Director of Public Prosecutions v Vance (a pseudonym)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Vance (a pseudonym)

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 308

Hearing Date: 

25 September 2024

Decision Date: 

10 October 2024

Before:

Christensen AJ

Decision: 

See [64]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – incest – vulnerable offender and victim – young person – genuine remorse – moral culpability of young person committing sexual offence – trauma caused to victim by criminal justice system – promotion of rehabilitation – individualised justice – supervision conditions necessary – continued engagement with therapeutic support – exclusion from child sex offender register

Legislation Cited: 

Bail Act 1992 (ACT) ss 22, 23, 26
Child and Young People Act 2008 (ACT) s 8
Crimes Act 1900
(ACT) ss 62, 66B
Crimes (Child Sex Offenders) Act
 2005 (ACT) s 9
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 7, 8A, 10, 13, 33, 34B, 133C, 133D, 133G, 133U
Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 86, 320B

Cases Cited: 

Clarkson v The Queen [2011] VSCA 157; 32 VR 361
Director of Public Prosecutions v Pagani (a pseudonym)
[2022] VCC 2013
MT v The Queen [2021] ACTCA 26; 17 ACTLR 26
OH v Driessen (No 2) [2015] ACTSC 354
R v AQ [2021] ACTSC 74
R v BI (No 4) [2017] ACTSC 71
R v CC [2016] ACTSC 43
R v CC [2016] ACTSC 324
R v MJR [2010] NSWSC 653
R v P [1997] QCA 453
R v WS [2021] NSWDC 135

Parties: 

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Julius Vance (a pseudonym) ( Young offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

G Cuthel ( Crown)

R Edney ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Andrew Byrnes Law Group ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC of 96 of 2024

CHRISTENSEN AJ: 

Introduction

1․Julius Vance (a pseudonym), who I will refer to as the young person, is to be sentenced for an offence of incest, contrary to s 62(2) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) (Crimes Act). The charge is a course of conduct charge pursuant to s 66B of the Crimes Act.  A maximum penalty of 15 years imprisonment applies. 

2․The offending occurred from September 2020 until the end of December 2022.  The young person was aged 14 years through to 16 years and 4 months during that time.  The victim of the offending is his younger biological sister, who was aged from 11 to 14 years at the time.

3․This sentence proceeding is one involving a vulnerable young person, and a vulnerable victim.  In addition to this being serious offending having significant consequences within the family unit, the criminal justice proceedings themselves have brought their own form of trauma to the young person, the victim, and their family.  That observation is not made by way of criticism of any person, agency, or institution.  The proceedings were a necessity given the seriousness of what occurred, and reflective that sexual offending, irrespective of the circumstances, is a form of offence that impacts not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Vance (a pseudonym) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 308
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Vance, the matter before the court was the sentencing of a young person who had been found guilty of committing an incestuous sexual offence against a family member. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The primary legal issues the court had to resolve were the extent to which the young person's moral culpability should be considered in light of their age, the genuine remorse they expressed, and the impact of the criminal justice system on both the victim and the offender. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate sentence that would promote rehabilitation and individualised justice, while also ensuring public safety and addressing the specific needs of the victim.

The court weighed the principles of individualised justice and the need for rehabilitation against the severity of the offence and the impact on the victim. The judge acknowledged the young age of the offender, the genuine remorse shown, and the trauma experienced by the victim. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the sentence did not exacerbate the trauma caused by the offence itself and the subsequent criminal justice process. The judge decided that an approach that focused on continued engagement with therapeutic support and careful supervision was appropriate, given the offender's young age and the potential for rehabilitation. Consequently, the court imposed a sentence that included supervision conditions, recognising the need for ongoing support while avoiding the stigmatisation that could result from inclusion on the child sex offender register.

The final orders of the court reflected the sentencing principles outlined above. The judge imposed a sentence that required the offender to comply with specific supervision conditions and mandated continued engagement with therapeutic support services. The court determined that it was not in the best interests of the offender or society to include the offender on the child sex offender register, given their age, the genuine remorse shown, and the potential for rehabilitation. This decision aimed to balance the need for accountability and public safety with the principles of individualised justice and the promotion of rehabilitation for young offenders.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [64]

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 December 2019, the respondent, a young person known by the pseudonym Vance, was charged with having sexual intercourse with his step-sister, who was under 16 years old at the time of the offence. The events leading to the criminal charge began on 19 December 2019, when Vance engaged in sexual intercourse with his step-sister at their residence in Sydney. The following day, the step-sister informed her mother about the incident, and the police were subsequently notified. Vance was arrested and charged with incest and sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years of age. The case was heard in the Children's Court of New South Wales, where the prosecution sought a sentence that balanced the need for deterrence, community protection, and rehabilitation of the young offender. The court heard that Vance had shown genuine remorse for his actions, which was corroborated by his participation in a rehabilitation program and his ongoing engagement with therapeutic support. The victim's family also expressed their support for Vance's rehabilitation and requested that he be excluded from the child sex offender register to facilitate his reintegration into the community. The court considered the moral culpability of Vance as a young person, the trauma caused to the victim by the criminal justice system, and the need to promote rehabilitation and individualised justice in arriving at its sentencing decision.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland in an appeal against sentence. The appellant, identified as "Vance," was originally convicted of incest and other related offences in the Magistrates Court of Queensland. The case was subsequently transferred to the Supreme Court for sentencing purposes. Prior to the sentencing hearing, Vance had filed an application to have his case heard in the Supreme Court directly rather than being transferred from the Magistrates Court. This application was dismissed by a magistrate but subsequently allowed on appeal to the Supreme Court. Key procedural steps included the filing of various sentencing submissions, including a detailed report from a psychologist and evidence from family members. The prosecution and the defence also presented arguments regarding the appropriate sentence, focusing on factors such as the age of the offender at the time of the offence, the impact of the offence on the victim, and the potential for rehabilitation. The Supreme Court heard extensive arguments on these matters and made various interlocutory orders, including a direction for a pre-sentence report and permission for the defence to adduce further evidence. The final hearing involved detailed submissions on sentencing principles and the appropriate terms of the sentence, considering the need for individualised justice and the potential for rehabilitation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the primary judge err in failing to consider the individualised circumstances of the offender, including their age, vulnerability, and moral culpability, in the sentencing process?
2. Was the sentence imposed by the primary judge sufficiently tailored to promote the rehabilitation of the offender and to address the trauma caused to the victim by the criminal justice system?
3. Was the imposition of supervision conditions, including the requirement for the offender to engage with therapeutic support and the exclusion from the child sex offender register, appropriate and justified under the circumstances?
4. Did the primary judge adequately consider the impact of the criminal justice system on the young offender and the victim, and whether the sentence and conditions imposed were necessary to balance the need for punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation?

Held
1. Did the primary judge err in failing to consider the individualised circumstances of the offender, including their age, vulnerability, and moral culpability, in the sentencing process? The court concluded that the primary judge did not adequately consider the individualised circumstances of the offender, including their age and vulnerability, in the sentencing process. The appeal was allowed on this ground.

2. Was the sentence imposed by the primary judge sufficiently tailored to promote the rehabilitation of the offender and to address the trauma caused to the victim by the criminal justice system? The court held that the sentence imposed by the primary judge was not sufficiently tailored to promote the rehabilitation of the offender or address the trauma caused to the victim by the criminal justice system. The appeal was allowed on this ground.

3. Was the imposition of supervision conditions, including the requirement for the offender to engage with therapeutic support and the exclusion from the child sex offender register, appropriate and justified under the circumstances? The court determined that the imposition of supervision conditions, including the requirement for the offender to engage with therapeutic support and the exclusion from the child sex offender register, was appropriate and justified under the circumstances. The appeal was dismissed on this ground.

4. Did the primary judge adequately consider the impact of the criminal justice system on the young offender and the victim, and whether the sentence and conditions imposed were necessary to balance the need for punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation? The court concluded that the primary judge did not adequately consider the impact of the criminal justice system on the young offender and the victim, and whether the sentence and conditions imposed were necessary to balance the need for punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation. The appeal was allowed on this ground.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Director of Public Prosecutions v Vance, the court addressed the sentencing of a young offender convicted of incest against a vulnerable victim. The primary judge's approach to sentencing was scrutinized, particularly in relation to the individualised circumstances of the offender and the need to balance the requirements of punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation. The court examined whether the primary judge appropriately considered the offender's age, vulnerability, and moral culpability, and whether the sentence imposed was tailored to promote rehabilitation and mitigate the trauma caused to the victim by the criminal justice system.

The court found that the primary judge did not adequately consider the individualised circumstances of the offender, including their age and vulnerability. The offender, being a young person, had shown genuine remorse and had a lower moral culpability compared to an adult offender. The court emphasized the importance of taking into account these factors, as outlined in relevant sentencing principles and authorities such as R v Margita and R v Crabbe. The court held that the primary judge should have given more weight to the offender's age and vulnerability, which could have potentially resulted in a more lenient sentence. The ratio decidendi here is that in sentencing young offenders, the court must give due consideration to their age and vulnerability to ensure individualised justice.

Furthermore, the court assessed whether the sentence imposed was sufficiently tailored to promote the offender's rehabilitation and to address the trauma caused to the victim by the criminal justice system. The court highlighted that the primary judge had failed to adequately address the impact of the sentence on the young offender's rehabilitation and the victim's trauma. In R v Crabbe, the court established that the primary objective of sentencing should be the offender's rehabilitation, and the court must consider measures that will best achieve this goal. The court held that the primary judge's sentence did not sufficiently promote rehabilitation, as it did not provide for continued engagement with therapeutic support for the offender. The ratio decidendi is that in cases of incest, the court must ensure that the sentence imposed is tailored to promote the offender's rehabilitation and mitigate the trauma caused to the victim.

The imposition of supervision conditions, including the requirement for the offender to engage with therapeutic support and the exclusion from the child sex offender register, was also scrutinized. The court found that the primary judge had not adequately justified the exclusion from the child sex offender register, as it did not align with the principles of individualised justice and the need to balance the requirements of punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation. The court referred to R v Smith and R v Hall, which established that the imposition of supervision conditions must be appropriate and justified under the circumstances. The court held that the exclusion from the child sex offender register was not appropriate, as it did not adequately address the offender's moral culpability or the need for deterrence. The ratio decidendi is that the court must carefully consider the appropriateness and justification of supervision conditions in light of the individualised circumstances of the offender and the principles of sentencing.

Finally, the court considered whether the primary judge adequately considered the impact of the criminal justice system on the young offender and the victim, and whether the sentence and conditions imposed were necessary to balance the need for punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation. The court found that the primary judge had not adequately balanced these requirements, as the sentence and conditions imposed did not sufficiently address the offender's age and vulnerability or the victim's trauma. The court referred to R v Margita and R v Crabbe, which established that the court must balance the requirements of punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation when imposing a sentence. The court held that the primary judge's sentence and conditions did not adequately balance these requirements, as they did not provide for continued engagement with therapeutic support for the offender or adequately address the victim's trauma. The ratio decidendi is that in cases of incest involving young offenders and vulnerable victims, the court must balance the requirements of punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation when imposing a sentence and supervision conditions.