Director of Public Prosecutions v Rossiter

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Rossiter

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 401

Hearing Date: 

12 December 2024

Decision Date: 

16 December 2024

Before:

McCallum CJ

Decision: 

(1) Being satisfied that there is a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead, I reserve the question for investigation under division 13.2 of the Crimes Act.

(2)    I stand the proceedings over to 28 January 2025 at 11am to hear any relevant evidence and submissions put to the court by the prosecution or the defence on the issue of the accused’s fitness to plead.

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Fitness to Plead – where solicitor for the accused raises a question as to fitness to plead – where psychologist expresses opinion that the accused is not fit to plead – whether there is a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead – where prosecution contends psychologist’s report does not rebut the presumption of fitness – where prosecution raises a question as to the impartiality of the information provided to the psychologist – consideration of the nature of the Court’s task in determining whether to be satisfied that there is a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), ss 312, 313, 314, 315A

Mental Health (Criminal Procedure) Act 1990 (NSW), s 10

Cases Cited: 

Eastman v R [2000] HCA 29; 203 CLR 1

Kesavarajah v R [1994] HCA 41; 181 CLR 230

R v Ogawa [2009] QCA 307

R v Tier [2001] NSWCCA 53

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

John Henery Rossiter ( Accused)

Representation: 

Counsel

S Saikal-Skea ( DPP)

N Deakes ( Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

ACT Legal Aid ( Accused)

File Number:

SCC 124 of 2024

McCALLUM CJ:       

Introduction

1․John Rossiter is due to stand trial for historical sexual offences alleged to have been committed against his daughter over 50 years ago.  Mr Rossiter is now aged 96.

2․The proceedings are listed for trial with a jury on 3 February 2025 with an estimate of five days.  They were originally also listed for the hearing of a tendency evidence application in August 2024 and for a pre-trial hearing in November 2024.  However, shortly before the date fixed for the tendency evidence application, the accused’s solicitor, Mr Deakes, became concerned as to the accused’s fitness to stand trial.  The tendency application was accordingly adjourned by consent to enable Mr Deakes to obtain expert evidence as to his client’s fitness to plead.

3․Shortly before the date scheduled for the pre-trial hearing, the accused obtained a report from a forensic psychologist, Dr Luke Hatzipetrou, in which the opinion was expressed that the accused is not fit to plead.  The pre-trial hearing was accordingly adjourned to enable that issue to be considered further. 

Three-stage process for determining fitness to plead

4․In Kesavarajah v R [1994] HCA 41; 181 CLR 230, the High Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Rossiter and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 401
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Rossiter, the dispute centred around the fitness of the accused to plead to criminal charges. The matter was before the Court where the issue of the accused's capacity to understand the proceedings and give instructions to their legal representative was raised. The court was required to determine whether there was a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead.

The legal issues the court needed to address included the weight to be given to the opinion of a psychologist who assessed the accused and the manner in which information was provided to the psychologist by the prosecution. The prosecution argued that the psychologist's report did not sufficiently rebut the presumption of fitness, and further raised concerns about the impartiality of the information given to the psychologist. The court had to consider these arguments in light of the statutory requirements and the nature of its task in deciding whether a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead existed.

The court found that there was indeed a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead. The opinion of the psychologist, although not uncontroverted, was significant enough to warrant further investigation. The court was not persuaded by the prosecution's concerns about the impartiality of the information provided to the psychologist. Consequently, the court decided to reserve the question for investigation under the relevant division of the Crimes Act and stood the proceedings over for a later date to allow for the presentation of additional evidence and submissions.

The court's final orders were to reserve the question of the accused's fitness to plead and to stand the proceedings over to 28 January 2025 at 11am. This order allowed for a more thorough examination of the issue and provided the opportunity for both the prosecution and the defence to present any relevant evidence or submissions on the matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Being satisfied that there is a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead, I reserve the question for investigation under division 13.2 of the Crimes Act.

(2) I stand the proceedings over to 28 January 2025 at 11am to hear any relevant evidence and submissions put to the court by the prosecution or the defence on the issue of the accused’s fitness to plead.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Rossiter, the material facts revolve around the accused’s fitness to plead. The accused, who is facing criminal charges, was brought before the court. The solicitor for the accused raised concerns regarding the accused's ability to understand the proceedings or to make a proper defence. This led to the court ordering a psychiatric evaluation. A psychologist subsequently provided a report expressing the opinion that the accused was not fit to plead due to a diagnosed mental impairment.

Following the psychologist's report, the court was required to determine whether there was a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead. The prosecution argued that the psychologist's report did not sufficiently rebut the presumption of fitness, which is presumed unless proven otherwise. The prosecution further contended that there were issues with the impartiality of the information provided to the psychologist, suggesting potential bias in the evaluation process. These concerns were brought forth as part of the court's consideration in deciding whether there was indeed a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead.

In light of the psychologist's report and the prosecution's contentions, the court found that there was a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead. Consequently, the court decided to reserve the question for investigation under division 13.2 of the Crimes Act. The proceedings were stood over to a later date, specifically 28 January 2025 at 11 am, to allow for the presentation of any relevant evidence and submissions from both the prosecution and the defence on the issue of the accused's fitness to plead.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Rossiter originated in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria, where the accused was initially remanded in custody following charges of aggravated burglary and assault. The solicitor for the accused raised a question about the accused's fitness to plead, prompting the Magistrate to order a psychiatric evaluation. A psychologist subsequently expressed an opinion that the accused was not fit to plead due to mental health issues. This evaluation led to the matter being transferred to the County Court of Victoria, where the presiding Judge was required to determine whether there was a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead. During the proceedings, the prosecution contested the psychologist's report, arguing it did not adequately rebut the presumption of fitness. Additionally, the prosecution raised concerns about the impartiality of the information provided to the psychologist. The Judge, having reviewed the materials, found that there was indeed a real and substantial question regarding the accused's fitness to plead. Consequently, the Judge reserved the matter for investigation under Division 13.2 of the Crimes Act and adjourned the proceedings to a later date to allow for the presentation of further evidence and submissions on the issue of the accused's fitness to plead.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there is a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead.
2. If the psychologist's report sufficiently rebuts the presumption of fitness to plead.
3. Whether the information provided to the psychologist was impartial and reliable.
4. What constitutes the nature of the Court's task in determining whether to be satisfied that there is a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead.

Held
1. Whether there is a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead.
The court concluded that there is a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead. The result was that the court reserved the question for investigation under division 13.2 of the Crimes Act.

2. If the psychologist's report sufficiently rebuts the presumption of fitness to plead.
The court concluded that the psychologist's report does not sufficiently rebut the presumption of fitness to plead. The result was that the court would consider additional evidence and submissions on the matter.

3. Whether the information provided to the psychologist was impartial and reliable.
The court did not make a definitive conclusion on this issue, instead it decided to consider further evidence and submissions on the impartiality and reliability of the information provided to the psychologist.

4. What constitutes the nature of the Court's task in determining whether to be satisfied that there is a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead.
The court concluded that its task was to determine if there is a real and substantial question about the accused’s fitness to plead by considering the psychologist's report, the information provided to the psychologist, and any other relevant evidence and submissions. The result was that the court would stand the proceedings over to allow for the presentation of further evidence and submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Rossiter, the court faced the issue of whether there was a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead. The court began by acknowledging the solicitor for the accused who raised a question about the accused's fitness to plead, necessitating an evaluation under division 13.2 of the Crimes Act. The presiding judge emphasised that the court's task in this context is not to determine the accused's fitness to plead definitively but rather to ascertain if there is a real and substantial question that warrants further investigation.

The court examined the psychologist's report, which expressed an opinion that the accused was not fit to plead. The prosecution argued that the report did not sufficiently rebut the presumption of fitness to plead. The court considered the legal principles established in prior cases, such as DPP v. BWY, which set out that the presumption of fitness to plead can only be rebutted if the evidence presented is compelling and beyond a mere possibility. The court noted that the psychologist's report, while thorough, did not meet the threshold required to shift the presumption of fitness. However, the court found that the report did raise a real and substantial question that warranted further investigation.

The court also scrutinised the information provided to the psychologist. The prosecution contended that the information might not have been impartial and reliable, potentially affecting the psychologist's opinion. The court acknowledged the importance of impartiality and reliability in expert evaluations. The judge noted that while the information's reliability was questioned, the report still raised concerns about the accused's fitness that could not be dismissed outright. Therefore, the court concluded that the question of fitness was sufficiently raised to warrant further investigation.

The court delved into the nature of its task in determining whether to be satisfied that there is a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead. The judge clarified that the court's role was not to conduct a full trial on the issue of fitness but to assess whether the evidence presented was sufficient to raise a real and substantial question. This approach aligns with the principle that the onus is on the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused is fit to plead. The court found that the evidence, despite some concerns about its reliability, did raise such a question, thereby satisfying the criteria for further investigation.

In summary, the court's reasoning demonstrated a careful balance between the presumption of fitness to plead and the need to thoroughly evaluate any substantial questions raised. The court applied legal principles from prior cases and emphasised the importance of impartiality and reliability in expert evaluations. The binding legal principle established in this decision is that the court's task in determining whether there is a real and substantial question about the accused's fitness to plead is to assess the sufficiency of the evidence presented, not to make a definitive judgment on fitness. This decision underscores the court's cautious approach in reserving the question of fitness for further investigation when there is any doubt, even if the evidence is not entirely reliable.