requirement for "proof of product". The trial judge found that there was a triable issue regarding the clause but allowed the defendant to defend on the condition that the deposit be paid into court. The defendant appealed against the condition imposed on the leave to defend.

The legal issues before the court were whether the trial judge correctly exercised his discretion in imposing conditions on the leave to defend and whether such conditions could be imposed in cases involving disputes over the interpretation of a contract clause. The court had to determine if there was an error of law in the exercise of discretion or if relevant matters were overlooked.

The court found that the trial judge correctly exercised his discretion under Order 18 of the Supreme Court Rules, which grants a global discretion to the judge to grant leave to defend with or without conditions. The court rejected the argument that a distinction should be made between disputes of fact, credit, or law. It was noted that the trial judge's decision was justified based on the doubtful validity of the defendant's argument, the lack of evidence of hardship, and the need to protect the plaintiff. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established