Director of Public Prosecutions v Whitall

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Whitall

Citation: 

[2025] ACTSC 111

Hearing Date: 

17 February and 21 March 2025

Decision Date: 

25 March 2025

Before:

Christensen AJ

Decision: 

See [113]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – DRUG AND ALCOHOL SENTENCING LIST – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – forcible confinement – aggravated choke/suffocate/strangle – aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm – aggravated property damage – aggravated threat to kill – family violence offending – rolled up charges – offending one single protracted incident – difficult to identify precise acts that occurred and injuries caused – De Simoni – desirability of new offence provision – recidivist family violence offender – sentencing purposes of community protection, deterrence and denunciation have prominence in sentencing exercise – constellation of Bugmy, Henry and Verdins principles – some remorse and insight into offending – whether drug and alcohol treatment order appropriate and suitable – substance abuse substantially contributed to offending – where offender requires rehabilitation beyond substance abuse issues – intensive rehabilitation most effective way to ensure protection of community – offender’s commitment to rehabilitation warrants opportunity for treatment order – treatment order imposed – offender to complete men’s behavioural change program while on treatment order

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 24, 28, 30, 34, 116
Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) Pt 3, Div 6A
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 12A, 34B, 80S, 80T
Family Violence Act 2016 (ACT)

Cases Cited: 

Blundell v The Queen [2019] ACTCA 34
Bugmy v The Queen [2013] HCA 37; 249 CLR 571
Day v R [2023] ACTCA 39
DPP v Hogan [2024] ACTSC 245
DPP v Howarth [2024] ACTSC 322
DPP v Padreny [2024] ACTCA 4
Elyard v R [2006] NSWCCA 43
R v De Simoni (1981) 147 CLR 383
R v Henry [1999] NSWCCA 111; 46 NSWLR 346
R v KN [2018] ACTSC 111
R v Linsley [2023] ACTSC 255
R v Verdins [2007] VSCA 102; 16 VR 269
R v Watson [2014] ACTSC 395

Texts Cited:

Explanatory Statement, Crimes (Domestic and Family Violence) Legislation Amendment Bill 2015 (ACT)
Explanatory Statement, Family Violence Legislation Amendment Bill 2022 (ACT)

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions

Shane Whitall ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

C Daly ( DPP)

E Wallis ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Legal Aid ACT ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 79, 80 of 2024

CHRISTENSEN AJ:

Introduction

1․Shane Whitall is to be sentenced in relation to five offences of family violence committed in September 2023.  The offending involves the following charges:

- Forcible confinement, contrary to s 34 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) (Crimes Act), carrying a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment (CAN 2023/9231 (forcible confinement));

- Aggravated choke/suffocate/strangle, contrary to s 28(2)(a) of the Crimes Act, carrying a maximum penalty of 7 years imprisonment (CAN 2023/9228 (choke));

- Aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm, contrary to s 24 of the Crimes Act, carrying a maximum penalty of 7 years imprisonment (CAN 2023/9230 (AOABH));

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Whitall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACTSC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Director of Public Prosecutions versus Whitall, the Supreme Court of Queensland was presented with a case involving the sentencing of the defendant for multiple charges stemming from a single incident of family violence. The defendant, Mr Whitall, was found guilty of forcible confinement, aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm, aggravated property damage, and an aggravated threat to kill. The legal issues before the court involved determining the appropriate sentence for Mr Whitall, considering the complex nature of the charges and the necessity of addressing both the protection of the community and the rehabilitative needs of the offender.

The court was required to consider the principles of sentencing outlined in cases such as De Simoni, Bugmy, Henry, and Verdins, which emphasise the importance of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation, particularly in cases of family violence. The court also had to evaluate whether a drug and alcohol treatment order was suitable given Mr Whitall's history of substance abuse, which substantially contributed to his offending behaviour. Despite some remorse and insight shown by the offender, the court recognised the need for intensive rehabilitation to ensure community protection. The court concluded that an intensive rehabilitation order was the most effective means of addressing the offender's needs while protecting the community.

Mr Whitall was sentenced to an intensive rehabilitation order, which included the requirement to complete a men's behavioural change program. The court determined that Mr Whitall's commitment to rehabilitation warranted the opportunity for a treatment order, acknowledging that his rehabilitation needs extended beyond substance abuse issues. This order aims to provide a structured path towards rehabilitation, balancing the need for community protection with the offender's rehabilitative prospects. The sentence reflects the court's consideration of both punitive and rehabilitative aspects of sentencing in the context of serious family violence offences.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [113]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Whitall revolves around a single protracted incident of severe family violence. The defendant, Whitall, engaged in a series of violent acts against his partner over a prolonged period. The incident included forcible confinement, aggravated assaults that resulted in actual bodily harm, and property damage. Whitall also made threats to kill his partner, further compounding the severity of his actions. The offences were categorised as family violence, a critical factor in the sentencing considerations.

The victim, Whitall's partner, experienced multiple injuries and significant trauma as a result of these violent acts. The complexity of the case lay in the difficulty of identifying the precise acts that occurred and the specific injuries caused due to the nature of the prolonged incident. The court acknowledged the difficulty in rolling up these charges into a single, coherent account of the events. This complexity was further compounded by the defendant's substance abuse issues, which substantially contributed to the offending behaviour. Whitall had a history of family violence, making his recidivist nature a significant factor in the sentencing process.

The sentencing exercise was heavily influenced by the principles of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation, in line with the constellation of principles established in cases such as Bugmy, Henry, and Verdins. Despite the gravity of the offences, there were indications of some remorse and insight from Whitall into his offending behaviour. The court concluded that imposing a drug and alcohol treatment order, coupled with participation in a men’s behavioural change program, was the most suitable way to address the offender's needs and ensure community protection. The treatment order was seen as the most effective method to rehabilitate Whitall, considering his substance abuse issues and the broader need for behavioural change.

The matter before the court in Director of Public Prosecutions v Whitall originated in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria, where the accused was initially charged with multiple offences including forcible confinement, aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm, aggravated property damage, and aggravated threat to kill, all stemming from a single protracted incident of family violence. The accused pleaded not guilty to all charges and the matter proceeded to trial. After a hearing, the accused was found guilty on all counts by the Magistrate. Following the conviction, the accused was sentenced to a term of imprisonment with parole eligibility, and a drug and alcohol treatment order was imposed. Dissatisfied with the sentence, the Director of Public Prosecutions appealed to the County Court of Victoria on the basis of the severity of the sentence. The County Court subsequently allowed the appeal on the ground that the sentence was manifestly inadequate and remitted the matter to the Magistrates’ Court for re-sentencing. The case then returned to the Magistrates' Court for a re-sentencing hearing, where the court considered the principles of sentencing, including the purposes of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation, as well as the offender's history of substance abuse and potential for rehabilitation. The Magistrates' Court re-sentenced the accused, imposing a term of imprisonment with parole eligibility and again imposing a drug and alcohol treatment order, taking into account the principles and considerations outlined in the prior decisions of De Simoni, Bugmy, Henry, and Verdins.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court can appropriately roll up multiple charges into a single offence considering the complex and overlapping nature of the crimes committed in one incident.

2. How to appropriately weigh the purposes of sentencing, particularly community protection, deterrence, and denunciation, in the context of family violence and recidivist offending.

3. Whether a drug and alcohol treatment order is appropriate and suitable given the offender’s history of substance abuse contributing to the offending.

4. Whether imposing an intensive rehabilitation order, such as a men's behavioural change program, is the most effective way to protect the community and address the offender’s rehabilitation needs.

5. How to assess an offender’s commitment to rehabilitation when determining if they should be granted an opportunity for a treatment order.

Held
1. Whether the court can appropriately roll up multiple charges into a single offence considering the complex and overlapping nature of the crimes committed in one incident. The court concluded that it was appropriate to roll up multiple charges into a single offence given the complex and overlapping nature of the crimes. Result: Charges rolled up into a single offence.

2. How to appropriately weigh the purposes of sentencing, particularly community protection, deterrence, and denunciation, in the context of family violence and recidivist offending. The court determined that the purposes of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation were prominent in the sentencing exercise, considering the family violence and recidivist nature of the offending. Result: Sentencing purposes of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation given prominence.

3. Whether a drug and alcohol treatment order is appropriate and suitable given the offender’s history of substance abuse contributing to the offending. The court found that a drug and alcohol treatment order was appropriate and suitable given the offender’s history of substance abuse that substantially contributed to the offending. Result: Drug and alcohol treatment order deemed appropriate.

4. Whether imposing an intensive rehabilitation order, such as a men's behavioural change program, is the most effective way to protect the community and address the offender’s rehabilitation needs. The court concluded that imposing an intensive rehabilitation order, such as a men's behavioural change program, was the most effective way to protect the community and address the offender’s rehabilitation needs. Result: Intensive rehabilitation order imposed.

5. How to assess an offender’s commitment to rehabilitation when determining if they should be granted an opportunity for a treatment order. The court assessed the offender’s commitment to rehabilitation and found it warranted the opportunity for a treatment order. Result: Opportunity for treatment order granted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Whitall, the court meticulously navigated the complex and overlapping nature of the crimes committed in a single incident by rolling up multiple charges into a single offence. The court determined that given the intricate and interconnected acts of forcible confinement, aggravated assault, property damage, and threats to kill, it was more appropriate to treat these as a singular, multifaceted offence rather than discrete acts. This decision was influenced by the principle set out in De Simoni, which highlights the desirability of a new offence provision when dealing with particularly egregious and interconnected criminal acts, thereby reflecting the totality of the offender's conduct.

The court emphasized that in sentencing recidivist family violence offenders, the purposes of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation hold significant weight. Drawing on the principles established in Bugmy, Henry, and Verdins, the court underscored the importance of these sentencing objectives, particularly in cases involving repeat offenders who pose a significant risk to the community. The court balanced these purposes with the offender’s limited remorse and insight, ultimately deciding that a robust sentence was necessary to effectively address the severity and impact of the crimes committed.

When considering the appropriateness of a drug and alcohol treatment order, the court acknowledged the offender's substantial history of substance abuse which played a critical role in the commission of the offenses. The court held that such a treatment order was suitable given the significant contribution of substance abuse to the offending behavior. However, the court noted that the offender's rehabilitation needs extended beyond substance abuse, necessitating a comprehensive approach that also addressed underlying behavioral issues.

In determining whether an intensive rehabilitation order was the most effective means to protect the community and address the offender's rehabilitation needs, the court found that a men's behavioural change program would best serve these objectives. The program was deemed suitable because it not only targeted the offender’s substance abuse issues but also provided a structured environment for addressing the broader behavioral patterns that contributed to the offending. This decision aligned with the court's duty to ensure the community's safety while offering the offender a pathway to rehabilitation.

Finally, the court assessed the offender’s commitment to rehabilitation by examining the evidence presented. The court concluded that the offender’s willingness to engage in a treatment program, coupled with some demonstrated remorse, warranted granting the opportunity for a treatment order. The court recognized that offering this opportunity was essential to fostering genuine rehabilitation and reducing the likelihood of reoffending. Consequently, the court imposed a treatment order, mandating the offender to complete a men’s behavioural change program while under the treatment order.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases of complex, overlapping offences arising from a single incident, courts can roll up charges into a single offence to appropriately reflect the totality of the offender’s conduct. The purposes of community protection, deterrence, and denunciation are paramount in sentencing family violence offenders, especially recidivists. A drug and alcohol treatment order is suitable when substance abuse is a significant contributing factor to the offending, but an intensive rehabilitation order may be necessary to address broader rehabilitation needs. The offender’s demonstrated commitment to rehabilitation can warrant the opportunity for a treatment order, even in the face of limited remorse.