Director of Public Prosecutions v Paton

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

CITATION: Director of Public Prosecutions v Paton [2021] NTSC 36

PARTIES:  DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC   PROSECUTIONS

v

PATON, Jon William

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:105 of 2017 (21753364)

DELIVERED:  29 April 2021

HEARING DATES:  4, 5 and 19 November 2019

6, 7, 10 and 18 February 2020

JUDGMENT OF:  Grant CJ

CATCHWORDS:

CRIME – Confiscations – Unexplained wealth

Whether more likely than not that the respondent’s total wealth is greater than his lawfully acquired wealth – Respondent bore burden of establishing on the balance of probabilities that the property, services, advantages and benefits constituting his total wealth were lawfully acquired – Onus discharged – Application dismissed.

Criminal Property Forfeiture Act 2002 (NT) s 6, s 11, s 67, s 68, s 69, s 70, s 71, s 98, s 136
Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT) s 140

Ballard v Multiplex [2012] NSWSC 426, Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336, Carney v Newton [2006] TASSC 4, Chen v State of New South Wales (No 2) [2016] NSWCA 292, Henderson v Queensland (2014) 89 ALJR 162, Jackson v Lithgow City Council [2008] NSWCA 312, Kuligowski v Metrobus (2004) 220 CLR 363, Morley & Ors v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2010] NSWCA 331, Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd (1992) 67 ALJR 170, Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes [2008] NSWCA 246, NOM v DPP (2012) 38 VR 618, Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuiness (2000) 49 NSWLR 262, referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Applicant:SJ Monck

Respondent:  Self-represented

Solicitors:

Applicant:Solicitor for the Northern Territory

Respondent:  Self-represented

Judgment category classification:          B

Judgment ID Number:  GRA2106

Number of pages:  44

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT ALICE SPRINGS

Director of Public Prosecutions v Paton [2021] NTSC 36
No. 105 of 2017 (21753364)

BETWEEN:

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

Applicant

AND:

JON WILLIAM PATON

Respondent

CORAM:    GRANT CJ

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 29 April 2021)

  1. This is an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions pursuant to s 67 of the Criminal Property Forfeiture Act 2002 (NT) for an unexplained wealth declaration against the respondent.

    Background and procedural history

  2. On 7 January 2016, the respondent left Alice Springs and drove to South Australia in a white Ford Ranger motor vehicle.  While there he came into possession of 12.7 kilograms of cannabis packaged into individual one pound Cryovac bags.  On 10 January 2016, he drove from South Australia back to the Northern Territory with the cannabis concealed in the rear tray of the vehicle.  He was apprehended by police approximately 100 kilometres South of Alice Springs.  Police conducted a search of the vehicle and located the cannabis.  The respondent was subsequently charged with drug offences.  On 23 August 2016, the respondent was found guilty by a jury of the unlawful possession of a commercial quantity of cannabis.  He was sentenced to imprisonment for four years and six…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Paton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NTSC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Paton involved an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) under section 67 of the Criminal Property Forfeiture Act 2002 (NT) for an unexplained wealth declaration against the respondent, who had been found guilty of possessing a commercial quantity of cannabis and subsequently sentenced to imprisonment. The respondent was self-represented during the proceedings which were conducted over seven days. The primary issue before the court was whether the respondent had discharged the burden of proving on the balance of probabilities that his total wealth was not greater than his lawfully acquired wealth, thus avoiding the declaration of unexplained wealth.

The court considered the evidence provided by the respondent regarding the sources of his wealth, including monies received through various transactions and a sale of household goods. The respondent argued that these funds were lawfully acquired, and the court had to determine whether the evidence presented was sufficient to establish this on the balance of probabilities. The court applied the Briginshaw standard of proof, requiring a reasonable satisfaction that the respondent's wealth was not derived from unlawful activities. The court concluded that the respondent had discharged the burden of proof by providing credible evidence that his wealth was lawfully acquired, as he demonstrated that the funds in question were derived from legitimate sources such as the sale of personal property.

As a result, the court dismissed the DPP's application for an unexplained wealth declaration. The evidence provided by the respondent was deemed sufficient to establish that his wealth was not greater than his lawfully acquired wealth. Therefore, the court found that the respondent had successfully discharged the burden of proof on the balance of probabilities.

The court made no order for an unexplained wealth declaration against the respondent, effectively dismissing the DPP's application. This decision was based on the respondent's credible evidence that his wealth was derived from lawful activities, satisfying the Briginshaw standard of proof.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions pursuant to s 67 of the Criminal Property Forfeiture Act 2002 (NT) for an unexplained wealth declaration against the respondent. Background and procedural history On 7 January 2016, the respondent left Alice Springs and drove to South Australia in a white Ford Ranger motor vehicle. While there he came into possession of 12.7 kilograms of cannabis packaged into individual one pound Cryovac bags. On 10 January 2016, he drove from South Australia back to the Northern Territory with the cannabis concealed in the rear tray of the vehicle. He was apprehended by police approximately 100 kilometres South of Alice Springs. Police conducted a search of the vehicle and located the cannabis. The respondent was subsequently charged with drug offences. On 23 August 2016, the respondent was found guilty by a jury of the unlawful possession of a commercial quantity of cannabis. He was sentenced to imprisonment for four years and six months which was suspended after he had served 21 months in prison. On 10 November 2017, the Director of Public Prosecutions made application for a restraining order in relation to a residential property owned by the respondent in Alice Springs, and for the unexplained wealth declaration. On 27 November 2017, the application was amended to include the motor vehicle the respondent was driving at the time of his apprehension. The restraining order was made on 8 January 2018. On 25 June 2018, the Director of Public Prosecutions made application for the forfeiture of the motor vehicle on the ground that it was “crime-used” property within the meaning of s 11 of the Criminal Property Forfeiture Act. The vehicle had been used directly in the commission of the offence for which the respondent had been found guilty and convicted[1], and on 28 June 2018 an order was made for the forfeiture of the motor vehicle to the Territory. The application for the unexplained wealth declaration was deferred until the respondent’s release from prison, and did not proceed to hearing until 4 November 2019. The hearing proceeded over seven separate days in November 2019 and February 2020, due in part to the fact that the respondent was self-represented in the matter and required a number of adjournments for the purpose of producing relevant evidence and preparing submissions.Unexplained wealth Section 68 of the Criminal Property Forfeiture Act defines “unexplained wealth” in the following terms:Unexplained wealth (1) For this Act, a person has unexplained wealth if the value of the person's total wealth as described in subsection (2) is greater than the value of the person's lawfully acquired wealth as described in subsection (3). (2) The value of the person's total wealth is the total value of all the items of property, and all the services, advantages and benefits, that together constitute the person's wealth. (3) The value of the person's lawfully acquired wealth is the total value of all the items of property, and all the services, advantages and benefits, that constitute the person's wealth and were lawfully acquired.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The third and final deposit into this account is in the amount of $9800 made on 11 November 2015. The respondent’s evidence was to the effect that when he was trying to raise the monies for the deposit to purchase the house in late 2015 he conducted a lawn sale at which he sold a lot of the parts and household goods he had accumulated over the years. These included tools, drop saws, a vehicle front-end, a differential, spare tyres and other valuable items.The assessment of the respondent’s evidence As stated at the outset, the onus is on the respondent to establish on the balance of probabilities that the monies received by him in the transactions described above were lawfully acquired. However, the respondent does not bear any special onus, burden or standard in that respect. Section 140 of the Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT) provides that in a civil proceeding the court must find the case of a party proved if it is satisfied the case has been proved on the balance of probabilities. In doing so, the court may take into account the nature of the cause of action; the nature of the subject matter of the proceeding; and the gravity of the matters alleged. Those factors reflect the principles set out by Dixon J in Briginshaw v Briginshaw[8] that reasonable satisfaction is not a state of mind that is attained or established independently of the nature and consequences of the fact or facts to be proved. The seriousness of the allegation made, the inherent unlikelihood of an occurrence of a given description, or the gravity of the consequences flowing from a particular finding are relevant to deciding whether a matter is proved on the balance of probabilities. This is not a case in which the nature and consequences of the fact or facts to be proved by the respondent requires particularly cogent or strict proof. The respondent is not himself making serious allegations against any other person, or seeking a finding which would have grave consequences for another. Rather, in constructive and practical terms at least, the respondent is defending an assertion by the applicant that he acquired the monies concerned through criminal activity. However, that feature of the proceedings also does not work in any way to lower the cogency of the evidence required to establish that the monies were lawfully acquired, on the basis of the general proposition that people do not ordinarily engage in fraudulent or criminal conduct.[9] In Henderson v Queensland[10], the High Court considered the operation of Queensland legislation which required the respondent to satisfy the court that “it is more probable than not” certain property “is not illegally acquired property”. French CJ held at [15] that ‘[t]he placement of the burden of proof is uncompromising and unable to be ameliorated by any “conventional perception that members of our society do not ordinarily engage in fraudulent or criminal conduct”’.[11] What is required is that the Court is able to reach a state of actual persuasion of the occurrence or existence of the fact(s) asserted by the respondent.[12] A “[m]ere mechanical comparison of probabilities independent of a reasonable satisfaction will not justify a finding of fact”.[13] The respondent must show that his case is more likely than not.[14] The respondent will not have proven his case if the likelihood of his case and applicant’s assertions are perfectly balanced.[15] Where the Court is unable to reach a conclusion either way, the respondent will also have failed to discharge the burden of proof.[16] Having regard to those governing principles, there are a number of considerations relevant to the determination whether the respondent has proved to the requisite standard that the monies received by him in the transactions described above were lawfully acquired.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established