Director of Public Prosecutions v SA & Ors (Ruling No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

CRIMINAL DIVISION

S ECR 2022 0258
S ECR 2022 0260
S ECR 2022 0262
S ECR 2022 0264

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Crown
v
SA Accused
PM
QM
SY

---

JUDGE:

Incerti J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

28 June 2023

DATE OF RULING:

10 July 2023

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

DPP v SA & Ors (Ruling No 2)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2023] VSC 388

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Ruling – Incriminating conduct – Whether conduct reasonably capable of being viewed as evidence of incriminating conduct – Application of Jury Directions Act s 20 in trial by judge alone – Whether evidence should be excluded because of unfair prejudice arising from ‘forensic bind’– Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) s 137 – Wilson (a pseudonym) v The King [2022] VSCA 261.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Crown Ms K Churchill with
Mr J Manning
Office of Public Prosecutions
For SA Mr J Desmond with
Ms M Brown
KPT Legal Pty Ltd
For PM Ms S Lacy with Ms D Price Stary Norton Halphen
For QM Ms J Saunders Ajak Wolan & Associates
For SY Ms A Cannon Chester Metcalfe & Co

HER HONOUR:

Introduction

  1. The accused SY, QM, PM and SA are each charged with the murder of Declan Cutler (‘the deceased’) at Reservoir on 13 March 2022.[1]

    [1]Where necessary or appropriate pseudonyms have been used throughout this ruling in accordance with Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic) s 534.

  1. The charge is to be the subject of a judge-alone trial before me, commencing in mid-July 2023. In the case of QM, PM and SA, the prosecution intends to rely on certain conduct, by each of them, as evidence of incriminating conduct.

  1. On 27 June 2023, the prosecution filed an amended notice of incriminating conduct (‘the prosecution’s notice’) pursuant to s 19(1) of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic) (‘Jury Directions Act’). The notice sets out a number of items of evidence of conduct which the prosecution proposes to rely on as evidence of incriminating conduct against QM, PM and SA.

  1. Those three accused challenge the admissibility of a number of items of conduct set out in the prosecution’s notice. Each of the items challenged by each accused will be dealt with in turn below.

Principles

  1. Jury Directions Act s 20 provides:

(1)The prosecution must not rely on evidence of conduct as evidence of incriminating conduct unless—

(a)the prosecution has given notice in accordance with section 19; and

(b)the trial judge determines that, on the basis of the evidence as a whole, the evidence of conduct is reasonably capable of being viewed by the jury as evidence of incriminating conduct.

(2)Subsection (1) applies even if the evidence of conduct may be admissible for another purpose.

  1. Section 18 of the Jury Directions Act contains the following definitions:

conduct means the telling of a lie by the accused, or any other act or omission of the accused,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v SA & Ors (Ruling No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] VSC 388
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The defendants, SA and others, were on trial for various criminal offences before a judge alone, without a jury, under the Jury Directions Act. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) sought to introduce evidence that the defendants had made incriminating admissions to a person named Wilson, who was subsequently convicted of perjury. The defendants argued that this evidence should be excluded because it would cause unfair prejudice to the defendants due to the ‘forensic bind’ created by Wilson’s subsequent conviction for perjury.

The court had to determine whether the incriminating admissions were reasonably capable of being viewed as evidence of the defendants’ incriminating conduct, and whether the evidence should be excluded under the Evidence Act on the basis of unfair prejudice. The court considered the provisions of the Jury Directions Act and the Evidence Act, as well as the decision in Wilson v The King.

The court found that the incriminating admissions were reasonably capable of being viewed as evidence of incriminating conduct. However, the court also found that the evidence should be excluded because of the unfair prejudice arising from the ‘forensic bind’ created by Wilson’s subsequent conviction for perjury. The court held that the Evidence Act and the Jury Directions Act both provide for the exclusion of evidence where it would be unfair to admit it, and that the prejudice caused by the ‘forensic bind’ was sufficient to exclude the evidence.

The court ordered that the incriminating admissions made by the defendants to Wilson be excluded from evidence in the trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established