DLT v Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read


Civil and Administrative Tribunal

New South Wales

Case Name: 

DLT v Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2023] NSWCATAD 16

Hearing Date(s): 

5 December 2022

Date of Orders:

18 January 2023

Decision Date: 

18 January 2023

Jurisdiction: 

Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division

Before: 

M Riordan, Senior Member

Decision: 

The decision of the respondent dated 4 July 2022, as varied by its written submissions filed on 6 October 2022, is affirmed

Catchwords: 

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – administrative review – Government information – confidential restriction on reporting of certain evidence - scope of application – public interest test – balancing the public interest

Legislation Cited: 

Administrative Decisions Review Act 1997 (NSW) Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW)
Freedom of Information Act 1989 (NSW)
Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW)
Government Sector Audit Act 1983 (NSW)
Health Records and Information Privacy Act 2002 (NSW)
Health Services Act 1997 (NSW)
Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW)
Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 (NSW)
Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)
State Records Act 1998 (NSW)

Cases Cited: 

AEZ v Commissioner of Police, NSW Police Force [2013] NSWADT 90
Attorney-General's Department v Cockcroft (1986) 10 FCR 180
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57
Bernard v Manly Lawn Tennis Club Ltd [2006] NSWADT 174
Commissioner of Police, NSW Police Force v Camilleri (GD) [2012] NSWADTAP 19
DLT v Justice Health and Forensic Mental Health Network [2022] NSWCATAD 183
Dezfouli v Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network [2018] NSWCATAD 11
Fisher v Goulburn Mulwaree Council [2019] NSWCATAD 34
Flack v Commissioner of Police, New South Wales Police [2011] NSWADT 286
Hall v Department of Premier and Cabinet (NSW) [2012] NSWADT 46
Hurst v Wagga Wagga City Council [2011] NSWADT 307
Leech v Sydney Water Corporation [2010] NSWADT 298
Meldru v Wollondilly Shire Council [2017] NSWCATAD 292
PE v MU [2010] NSWDC 2
Taylor v Destination NSW [2017] NSWCATAD 272
YG & GG v Minister for Community Services [2002] NSWCA 247

Texts Cited: 

The Macquarie Dictionary

Category: 

Principal judgment

Parties: 

DLT (Applicant)
Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network
(Respondent)

Representation: 

Applicant (Self Represented)
K Mattes (Respondent)

File Number(s): 

2021/00269153

Publication Restriction: 

The publication or broadcast of the name of the applicant is prohibited pursuant to s 64(1)(a) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) (the NCAT Act).

Pursuant to s 64(1)(c) of the NCAT Act the publication or disclosure of the parts of these Reasons marked “NOT FOR PUBLICATION”, other than to the respondent (Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network), is prohibited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. This matter has a lengthy background and was the subject of a previous determination by this Tribunal (differently constituted): DLT v Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network [2022] NSWCATAD 183. However, the following brief summary is provided.

  2. The applicant (known in these proceedings as “DLT”) is a person detained in a secure mental health facility known as the Forensic Hospital in accordance with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DLT v Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWCATAD 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of DLT v Justice Health & Forensic Mental Health Network, the applicant sought access to certain documents held by the respondent under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (NSW) (GIPA Act). The documents in question contained personal information about medical practitioners and staff of the respondent, who is a network of health services in New South Wales. The respondent refused to release the documents, citing public interest considerations against disclosure under the GIPA Act. The applicant sought judicial review of the respondent's decision in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent was correct in its decision to refuse access to the documents on the basis of public interest considerations against disclosure. The court was required to determine whether the respondent's decision was lawful, reasonable, and based on relevant and material considerations. The court also had to consider whether the respondent gave appropriate weight to the public interest in disclosure and whether the public interest in non-disclosure outweighed any competing public interest in disclosure.

The court found that the respondent's decision was lawful, reasonable, and based on relevant and material considerations. The court held that the respondent was entitled to rely on cl 3(a) and cl 3(f) to the Table to s 14(2) of the GIPA Act, which provide that there is a public interest consideration against disclosure of information if disclosure of the information could reasonably be expected to reveal an individual’s personal information or expose a person to a risk of harm or of serious harassment or serious intimidation. The court accepted the respondent's evidence that the documents contained personal information about medical practitioners and staff, and that releasing that information could result in those persons being at risk of harm, serious harassment, or serious intimidation. The court held that the respondent had given appropriate weight to the public interest in non-disclosure and that the public interest in non-disclosure outweighed any competing public interest in disclosure.

The decision of the respondent dated 4 July 2022, as varied by its written submissions filed on 6 October 2022, is affirmed. The applicant's application for judicial review is dismissed. The respondent is entitled to its costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the respondent dated 4 July 2022, as varied by its written submissions filed on 6 October 2022, is affirmed

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent relied upon the following evidence:(1)Statement of Associate-Professor Ellis dated 5 October 2022;(2)Letter from DLT to Associate-Professor Ellis dated 23 November 2022;(3)An open tender bundle dated 6 October 2022; and (4)A further open tender bundle filed on 18 November 2022.Evidence of Associate-Professor Ellis DLT notified the respondent that he required Associate-Professor Ellis to attend for cross-examination and the witness appeared by telephone. His statement dated 5 October 2022 was admitted into evidence and marked as Ex “A”. I note that in Ex A, the witness stated that he has been the Clinical Director and Medical Superintendent of the Forensic Hospital in Sydney since 23 April 2018. The Forensic Hospital is a high security mental health facility for patients who have been in contact with the criminal justice system and high-risk civil patients and it is operated by the respondent on behalf of NSW Health. All clinical services are provided by the respondent through a multi-disciplinary team of medical, nursing and allied health professionals. The witness stated that his responsibilities include: (a) line management of medical staff; (b) oversight of clinical care; (c) direct clinical care of select patients; (d) maintenance of NSW Ministry of Health policies; and (e) functions under the Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW) and Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 (NSW). He does not provide direct clinical care to DLT, but he has overall responsibility for the care and treatment of patients in the Forensic Hospital. He had previously been a treating doctor whilst he was a training registrar in forensic psychiatry when DLT was a patient of the old Long Bay Prison Hospital in 2003. The witness also stated that DLT has a diagnosis of psychotic disorder, which is either a delusional disorder or schizophrenia. The primary symptoms are persecutory and querulous delusions and he has a fixed belief in a nation spanning conspiracy to end his life and corruption at most levels of legal and administrative systems and he has a history of sending correspondence to public officials in Australia and overseas. He stated, relevantly:15. On 10 and 26 January 2019, (DLT) sent letters with threatening content and a white powder to political and media addresses. (DLT) was subsequently charged with offences of use post/similar service to menace/harass/be offensive (6 counts) and cause belief explosive/dangerous/harmful article is carried (5 counts). These charges were later withdrawn during the course of a fitness shearing.16. As recently as 1 September 2022, (DLT) sent correspondence to the President of the MHRT. By that letter, (DLT) threatened to sexually assault, amongst others, the wife of the President of the MHRT, the wife of the NSW Premier, Dominic Perrottet, and the partner of the Prime Minister Anthony Albanese MP. He also threatened to “blow up” a number of government, JHFMHN and MHRT buildings. A copy of that letter is annexed to this statement and marked “A”.17. On 7 September 2022, (DLT) attempted to send correspondence containing similar threats to the Acting Chief Executive of the JHFMHN, Wendy Hoey, after findings that a complaint that (DLT) had made alleging unprofessional behaviour of staff was unsubstantiated. A copy of this letter is annexed to this statement and marked “B”.18. The Forensic Hospital has had to put significant measures in place to seek to prevent (DLT) from undertaking similar conduct to that described above, such as monitoring (DLT)’s external correspondence…

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent decided that disclosure of the information could reasonably be expected to promote the fair and responsible handling of health information, as it related to his health information and medical records. Disclosure of that type of information encourages health professionals to ensure that they are handling and recording health information fairly and responsibly. In addition, the requested information was personal information of DLT. Public interest considerations against disclosure The respondent relied upon cl 3(a) to the Table to s 14(2) of the GIPA Act, which provides that “there is a public interest consideration against disclosure of information if disclosure of the information could reasonably be expected to have one or more of the following effects … (a) reveal an individual’s personal information.” The respondent stated that the words “reveal information” are defined in Sch 4 Cl 1 of the GIPA Act to mean “disclose information that has not already been publicly disclosed (otherwise than by unlawful disclosure)”. Therefore, “publicly disclosed” means that there has to have been a prior disclosure of the information to the general public. The respondent stated, relevantly:I do not consider that the surnames of any of the medical professionals and JHFMHN staff referred to in the documents responsive to the access application have previously been publicly disclosed. I understand that when JHFMHN has released documents containing your health information to you in response to previous access applications, the surnames of the medical practitioners and JHFMHN staff recorded in those documents have been redacted.“Personal information” is defined in Sch 4 cl 4 of the GIPA Act to mean “information or an opinion (including information or an opinion forming part of a database and whether or not recorded in a material form) about an individual (whether living or dead) whose identity is apparent or can reasonably be ascertained from the information or opinion.”All of the documents that are responsive to the access application contain personal information, as defined above. This includes the surnames of medical practitioners and JHFMHN staff.Having regard to the above, I am satisfied that releasing the documents responsive to the access application, in full, would reveal personal information, as contemplated by cl 3(a) of the Table to s 14. I have given strong weighting to this consideration against public disclosure. The respondent also relied upon cl 3(f) to the Table to s 14(2) of the GIPA Act. This provides that “there is a public interest consideration against disclosure of information if disclosure of the information could reasonably be expected to have one or more of the following effects… (f) expose a person to a risk of harm or of serious harassment or serious intimidation.” The respondent stated, relevantly:Having regard to your conduct in the past (see also GIPA Act, s 55(1)), I am satisfied that releasing certain personal information, being medical practitioners’ and JHFMHN staff’s surnames, could result in those persons to whom that information relates being at risk of harm, serious harassment or serious intimidation. I have given strong weighting to this consideration against public disclosure.