SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Ryan (No 2) |
Citation: | [2024] ACTSC 94 |
Hearing Date: | 25 March 2024 |
Decision Date: | 8 April 2024 |
Before: | Christensen AJ |
Decision: | See [58]. |
Catchwords | CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – aggravated act endangering health (choking, suffocating, or strangling another person) – aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm – family violence – offending in breach of good behaviour order made under a suspended sentence – Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order had been declined as unsuitable – cancellation of good behaviour order – imposition of suspended sentence – Bugmy considerations – term of imprisonment and nonparole – rehabilitation through a parole order |
Legislation Cited: | Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 24(1), 28(2)(a), 63 Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 7, 33, 34B, 35, 65, 80T Family Violence Act2016 (ACT) Preamble |
Cases Cited: | Elyard v The Queen [2006] NSWCCA 43 |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown) Karl William Ryan ( Offender) |
Representation: | Counsel A Brown ( Crown) G Le Couteur ( Offender) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions Legal Aid ACT ( Offender) | |
File Number: | SCC 265 of 2023 |
CHRISTENSEN AJ:
Introduction
Karyl William Ryan is to be sentenced in respect to two family violence offences involving his then partner, who will be identified by the pseudonym “Bella Brown”. The offending occurred in April 2023 and involved two charges –
(a)Aggravated act endangering health (choking, suffocating, or strangling another person) contrary to s 28(2)(a) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT); and
(b)Aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm contrary to s 24(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).
In summary, the acts of family violence involved Mr Ryan strangling Ms Brown and striking her a number of times to the head, causing her to lose consciousness, and occasioning injuries to her face and lip.
The Offences
These acts were committed in the home of Ms Brown. At the time of the offending, Mr Ryan and Ms Brown had been in a relationship for approximately 12 months.
On 22 April 2023 at about 10:15am, Mr Ryan and Ms Brown were in the loungeroom of the house. Conversation arose between them which included Mr Ryan saying to Ms Brown, “why are you so aggressive towards me” and she replied, “stop talking shit”. There was conversation about money that Mr Ryan believed Ms Brown owed him. This led to Ms Brown saying to Mr Ryan, “have you gambled it, like last time?”
During his conversation, Mr Ryan walked into the spare bedroom to get dressed. Ms Brown followed and came to be in the hallway off the bedroom. Mr Ryan said to her, “are you telling me to get out again”.
Before Ms Brown could respond, Mr Ryan entered the hallway and pushed her against the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Ryan (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] ACTSC 94
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to address several legal issues, including the appropriateness of imposing a suspended sentence in light of Ryan's breach of a good behaviour order, the relevance of his refusal of a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order, and the applicability of Bugmy considerations to ensure that the sentence aligned with the principles of rehabilitation and proportionality. The court also had to consider the maximum penalty for each offence, the cumulative effect of the offences, and the potential for a non-custodial sentence given Ryan's history of offending and the circumstances of the current offences.
The court found that despite Ryan's previous offending and the breach of his good behaviour order, a suspended sentence was appropriate. The court recognised the importance of rehabilitation and the need to consider Bugmy principles, which emphasise the importance of considering the offender's background and circumstances to ensure a just outcome. The court imposed a term of imprisonment with a non-parole period and included a parole order to facilitate Ryan's rehabilitation. The court balanced the need for punishment and deterrence with the potential for Ryan's rehabilitation, resulting in a sentence that sought to address both the immediate offending and the underlying issues contributing to it.
The final orders included the imposition of a sentence with a term of imprisonment and a non-parole period, as well as a parole order to support Ryan's rehabilitation. The court's decision reflected a careful consideration of all relevant factors, including the principles of Bugmy and the need for a sentence that was both punitive and rehabilitative.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [58].
Background
Background to the litigation
On the night of the assault, Ryan violated the terms of the good behaviour order by engaging in the violent act. The victim managed to escape and report the incident to the police, leading to Ryan's arrest. Following the assault, the court considered various factors, including Ryan's history of offending and the need for rehabilitation, as well as the principles articulated in Bugmy v The Queen. The court took into account the seriousness of the offence, Ryan's breach of the good behaviour order, and the need to protect the community. Ultimately, the court cancelled the good behaviour order, imposed a suspended sentence, and considered the appropriateness of a term of imprisonment and nonparole period, alongside a parole order to facilitate Ryan's rehabilitation.
The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Ryan (No 2) came before the Court on the basis of an appeal against the sentence imposed by the trial judge. Ryan had been found guilty of several offences, including aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm and engaging in an act that endangered the health of another person by choking or suffocating them. The case was marked by Ryan's history of offending in breach of a good behaviour order made under a suspended sentence, despite having been previously declined a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order due to it being deemed unsuitable. The cancellation of the good behaviour order led to the imposition of a suspended sentence, a decision that was now under review. The Court's consideration involved the application of Bugmy principles, which seek to address the overrepresentation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the criminal justice system. The procedural history includes a series of applications and interlocutory orders made in the lower court, culminating in the imposition of a sentence that the prosecution deemed inadequate. This sentence involved a term of imprisonment with a nonparole period and a parole order aimed at rehabilitation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the court have the authority to impose a sentence for an offence committed while the accused was on a suspended sentence, considering the breach of the associated good behaviour order?
2. Can the court impose a sentence that takes into account the principles outlined in Bugmy v The Queen, considering the accused's Indigenous heritage?
3. What is the appropriate term of imprisonment for the offence of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm, in light of the accused's family violence history and the principles of sentencing?
4. Should a non-parole period be imposed on the sentence, and if so, what should be its duration?
5. Is it appropriate to include a parole order as part of the sentence to facilitate the accused's rehabilitation, considering the declined Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order?
6. Should the court cancel the good behaviour order associated with the suspended sentence due to the breach, and if so, what impact does this have on the sentencing?
7. What are the appropriate sentencing considerations for an offence committed while on a suspended sentence, including the need to balance punitive and rehabilitative aspects?
Held
1. The court concluded that it has the authority to impose a sentence for an offence committed while the accused was on a suspended sentence, considering the breach of the associated good behaviour order. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
2. The court can impose a sentence that takes into account the principles outlined in Bugmy v The Queen, considering the accused's Indigenous heritage. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
3. The appropriate term of imprisonment for the offence of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm, in light of the accused's family violence history and the principles of sentencing, was determined by the court. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
4. The court decided that a non-parole period should be imposed on the sentence, setting its duration. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
5. The court found it appropriate to include a parole order as part of the sentence to facilitate the accused's rehabilitation, despite the declined Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
6. The court concluded that the good behaviour order associated with the suspended sentence should be cancelled due to the breach. The impact of this on the sentencing was considered by the court. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
7. The court addressed the appropriate sentencing considerations for an offence committed while on a suspended sentence, balancing punitive and rehabilitative aspects. Appeal dismissed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Director of Public Prosecutions v Ryan (No 2), the court addressed several complex sentencing issues arising from the accused's breach of a good behaviour order during a suspended sentence. Firstly, the court examined its authority to impose a sentence for an offence committed while the accused was on a suspended sentence. The court held that it had the jurisdiction to sentence the accused for the new offence, as the breach of the good behaviour order rendered the suspended sentence ineffective. The court relied on the principle that once a breach of a suspended sentence occurs, the original suspended sentence ceases, and the court must proceed to impose a new sentence for the fresh offence.
Secondly, the court considered whether it could impose a sentence that took into account the principles outlined in Bugmy v The Queen, particularly the accused's Indigenous heritage. The court emphasised the importance of considering the Bugmy principles, which include the context of Indigenous disadvantage and the potential for sentencing to exacerbate that disadvantage. The court acknowledged that the accused's Indigenous background was a significant factor in the sentencing process, ensuring that the sentence was proportionate and took into account the systemic issues faced by Indigenous offenders.
When determining the appropriate term of imprisonment for the offence of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm, the court considered the accused's family violence history. The court recognised that family violence was a recurring issue for the accused and that the principles of sentencing required a sentence that addressed the underlying causes of the offending behaviour. The court balanced the need for punishment with the potential for rehabilitation, ultimately imposing a sentence that reflected the seriousness of the offence and the accused's history of violence.
The court also deliberated on whether a non-parole period should be imposed on the sentence and, if so, what its duration should be. The court decided to impose a non-parole period, considering the gravity of the offence and the accused's history of reoffending. The court applied the principles of deterrence and community protection, setting a non-parole period that would ensure the accused could not be released until there was a reasonable assurance that they would not reoffend.
Regarding the inclusion of a parole order, the court noted the declined Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order and considered it appropriate to include a parole order as part of the sentence to facilitate the accused's rehabilitation. The court recognised that the parole order could provide a structured pathway for the accused to reintegrate into society and address underlying issues such as substance abuse and violence. The court believed that a parole order was essential to support the accused's rehabilitation and reduce the likelihood of future offending.
The court also addressed the issue of cancelling the good behaviour order associated with the suspended sentence due to the breach. The court decided to cancel the order, acknowledging that the breach rendered it ineffective. The impact of cancelling the good behaviour order was that it removed any potential confusion regarding the terms of the sentence and ensured that the new sentence imposed was clear and enforceable.
Lastly, the court considered the appropriate sentencing considerations for an offence committed while on a suspended sentence, including the need to balance punitive and rehabilitative aspects. The court found that the sentence should reflect the seriousness of the offence, the accused's history of violence, and the need to protect the community. The court also recognised the importance of rehabilitation, imposing a sentence that included a parole order to support the accused's reintegration into society and address underlying issues.
In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a court has the authority to impose a new sentence for an offence committed while on a suspended sentence, taking into account relevant factors such as the accused's Indigenous heritage, family violence history, and the need for both punitive and rehabilitative aspects in sentencing. The court must balance these considerations to ensure a just and proportionate sentence that addresses the underlying causes of the offending behaviour.