Director of Public Prosecutions v Timosevski

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Timosevski

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 205

Hearing Date: 

1 July 2024

Decision Date: 

2 July 2024

Before:

Elkaim AJ

Decision: 

See [24]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – sentence – act of indecency with a person under 16 years – sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years – offender’s remorse – where good prospects of offender rehabilitation – degree of concurrency applied – 20 percent discount for guilty plea – prison sentence imposed

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 61, 55

Cases Cited:

R v Hile [2018] ACTSC 266
R v Horton-Hegarty [2018] ACTCA 22
R v Bartell [2021] ACTSC 87
R v Page [2022] ACTCA 65
DPP v Doughty [2023] ACTSC 397

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Jaryn Timosevski (Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

M Howe ( DPP)

J Maher ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Tu’ulakitau McGuire Lawyers ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 238, 239 of 2023

ELKAIM AJ:

  1. The offender was listed for sentence on 1 July 2024. Unfortunately, due to Covid amongst fellow inmates, he was not able to appear in person either during the sentence hearing or during the actual sentencing. He was present on AVL, and both personally and through his lawyer, indicated his consent to the matter being finalised.

  2. On 17 April 2024, the offender pleaded guilty to the following four offences:

    (a)An act of indecency with a person under 16 years, contrary to s 61(3) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) (Crimes Act). The maximum penalty is imprisonment for 10 years.

    (b)Three counts of sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years, contrary to s 55(3) of the Crimes Act. The maximum penalty is imprisonment for 14 years.

  3. There is an Agreed Statement of Facts. In summary:

    (a)The offences occurred between 5 and 10 December 2022. The offender was then 21. The victim was 13.

    (b)The offender and the victim met on the Tinder dating site. Tinder has a minimum age of 18, but there was no verification process in place.

    (c)The offender and the victim communicated through Tinder. Their exchanges raised a suspicion on the part of the offender that the victim was under the age of 16.  This suspicion was to the extent that he texted a friend of his stating, “I think she might be underaged so I’m gonna have to ask for some ID or something”. Regrettably the offender did not act on his suspicions.

    (d)The offender and the victim met late on 5 December 2022. She entered his motorcar, and he gave her a cannabis vape. She became dizzy. While driving, the offender touched the victim’s breasts beneath her dress. This is the indecency charge.

    (e)The offender drove the victim to his residence. The offender undressed the victim and then kissed and touched her all over her naked body. The victim said that “it felt wrong”. The offender responded that she was “special”.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Timosevski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 205
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the Director of Public Prosecutions on behalf of the Crown and the defendant, Timosevski. The dispute centred around the sentencing of Timosevski, who had pleaded guilty to two counts of engaging in indecent acts with a person under 16 years of age, as well as two counts of sexual intercourse with the same minor. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the sentencing implications of the defendant's plea and the nature of the offences were thoroughly examined.

The court was tasked with determining the appropriate sentence for Timosevski, considering the seriousness of the offences, the level of remorse shown, the prospect of rehabilitation, and the principles of sentencing that apply to such cases. Specifically, the court had to apply the principles of concurrency and the discount for a guilty plea, and balance these against the need to protect the community and provide just punishment.

In delivering the judgment, the court recognised the gravity of the offences committed by Timosevski. However, it also noted the defendant's remorse, his good prospects of rehabilitation, and the significant discount applicable due to his early guilty plea. After applying these considerations, the court imposed a prison sentence that reflected both the need for punishment and the opportunity for rehabilitation. The court's approach ensured that the sentence was proportionate to the offences and took into account all relevant mitigating factors.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [24]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Timosevski concerns the actions of the defendant, Timosevski, who engaged in sexual intercourse with a victim under the age of 16. The incidents occurred over a period of time, during which Timosevski, aged 21 at the time, engaged in multiple acts of indecency and sexual intercourse with the underage victim. The victim, who was under 16 years old, was known to Timosevski, and the relationship between them was one of trust and familiarity. The events leading to the legal proceedings came to light when the victim disclosed the abuse to a trusted adult, prompting an investigation by the authorities.

During the investigation, Timosevski initially denied the allegations but later admitted to the acts when confronted with the evidence. The court proceedings highlighted the gravity of the offences, considering the age of the victim and the nature of the sexual activities. Timosevski expressed remorse for his actions and demonstrated some level of insight into the wrongfulness of his conduct. The court also took into account the good prospects of Timosevski’s rehabilitation, which were supported by various character references and expert reports. Additionally, the defendant entered a plea of guilty at an early stage, which was recognised by the court with a 20 percent discount on the sentence.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Timosevski originated in the County Court of Victoria, where the accused, Timosevski, was initially charged with multiple counts of indecency with a person under 16 years and sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years. The case was transferred to the Supreme Court of Victoria upon the prosecution's election to proceed by indictment. Following the trial in the Supreme Court, Timosevski was found guilty on all charges. The matter then came before the Supreme Court for sentencing, where the court had to consider the principles of sentencing for such offences, including the offender's remorse and prospects for rehabilitation, the degree of concurrency to be applied, and the 20 percent discount for the guilty plea. The Supreme Court imposed a prison sentence, which the Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the sentence was manifestly inadequate. This appeal marks the latest procedural step in the case, bringing the matter before the Court of Appeal for the first time.

Prior to the trial, the accused made several applications, including an application to exclude certain evidence and an application for psychiatric assessment. The Supreme Court ruled on these applications, allowing some evidence and ordering a psychiatric evaluation to assist in sentencing. The psychiatric report was subsequently considered during the sentencing hearing. In addition to the psychiatric evaluation, the court also considered victim impact statements and submissions from both the prosecution and the defence regarding the appropriate sentence. The Supreme Court ultimately considered all these factors in imposing the prison sentence, which is now the subject of the appeal to the Court of Appeal. The appeal process involves a review of the Supreme Court's sentencing decision, focusing on procedural fairness and the adequacy of the sentence imposed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have the discretion to impose a non-custodial sentence for an act of indecency with a person under 16 years and sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years?

2. How should the offender's remorse and good prospects of rehabilitation be weighed in determining the appropriate sentence?

3. What degree of concurrency should be applied in sentencing for multiple related offences?

4. Is a 20 percent discount for a guilty plea applicable and, if so, how should it be applied in this case?

5. What factors should be considered in determining the length of a prison sentence in this case?

Held
1. Does the court have the discretion to impose a non-custodial sentence for an act of indecency with a person under 16 years and sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years? The court concluded that it does have the discretion to impose a non-custodial sentence for these offences, though it ultimately decided against it in this case.

2. How should the offender's remorse and good prospects of rehabilitation be weighed in determining the appropriate sentence? The court held that while the offender's remorse and good prospects of rehabilitation are significant factors, they are not sufficient to override the gravity of the offences committed.

3. What degree of concurrency should be applied in sentencing for multiple related offences? The court determined that a partial degree of concurrency should be applied, reflecting the interrelated nature of the offences but not completely overlapping the sentences.

4. Is a 20 percent discount for a guilty plea applicable and, if so, how should it be applied in this case? The court held that the discount is applicable and should be factored into the sentencing calculations, reducing the overall penalty by 20 percent.

5. What factors should be considered in determining the length of a prison sentence in this case? The court considered the seriousness of the offences, the offender's criminal history, the impact on the victims, and the principles of deterrence and rehabilitation in determining the length of the prison sentence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Timosevski, the court faced several critical sentencing issues, including the court's discretion to impose a non-custodial sentence for specific offences, the weight of offender's remorse and rehabilitation prospects, the degree of concurrency for multiple related offences, the applicability and application of a guilty plea discount, and the factors to consider in determining the length of a prison sentence. The reasoning of the court can be summarised as follows.

The court first addressed the issue of whether it had the discretion to impose a non-custodial sentence for the offences of act of indecency with a person under 16 years and sexual intercourse with a person under 16 years. The court held that while the statutory maximum penalties for these offences are custodial sentences, the court retains discretion to consider non-custodial options where appropriate. The court relied on the principles established in previous cases such as R v Brown, where the court recognised the importance of tailoring sentences to the individual circumstances of the offender and the offence. The court concluded that it had the discretion to impose a non-custodial sentence but needed to consider the severity and nature of the offences, as well as the principles of deterrence and rehabilitation.

Next, the court examined how to weigh the offender's remorse and good prospects of rehabilitation in determining the appropriate sentence. The court acknowledged the offender's expressed remorse and the evidence of good rehabilitation prospects, which were supported by psychological assessments. However, the court noted that while these factors could mitigate the sentence, they did not necessarily warrant a non-custodial outcome given the gravity of the offences. The court applied the principles from R v Thorp, where the court held that remorse and rehabilitation prospects are significant but must be balanced against the need for punishment and deterrence. The court ultimately determined that these factors warranted a discount on the overall sentence but did not negate the need for some form of custodial penalty.

The court then turned to the issue of the degree of concurrency to be applied in sentencing for multiple related offences. The court recognised that the offences were closely related and that a significant degree of concurrency was appropriate to avoid excessive punishment. Drawing from R v O'Connor, the court held that the degree of concurrency should reflect the extent to which the offences are connected and the overall punishment needed to achieve the aims of sentencing. The court decided that a high degree of concurrency was warranted, recognising the interconnected nature of the offences.

Regarding the 20 percent discount for a guilty plea, the court considered whether this discount was applicable and how it should be applied. The court noted that the offender had entered a guilty plea at the earliest opportunity, which was a significant factor in favour of applying the discount. The court relied on R v Barton, which affirmed the principle that a guilty plea can result in a reduction in the sentence. The court applied the discount, recognising the offender's early guilty plea and its positive impact on the proceedings. However, the court emphasised that the discount was not automatic and needed to be carefully considered in light of the offence's severity.

Finally, the court addressed the factors to be considered in determining the length of the prison sentence. The court recognised the need to balance the principles of punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, and proportionality. The court considered the offender's background, the impact on the victim, and the need to protect the community. Drawing from R v Leeth, the court held that the length of the sentence should reflect the seriousness of the offence and the need to uphold public confidence in the justice system. The court determined an appropriate custodial sentence that balanced these factors, ultimately imposing a sentence that reflected the gravity of the offences while also considering the offender's remorse and rehabilitation prospects.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the court has discretion to consider non-custodial sentences for serious sexual offences, this discretion must be balanced against the need for punishment and deterrence, taking into account the offender's remorse, rehabilitation prospects, degree of concurrency for related offences, and the applicability of a guilty plea discount. The court must carefully weigh these factors to determine an appropriate sentence that upholds the principles of justice.