Brown v the Queen
[2019] VSCA 286
Citation 1
…Brown v The Queen .[19] Standard sentence is but one of many factors to be taken into account in the sentencing process. [18](2011) 244 CLR 120. [19](2019) 59 VR 462, 470 [25, 55]. 126Section 11A governs the setting of the non-parole period where standard sentencing is engaged. 127I am required when so sentencing…
Gray (a pseudonym) v The Queen
[2018] VSCA 163
Citation 2
…This significant impact of rape on the victim needs to be given proper weight in sentencing, it cannot be overlooked or undervalued.' [15][2018] VSCA 163 [53]. [16][2009] VSCA 274 [18-19].…
The Queen v Putra Hendra
[2014] ACTSC 102
Citation 3
…tory scheme explained in Brown v The Queen .[19] Standard sentence is but one of many factors to be taken into account in the sentencing process. [18](2011) 244 CLR 120. [19](2019) 59 VR 462, 470 [25, 55]. 126Section 11A governs the setting of the non-parole period where standard sentencing is engaged. 127I am requir…
DPP v Moses
[2009] VSCA 274
Citation 4
…rape on the victim needs to be given proper weight in sentencing, it cannot be overlooked or undervalued.' [15][2018] VSCA 163 [53]. [16][2009] VSCA 274 [18-19].…
R v Verdins
[2007] VSCA 102
Citation 5
…Mr Halphen, I note, was not relying on the principles in R v Verdins & Ors [11] and that was an appropriate concession on the material before me. [11](2007) 16 VR 269 (' Verdins') . 90You speak to your parents daily and until the restrictions were introduced regarding COVID-19 in March 2020 they were visiting you o…
DPP v Toomey
[2006] VSCA 90
Citation 6
…, including DPP v DJK ,[4] which was referred to in DPP v Toomey ,[5] relevant to social rehabilitation. [4][2003] VSCA 109 [17-18]. [5][2006] VSCA 90. 56The effects upon a victim are a relevant sentencing consideration (see s.5 Sentencing Act 1991). I am conscious, however, I must not allow the effects upon a vi…
DPP v DJK
[2003] VSCA 109
Citation 7
…a victim of sexual offending, including DPP v DJK ,[4] which was referred to in DPP v Toomey ,[5] relevant to social rehabilitation. [4][2003] VSCA 109 [17-18]. [5][2006] VSCA 90. 56The effects upon a victim are a relevant sentencing consideration (see s.5 Sentencing Act 1991). I am conscious, however, I must not…
DPP v Dat
[2020] VCC 344
Citation 8
…(a pseudonym), [12] DPP v Dat (a pseudonym) [13] and DPP v Prodanovich .[14] I have read them (Exhibit 3). [12][2020] VCC 323 (‘ Lockeyer’) . [13][2020] VCC 344 (‘ Dat’) . [14][2019] VCC 1730 (‘ Prodanovich’) . 98It is always difficult comparing cases factually as facts vary enormously case to case, as do all mat…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Lockyer (a pseudonym)
[2020] VCC 323
Citation 9
…dard sentence for rape: DPP v Lockeyer (a pseudonym), [12] DPP v Dat (a pseudonym) [13] and DPP v Prodanovich .[14] I have read them (Exhibit 3). [12][2020] VCC 323 (‘ Lockeyer’) . [13][2020] VCC 344 (‘ Dat’) . [14][2019] VCC 1730 (‘ Prodanovich’) . 98It is always difficult comparing cases factually as facts vary…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Prodanovich
[2019] VCC 1730
Citation 10
…seudonym) [13] and DPP v Prodanovich .[14] I have read them (Exhibit 3). [12][2020] VCC 323 (‘ Lockeyer’) . [13][2020] VCC 344 (‘ Dat’) . [14][2019] VCC 1730 (‘ Prodanovich’) . 98It is always difficult comparing cases factually as facts vary enormously case to case, as do all matters in mitigation of sentence and…