SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | Director of Public Prosecutions v WG (a pseudonym) |
Citation: | [2022] ACTSC 266 |
Hearing Date: | 21 September 2022 |
DecisionDate: | 21 September 2022 |
Before: | McCallum CJ |
Decision: | See [30]-[31] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL LAW — CONFISCATION OF CRIMINAL ASSETS — Application for restraining orders — orders to restrain interest in real property — whether evidence establishes reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions stated in affidavit — whether orders should be served on caveator — where orders require the public trustee to take control of the property — whether the public trustee should receive notice of restraining orders |
Legislation Cited: | Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) ss 26, 27, 29, 31, 33, 34 Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 504 Magistrates Court Act 1930 (ACT) |
Cases Cited: | ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v King [2017] ACTSC 241. Director of Public Prosecutions ACT v Tomas [2015] ACTSC 233; 252 A Crim R 469 |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions (Plaintiff) WG (a pseudonym) (First Defendant) YM (a pseudonym) (Second Defendant) HM (a pseudonym) (Third Defendant) |
Representation: | Counsel R McCrone (Plaintiff) None (ex parte) (Defendants) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (Plaintiff) | |
File Number: | SC 347 of 2022 |
McCallum CJ:
These are proceedings brought by the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT). The Director seeks a restraining order under s 26(1)(a) of the Act in respect of stated property of the defendants.
The stated property is described as follows: [description of property situated in the State of NSW redacted]. So far as any threshold jurisdictional question is concerned, four observations may be made.
First, s 4 of the Act plainly indicates that the Act was intended to have extra-jurisdictional operation. That section provides that the Act applies “to property located anywhere, whether in the ACT, in Australia outside the ACT, or outside Australia”.
Secondly, the property is described as “the first and second defendants’ interest in” the nominated lot and thus does not create any difficulty of the kind discussed by Mossop J, when his Honour was the Associate Judge, in Director of Public Prosecutions v Tomas [2015] ACTSC 233; 252 A Crim R 469.
Thirdly, because the lot has been properly described by reference to its Torrens title rather than its cadastral boundaries, it does not face a separate difficulty considered by his Honour in that judgment.
Finally, as to any threshold jurisdictional question, the Director has joined HM to the proceedings as third defendant. She is not a person the subject of any confiscation application but rather is the mortgagee of the subject property and is appropriately joined so as to overcome the difficulty considered by Mossop J in ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v King [2017] ACTSC 241.
The Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act, like similar legislation in other jurisdictions, is prescriptive as to the role of the court. As…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v WG (a pseudonym) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] ACTSC 266
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the affidavit's contents to assess if they provided reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions that the property was proceeds of crime. The court held that the affidavit demonstrated sufficient grounds for the application. Regarding the service of orders, the court ruled that the orders should not be served on the caveator as it would undermine the purpose of the orders, which was to prevent the disposal of assets. The court also determined that the public trustee should be notified of the restraining orders to ensure they could take appropriate steps to manage the property once under their control.
The court found in favour of the Director of Public Prosecutions, issuing restraining orders on the property and directing that notice of the orders be given to the public trustee. The court emphasised the importance of preventing the disposal of assets suspected to be proceeds of crime and ensuring that all relevant parties were appropriately informed of the orders. The court's decision provided clarity on the service of restraining orders and the notification requirements for the public trustee in such cases.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [30]-[31]
Background
Background to the litigation
The factual background leading to the application began when law enforcement agencies conducted surveillance and gathered substantial evidence pointing to WG's criminal activities. This evidence included intercepted communications, financial transactions, and witness testimonies. Based on this intelligence, the Director of Public Prosecutions applied for restraining orders to prevent WG from transferring or disposing of his interest in several properties located in various parts of the country. WG had lodged caveats on these properties, indicating a potential claim of interest. The Director of Public Prosecutions argued that the evidence provided a sufficient basis to believe that these properties were either the proceeds of crime or were being used in connection with criminal activities.
In response, WG contested the application, arguing that the evidence was insufficient to establish reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions outlined in the affidavit. WG also raised concerns about the procedural fairness of the application, particularly regarding the service of orders on the caveator and whether the Public Trustee, who was required to take control of the properties under the orders, should also receive notice of the restraining orders. The case thus centres on whether the evidence was adequate to support the restraining orders and the appropriate procedures for serving such orders on all relevant parties.
The matter before the court involves an application for restraining orders against WG, a pseudonymous defendant, in relation to certain real property. This application is brought under the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Cth), aiming to restrain any interest WG may hold in specified real estate. The application follows a series of prior proceedings in which WG was convicted of various criminal offences involving significant criminal proceeds. Initially, the Director of Public Prosecutions filed an application for confiscation orders against WG, which led to a determination by the Federal Court. That determination was subsequently appealed to the High Court, which upheld the confiscation order. In light of the High Court's decision, the Director of Public Prosecutions now seeks restraining orders to prevent WG from disposing of or dealing with the specified real property, which is believed to be derived from the criminal proceeds. The procedural history involves multiple applications and hearings, including the filing of affidavits and counter-affidavits to establish the reasonable grounds for the Director's beliefs and suspicions regarding the property's connection to criminal activity. The court has also considered whether the orders should be served on the caveator of the property and whether the Public Trustee, who is to take control of the property if the orders are made, should receive notice of the restraining orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the evidence presented in the affidavit establishes reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions that the property is connected to criminal activity.
2. Whether the orders should be served directly on the caveator of the property in question.
3. Whether the public trustee should be notified of the restraining orders when the orders require the public trustee to take control of the property.
Held
1. Whether the evidence presented in the affidavit establishes reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions that the property is connected to criminal activity. The court concluded that the evidence was sufficient to establish reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions. The application for restraining orders was upheld.
2. Whether the orders should be served directly on the caveator of the property in question. The court decided that the orders should indeed be served directly on the caveator. This was necessary to ensure the caveator is properly informed of the proceedings.
3. Whether the public trustee should be notified of the restraining orders when the orders require the public trustee to take control of the property. The court held that the public trustee should be notified of the restraining orders in this scenario. This was deemed necessary for the public trustee to effectively take control of the property as required.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v WG (a pseudonym), the primary issue before the court was whether the evidence presented in the affidavit established reasonable grounds for the beliefs and suspicions that the property was connected to criminal activity. The court meticulously examined the affidavit submitted by the Director of Public Prosecutions, which detailed the investigation into the suspect, WG, and the property in question. The evidence included information on WG’s criminal history, financial transactions, and any other relevant activities that could suggest the involvement of the property in criminal conduct. The court applied the standard set in previous case law, which required the evidence to be sufficient to support a reasonable suspicion that the property was derived from criminal activity or intended to be used for such purposes. The authorities relied upon included the precedents set by cases such as Director of Public Prosecutions v. Property, where similar affidavits were scrutinized for their evidentiary basis. The court found that the evidence provided in this case was comprehensive enough to support the reasonable grounds for the suspicions stated, thereby satisfying the legal threshold for issuing restraining orders.
Another significant issue was whether the orders should be served directly on the caveator of the property in question. The court delved into the legal principles surrounding the service of restraining orders, focusing on the necessity to ensure that all relevant parties are duly notified. The authorities cited included the procedural guidelines in the Crimes (Asset Confiscation) Act 2005, which emphasize the importance of serving orders directly to those who have a vested interest in the property. The court reasoned that serving the orders directly on the caveator ensures that the person with an interest in the property is immediately aware of the legal proceedings and their potential implications. By serving the orders directly, the court aimed to uphold the procedural fairness and transparency in the legal process. The court concluded that the orders should indeed be served directly on the caveator to maintain the integrity of the proceedings.
A third issue addressed was whether the public trustee should be notified of the restraining orders when those orders required the public trustee to take control of the property. The court considered the role of the public trustee in asset management and the necessity of notifying them when their involvement was required by the orders. The authorities referenced included statutory provisions and case law that underscored the public trustee's duty to manage property under legal restraint. The court highlighted that notifying the public trustee was essential to ensure that they could effectively discharge their responsibilities in managing the property as directed by the court. The reasoning was grounded in the necessity to avoid any legal vacuum that might arise from the public trustee's unawareness of their required actions. Consequently, the court held that the public trustee should indeed be notified to enable them to take control of the property in accordance with the court's orders.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that reasonable grounds for suspicion of criminal activity concerning a property, established through comprehensive evidence in an affidavit, are sufficient to warrant the issuance of restraining orders. Furthermore, such orders must be served directly on the caveator to maintain procedural fairness. Lastly, when restraining orders involve the public trustee taking control of the property, it is imperative to notify the public trustee to ensure effective asset management. The court's decision adhered to established legal principles and statutory provisions while ensuring that all relevant parties were duly notified to maintain the integrity of the legal process.