DPP v Weybury
[2018] VSCA 120
Citation 1
…icular offending fits, on the spectrum of offence seriousness. The Court of Appeal says that there is not much benefit in doing so (see DPP v Weybury [2018] VSCA 120). 39However, Ms Wong suggested that the offending, the subject of the armed robbery offences, fell at the lower end of offence seriousness. That it w…
The Queen v Ta
[2019] VCC 1257
Citation 2
…s made as to the six sentences imposed by single judges of this court. The defence “relied” upon the cases of Brooks [2017] VCC 1236 , Livingston [2019] VCC 1257 and Mark [2016] VCC 523, whilst the prosecution “relied” upon Fantani [2019] VCC 639 , Smith [2017] VCC 882 and Pujara [2018] VCC 380. The citations are…
CBA v MTC Diesel Pty Ltd
[2019] VCC 639
Citation 3
…” upon the cases of Brooks [2017] VCC 1236 , Livingston [2019] VCC 1257 and Mark [2016] VCC 523, whilst the prosecution “relied” upon Fantani [2019] VCC 639 , Smith [2017] VCC 882 and Pujara [2018] VCC 380. The citations are referred to in my written reasons. I say “relied” and I have said enough already about my…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Pujara
[2018] VCC 380
Citation 4
…ngston [2019] VCC 1257 and Mark [2016] VCC 523, whilst the prosecution “relied” upon Fantani [2019] VCC 639 , Smith [2017] VCC 882 and Pujara [2018] VCC 380. The citations are referred to in my written reasons. I say “relied” and I have said enough already about my views as to that approach. I regard that process…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Brooks
[2017] VCC 1236
Citation 5
…ady dealt with the submissions made as to the six sentences imposed by single judges of this court. The defence “relied” upon the cases of Brooks [2017] VCC 1236 , Livingston [2019] VCC 1257 and Mark [2016] VCC 523, whilst the prosecution “relied” upon Fantani [2019] VCC 639 , Smith [2017] VCC 882 and Pujara [2018…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith
[2017] VCC 882
Citation 6
…oks [2017] VCC 1236 , Livingston [2019] VCC 1257 and Mark [2016] VCC 523, whilst the prosecution “relied” upon Fantani [2019] VCC 639 , Smith [2017] VCC 882 and Pujara [2018] VCC 380. The citations are referred to in my written reasons. I say “relied” and I have said enough already about my views as to that appro…
Director of Public Prosecutions v Mark
[2016] VCC 523
Citation 7
…ences imposed by single judges of this court. The defence “relied” upon the cases of Brooks [2017] VCC 1236 , Livingston [2019] VCC 1257 and Mark [2016] VCC 523, whilst the prosecution “relied” upon Fantani [2019] VCC 639 , Smith [2017] VCC 882 and Pujara [2018] VCC 380. The citations are referred to in my writte…