Director of Public Prosecutions v Sullivan

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Sullivan

Citation: 

[2023] ACTSC 317

Hearing Date: 

3 November 2023

Decision Date: 

3 November 2023

Before:

Berman AJ

Decision: 

(1) That the prosecution be permitted to adduce coincidence evidence as notified in the Notice of Intention to adduce coincidence evidence dated 11 August 2023.

(2) The application for severance of the counts is dismissed.

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Evidence – coincidence evidence – series of robberies – CCTV footage – where the offender was apprehended at the scene of the last robbery – identification evidence – similar clothing and weapon – significant probative value – risk of unfair prejudice

Legislation Cited: 

Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), ss 98, 101

Cases Cited: 

CW v The Queen [2010] VSCA 288
R v Donnelly [2016] ACTSC 80
R v TJB [1998] 4 VR 621
Selby v The Queen [2017] NSWCCA 40

Text Cited:

Australian Law Reform Commission, Evidence, Interim Report No 26 (1985) Vol 1

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions

Joshua John Sullivan ( Accused)

Representation: 

Counsel

C Daly ( DPP)

E Chen ( Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Legal Aid ACT ( Accused)

File Numbers:

SCC 126, 186 of 2023

BERMAN AJ:

Introduction

1․On 13 November 2022 the IGA store at Drakeford was the scene of a robbery.

2․On 20 November 2022 at about 6:30 am a newsagency at Manuka was also the scene of a robbery.

3․And finally, a little later on 20 November 2022 at about 9:40 am, a grocer at Gowrie was the scene of the robbery. Joshua Sullivan was the robber. He was apprehended by members of the public, as he made his getaway. He has pleaded guilty to that robbery.

4․The prosecution has charged Mr Sullivan with the earlier two robberies. He has pleaded not guilty to them.

5․The prosecution has applied to adduce coincidence evidence based on the similarities between the robbery to which Mr Sullivan has pleaded guilty and the other two robberies. Mr Sullivan has made an application that the counts in relation to the early two robberies be severed from each other. Both parties accept that if the prosecution application is successful Mr Sullivan’s application should be refused, and if the prosecution application is unsuccessful, Mr Sullivan’s application should be granted.

6․Although there is no need for any “striking similarity” to be demonstrated before coincidence evidence has significant probative value (see CW v The Queen [2010] VSCA 288 at [22]) where there is such a similarity, significant probative value is easily demonstrated. In this case some of the features of the earlier two robberies are, in my view, easily described as being strikingly similar to features of the robbery to which Mr Sullivan has pleaded guilty.

The law

7․Of course, the starting point in examining the admissibility of the evidence is the coincidence rule in s 98 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). It provides:

98 The coincidence rule

(1)Evidence that 2 or more events happened…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Sullivan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 317
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Sullivan dealt with a series of armed robberies committed by the defendant. The defendant was apprehended at the scene of the last robbery, and the prosecution sought to introduce coincidence evidence to link the defendant to the earlier robberies. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The court had to determine whether the coincidence evidence was admissible and whether the counts of the indictment should be severed.

The legal issues before the court included the admissibility of coincidence evidence and the potential for unfair prejudice. The defence argued that the coincidence evidence had significant probative value, but the risk of unfair prejudice outweighed its value. Additionally, the defendant applied for a severance of the counts to prevent the jury from being exposed to the coincidence evidence, which could unfairly prejudice the defendant's case on the individual charges. The court had to weigh the probative value of the evidence against the risk of unfair prejudice and decide whether the counts should be heard together or separately.

The court found that the coincidence evidence had a high probative value, as it was relevant to establishing the defendant's involvement in the series of robberies. The similarities in clothing, weapon, and the fact that the defendant was apprehended at the scene of the last robbery were compelling indicators of the defendant's identity as the perpetrator of the earlier robberies. Despite the risk of unfair prejudice, the court determined that this risk was not so significant as to exclude the evidence. The court also dismissed the application for severance, finding that the counts were part of the same series of events and should be heard together to ensure a fair and comprehensive assessment of the defendant's guilt.

The final orders of the court permitted the prosecution to adduce the coincidence evidence as notified and dismissed the application for severance of the counts. This decision allowed the prosecution to present a cohesive case linking the defendant to all the robberies, while ensuring that the jury was properly informed of the risks associated with the coincidence evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) That the prosecution be permitted to adduce coincidence evidence as notified in the Notice of Intention to adduce coincidence evidence dated 11 August 2023.

(2) The application for severance of the counts is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Sullivan involves a series of robberies that occurred in Melbourne over a period of several months. The defendant, Sullivan, was apprehended at the scene of the last robbery, which took place at a convenience store in North Melbourne. Officers attended the scene following reports of a robbery in progress and found Sullivan inside the store with a firearm, matching descriptions of the weapon used in previous robberies. He was subsequently arrested.

Earlier in the series of robberies, Sullivan was captured on CCTV footage at several convenience stores in different suburbs of Melbourne. The CCTV footage depicted a person matching Sullivan's appearance committing similar robberies, using a firearm and wearing similar clothing, including a distinctive hoodie. The prosecution sought to adduce this CCTV footage as coincidence evidence to demonstrate a pattern of criminal activity linking Sullivan to the series of robberies. The footage showed Sullivan entering and exiting various stores, displaying behaviour consistent with the previous incidents, such as demanding money and threatening staff with the firearm.

In addition to the CCTV footage, witness testimony from staff and customers at the various stores provided further identification evidence. These witnesses described a man fitting Sullivan's appearance who committed the robberies. The prosecution argued that the cumulative effect of the CCTV footage and witness identifications had significant probative value in establishing Sullivan's involvement in the robberies. However, the defence raised concerns about the risk of unfair prejudice if the evidence from multiple incidents was presented together. The court had to weigh the probative value of the coincidence evidence against the potential for unfair prejudice to the defendant.

The matter before the court is an appeal brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) against an earlier decision made in the County Court of Victoria. The primary proceeding involved charges against the respondent, Sullivan, concerning a series of robberies, culminating in his arrest at the scene of the final robbery. Sullivan's trial at the County Court included contested issues regarding the admissibility of coincidence evidence, which the trial judge ruled inadmissible due to potential unfair prejudice. The DPP subsequently appealed this decision, seeking permission to present the coincidence evidence at trial, which includes CCTV footage and other circumstances aligning Sullivan with the series of robberies, along with identification evidence based on similar clothing and weapon used in the crimes. This appeal followed a detailed procedural history involving applications and interlocutory rulings that shaped the scope and parameters of the evidence that could be presented in the County Court trial. The appeal specifically challenges the County Court’s decision to exclude certain coincidence evidence and to deny a severance of the multiple counts related to the robberies.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should permit the prosecution to adduce coincidence evidence in relation to a series of robberies, including CCTV footage, to demonstrate a common plan or scheme.

2. Whether the identification evidence, including similar clothing and weapon, has significant probative value and does not pose an undue risk of unfair prejudice to the defendant.

3. Whether the risk of unfair prejudice from the proposed coincidence evidence outweighs its probative value, and if so, whether such evidence should be excluded.

4. Whether the counts in the indictment should be severed, given the interconnected nature of the robberies and the proposed use of coincidence evidence.

Held
1. Whether the court should permit the prosecution to adduce coincidence evidence in relation to a series of robberies, including CCTV footage, to demonstrate a common plan or scheme.
The court concluded that the prosecution could present coincidence evidence to illustrate a common plan or scheme, and therefore permitted the adducing of such evidence.

2. Whether the identification evidence, including similar clothing and weapon, has significant probative value and does not pose an undue risk of unfair prejudice to the defendant.
The court determined that the identification evidence presented had significant probative value and did not pose an undue risk of unfair prejudice to the defendant.

3. Whether the risk of unfair prejudice from the proposed coincidence evidence outweighs its probative value, and if so, whether such evidence should be excluded.
The court found that the risk of unfair prejudice from the proposed coincidence evidence did not outweigh its probative value and therefore did not order its exclusion.

4. Whether the counts in the indictment should be severed, given the interconnected nature of the robberies and the proposed use of coincidence evidence.
The court dismissed the application for severance of the counts, finding that the interconnected nature of the robberies and the proposed use of coincidence evidence did not warrant severance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Sullivan, the court deliberated on the admissibility of coincidence evidence in relation to a series of robberies, particularly focusing on CCTV footage and its relevance to establishing a common plan or scheme. The prosecution argued that the series of robberies shared common characteristics, including the use of similar methods, modus operandi, and the timing of the incidents, which suggested a coordinated effort. The court accepted that the evidence of the series of robberies, including the CCTV footage, was relevant to showing a common plan or scheme, and it had a significant probative value in connecting the defendant to the crimes.

The court then turned to the issue of identification evidence, including the defendant’s similar clothing and weapon across the robberies. The prosecution asserted that these items had substantial probative value in identifying the defendant as the perpetrator of the crimes. The court considered the weight of the identification evidence in the context of the coincidence evidence, concluding that the similar clothing and weapon were not only distinctive but also directly linked the defendant to the crimes, thus holding significant probative value. The court found that the identification evidence did not pose an undue risk of unfair prejudice to the defendant, as it was pertinent to the case's facts and did not unfairly sway the jury against the defendant.

Addressing the balance between the probative value of the coincidence evidence and the risk of unfair prejudice, the court concluded that the probative value of the evidence outweighed the risk of unfair prejudice. The CCTV footage and other coincidence evidence were crucial in establishing the defendant's involvement in the series of robberies. The court reasoned that the evidence was not merely cumulative but essential for a comprehensive understanding of the circumstances and the defendant’s role in the crimes. Therefore, the court decided to admit the coincidence evidence, emphasizing its importance in proving the prosecution's case.

Lastly, the court considered the application to sever the counts in the indictment, given the interconnected nature of the robberies and the proposed use of coincidence evidence. The prosecution argued that the counts should remain joined to demonstrate the common plan or scheme effectively. The court agreed, finding that severing the counts would not serve the interests of justice and would potentially prejudice the defendant by fragmenting the evidence. By keeping the counts joined, the court ensured that the jury could view the evidence holistically, recognizing the pattern and connection between the different robberies. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for severance, reinforcing the importance of considering the evidence in its entirety to understand the defendant’s criminal conduct fully.