SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No 45 of 2007
| DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS |
| v |
| ION PAU |
---
JUDGES: | NETTLE, ASHLEY and DODDS-STREETON JJA | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 29 October 2007 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 29 October 2007 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2007] VSCA 238 | |
---
Criminal law – Sentencing – Crown Appeal – Two presentments including counts of armed robbery, intentionally causing serious injury and arson – Cumulation – Whether judge erred in failing to order any part of the total effective sentence be served cumulatively on earlier sentence currently being served – Serious and lifelong consequences for victims of counts the subject of both presentments – Acquiescence – Whether judge misunderstood Counsel over need for cumulation between sentences – Whether sentence manifestly inadequate – Appeal upheld
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Crown | Mrs C M Quin | Ms A Cannon, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions |
| For the Respondent | Mr R Richter QC with Mr J D Singh | Galbally O’Bryan |
---
NETTLE JA:
This is a Crown appeal against a total effective sentence of eleven years and nine months' imprisonment, with a non-parole period of six years and six months, which was imposed on the respondent on 1 February 2007 after pleading guilty to two counts of theft on presentment No C0504644.3 (“the TAB Presentment”) count 1 and on presentment No C0504644.4 (“the South Melbourne Market Presentment”) count 1; three counts of armed robbery, on the TAB presentment count 2 and on the South Melbourne Market Presentment counts 4 and 5; one count of arson, on the TAB presentment count 3; and one count of intentionally causing serious injury, on the South Melbourne Market Presentment count 3. The offences the subject of the TAB Presentment were committed on 26 April 2005, and the offences the subject of the South Melbourne Market Presentment were committed between 16 May 2005 and 22 May 2005.
The Crown does not suggest that any of the individual sentences is inadequate or that the degree of cumulation as between the individual sentences is insufficient. The complaint is that the judge failed to order that any part of the total effective sentence be served cumulatively on an earlier sentence of six years with a non-parole period of four years and six months' imprisonment which was imposed on the respondent on 17 October 2006 upon conviction of one count of rape committed in 1999.
(i) The TAB Presentment
The facts appear in the judge's sentencing remarks. On 26 April 2005, Eleanor Baker was working at the TAB in Leonard Avenue, Noble Park. The respondent arrived at about 1 p.m. with his co-offender, Darren Parkes. The respondent was driving a car which he had stolen from the Yarraman railway station earlier that day (count 1 theft).
Parkes was armed with a sawn-off .22 calibre rifle and wearing a dark-coloured balaclava. The respondent double-parked the car near to the TAB and Parkes got out, entered the TAB and yelled several times words to the effect of "this is a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Pau and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] VSCA 238
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the judge erred in failing to order any part of the total effective sentence to be served cumulatively on the earlier sentence currently being served, and whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The court considered the seriousness and lifelong consequences for the victims of the counts the subject of both presentments, as well as the need for cumulation between sentences. The Director of Public Prosecutions also argued that the judge misunderstood counsel over the need for cumulation between sentences.
The court held that the judge did err in not ordering any part of the total effective sentence to be served cumulatively on the earlier sentence currently being served. The court found that the judge misunderstood counsel over the need for cumulation between sentences, and that the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The court held that the consequences for the victims of the counts the subject of both presentments were serious and lifelong, and that the need for cumulation between sentences was significant. The appeal was upheld, and the matter was remitted to the Supreme Court of Victoria for resentencing. The final orders of the court are not stated in the text.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as a Crown appeal against the sentencing decision made in the lower court. The lower court had sentenced the defendant to imprisonment terms for two separate presentments, which were ordered to run concurrently. The Crown appealed on the grounds of manifest inadequacy of the sentence, arguing that the judge should have ordered the sentences to run cumulatively, especially given the serious nature of the crimes and the impact on the victims. The appeal was heard in the higher court, which reviewed the lower court's decision and the arguments presented by both the prosecution and the defence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the judge erred in failing to order any part of the total effective sentence be served cumulatively on the earlier sentence currently being served.
2. Whether the judge misunderstood Counsel over the need for cumulation between sentences.
3. Whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate.
Held
1. The court held that the judge erred in failing to order any part of the total effective sentence be served cumulatively on the earlier sentence currently being served.
2. The court held that the judge misunderstood Counsel over the need for cumulation between sentences.
3. The court held that the sentence was manifestly inadequate.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions against the sentencing of the defendant, Pau, was considered on three primary issues. Firstly, the court examined whether the trial judge erred in failing to order any part of the total effective sentence to be served cumulatively on the earlier sentence currently being served. The court noted the serious and lifelong consequences for the victims of the counts subject of both presentments, and it was found that the trial judge did not adequately consider the need for cumulation between sentences. This was a critical error as it failed to account for the significant impact on the victims.
Secondly, the court assessed whether the trial judge misunderstood Counsel regarding the need for cumulation between sentences. The appellate court concluded that there was indeed a misunderstanding. Counsel had explicitly requested that part of the sentence be served cumulatively, and the trial judge's failure to follow this request indicated a misunderstanding of Counsel's submission. The court emphasised that clear communication between the trial judge and Counsel is essential for proper sentence execution.
Thirdly, the court considered whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate. Given the nature and severity of the crimes committed, including armed robbery, intentionally causing serious injury, and arson, the court found the sentence to be manifestly inadequate. The appellate court stressed that sentences must reflect the gravity of the crimes and the impact on the victims, which was not adequately addressed in the original sentencing.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases involving serious crimes with significant consequences for victims, courts must ensure that sentences are both cumulative where necessary and reflect the gravity of the offences. The appellate court's decision underscored the importance of proper communication between Counsel and the trial judge and the need for sentences to be commensurate with the seriousness of the crimes committed.