Director of Public Prosecutions v Murphy (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:  DPP v Murphy (No 2)
Citation:  [2023] ACTSC 227
Hearing Date:  15 August 2023
Decision Date:  17 August 2023
Before:  Mossop J
Decision:  See [110].
Catchwords:  CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND
PROCEDURE – Judgment and punishment – sentence –

offender found guilty by jury of offences including recklessly inflicting grievous bodily harm, engage in sexual intercourse

without consent and choke strangle or suffocate – where
offender pleaded guilty to other charges following finding of guilt
– where all offending occurred in family violence context –
offences range from the mid-range of objective seriousness to
the worst category of case – risk of further offending – sentence
of full-time imprisonment imposed
Legislation Cited:  Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), s 74
Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), ss 23, 24, 25, 26, 54(1), 116(3)
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), ss 33(1)(za), 34B
Cases Cited:  R v Wilkinson (No 5) [2009] NSWSC 432

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions Shay Kahu Murphy (Offender)

Representation:  Counsel
A Williamson SC (DPP)
J Maher (Offender)
Solicitors
Director of Public Prosecutions
Paul Edmonds & Associates (Offender)
File Numbers:  SCC 92 of 2022
SCC 93 of 2022
SCC 350 of 2022
MOSSOP J: 
Introduction 
1․  These proceedings are sentencing proceedings relating to Shay Kahu Murphy.
2․  On 10 February 2023 he was convicted by a jury of nine offences on an indictment dated
7 February 2023. Those offences related to two victims. At the commencement of that
trial (prior to the empanelment of the jury), he pleaded guilty to the transfer charge of
property damage (CC2021/11052), although it was noted at the time that the facts
underpinning that charge were disputed.
3․  Severed from that proceeding were two charges relating to two other victims. These
charges were contained on a second indictment dated 11 April 2023. On 12 April 2023
the offender pleaded guilty to both charges the subject of the severed proceeding.
4․  There remain the outstanding transfer charges pressed by the Director of Public
Prosecutions (DPP) which this court has a discretion to deal with on the evidence
adduced in the trial if it considers that it is in the interests of justice to do so. It is in the
interests of justice that they be determined by this court. The prosecution accepts that
some of those transfer charges should, in light of the jury’s verdicts on associated counts,
be dismissed. Leaving aside the charges in this latter category, the charges to be dealt
with, set out in roughly chronological order, are as follows. For reasons given in a
moment, the victims are identified as Ms A, Ms B, Ms C and Ms D.
Offence Date Victim
1 Negligently causing grievous bodily harm 31 August 2011 – Ms A
(Count 3: CC2022/1150) 9 December 2011
2 Recklessly inflicting grievous bodily harm 8 December 2011 – Ms A
(Count 6: SCAN2022/61) 17 December 2011
3 Engage in sexual intercourse without 1 September 2011 – Ms A
consent (Count 9:…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Murphy (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, the Court was required to sentence Shay Kahu Murphy, who had been found guilty by a jury of multiple offences against four different victims, as well as other charges to which he had pleaded guilty. The legal issues before the Court included determining the objective seriousness of each offence, considering the subjective circumstances of the offender, and assessing the totality of the sentence. The Court also had to decide whether to impose concurrent or consecutive sentences, taking into account the need for general and specific deterrence, denunciation, and the protection of the community.

In its judgment, the Court carefully considered the objective seriousness of each offence, noting the significant power differentials, the controlling and manipulative nature of the offending, and the long-term impact on the victims. The Court also examined the subjective circumstances of the offender, including his troubled upbringing and history of violent and abusive behaviour towards his partners. The Court found that the offender's prospects of rehabilitation were poor, and that the protection of the community was a paramount consideration.

The Court imposed a total sentence of 14 years and 2 months, with a non-parole period of 8 years and 6 months. The sentences for each offence were structured to ensure that the overall sentence was just and appropriate, taking into account the need for totality and the separate offending against different victims. The Court did not recommend any specific conditions for parole, considering the length of the sentence and the need to allow the Sentence Administration Board discretion in making parole decisions.

The final orders of the Court included convictions and sentences for each of the offences, the dismissal of certain charges, and the imposition of a non-parole period.

Background

Background to the litigation

Shay Kahu Murphy was convicted by a jury on charges related to two victims, Ms A and Ms B, while he pleaded guilty to charges involving Ms C and Ms D. The charges span a range of offences including grievous bodily harm, sexual offences without consent, assault, and property damage, occurring in multiple incidents over several years. The offending against Ms A began in September 2011 when she was 16 and he was 20. They met at Michel’s Patisserie where she undertook work experience and he was a full-time employee. Over time, their relationship turned abusive, with him displaying controlling and aggressive behaviour. Ms A was manipulated into cutting herself, resulting in grievous bodily harm charges. The relationship ended in February 2012. The offending against Ms B began in July 2012 when they were both working at Canberra Hospital. They married in 2016 and had a daughter, but the relationship ended in November 2018. The charges against Ms B include multiple counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm, sexual offences without consent, and common assault, all of which occurred within a context of family violence. The relationship with Ms C started in 2019 and was marked by controlling and abusive behaviour, including choking and threatening conduct, resulting in charges of choking, suffocation, and property damage. Ms D's relationship with Murphy started in July 2021, characterized by jealousy and verbal abuse, culminating in an assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Throughout the relationships, Murphy demonstrated a pattern of emotional manipulation, controlling, and violent behaviour, and degradation towards his partners.

Director of Public Prosecutions v Murphy (No 2) is a sentencing proceeding following the conviction of Shay Kahu Murphy on various charges related to multiple victims. Murphy was initially convicted by a jury on 10 February 2023 on charges related to Ms A and Ms B. Prior to the sentencing hearing, Murphy pleaded guilty to charges related to Ms C and Ms B, which were severed from the initial trial. The court considered several transfer charges pressed by the Director of Public Prosecutions, determining which should be dismissed based on the jury's verdicts on associated counts. The sentencing hearing addressed the objective seriousness of the offences, which ranged from mid-range to the worst category, within a family violence context. Victim impact statements were presented, highlighting the profound and lasting effects on the victims. The court also considered the subjective circumstances of the offender, including his dysfunctional upbringing and history of abusive behavior. Murphy's lack of remorse and denial of the charges further influenced the sentencing considerations. The court imposed a total sentence of 14 years and two months, with a non-parole period of eight years and six months, reflecting the need for general and specific deterrence, denunciation, and community protection.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the objective seriousness of the offences committed against Ms A?
2. What is the objective seriousness of the offences committed against Ms B?
3. What is the objective seriousness of the offences committed against Ms C?
4. What is the objective seriousness of the offences committed against Ms D?
5. Should the transfer charges be dismissed as per the prosecution's submission?
6. Is the offender at a medium to high risk of general reoffending and above average risk of sexual reoffending?
7. Should the offender's plea of guilty be taken into account when determining the sentence?
8. Should the time the offender has already spent in custody be taken into account when determining the sentence?
9. What is the appropriate non-parole period for the offender's total sentence?

Held
1. The court found the offence against Ms A, specifically the negligent infliction of grievous bodily harm, to be at the low end of objective seriousness. The court found the offence of recklessly inflicting grievous bodily harm on Ms A to be in the low to mid-range of objective seriousness. The court found the offence of sexual intercourse without consent against Ms A to be in the mid-range of objective seriousness.

2. The court found the common assault charges against Ms B (CC2021/11049, CC2021/11050, CC2021/11058) to be at the upper end of the mid-range of objective seriousness. The court found the property damage charge (CC2021/11052) against Ms B to be in the mid-range of objective seriousness. The court found the assault occasioning actual bodily harm charges (Count 10, Count 12) against Ms B to be in the high end and mid-range of objective seriousness, respectively. The court found the common assault charges (Count 18, Count 19) against Ms B to be in the worst category of case for a common assault. The court found the sexual intercourse without consent charges (Count 15, Count 17) against Ms B to be at the upper end of the mid-range of objective seriousness.

3. The court found the offence of choke, strangle or suffocate against Ms C to be in the mid-range of objective seriousness. The court found the common assault and property damage charges (CC2021/11194, CC2021/11195) against Ms C to be in the mid-range of objective seriousness.

4. The court found the offence of assault occasioning actual bodily harm against Ms D to be at the low end of the mid-range of objective seriousness.

5. The court agreed with the prosecution's submission and dismissed the transfer charges CC2022/1148, CC2022/1146, and CC2021/11051.

6. The court accepted the opinion of the pre-sentence report and Dr. Bollinger that the offender is at a medium to high risk of general reoffending and above average risk of sexual reoffending.

7. The court decided that the offender's plea of guilty to some charges should result in a reduction of between 10 and 15 percent of the sentence.

8. The court decided to take into account the 188 days the offender has already spent in custody by backdating the sentence until 10 February 2023.

9. The court determined that the appropriate non-parole period for the offender's total sentence is eight years and six months, which corresponds to 60 percent of the total sentence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, presided over by Justice Mossop, meticulously examined the nature and gravity of the offences committed against each of the victims, Ms A, Ms B, Ms C, and Ms D, in the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Murphy (No 2). The court delineated the objective seriousness of these offences by taking into account the context in which they were committed, and the surrounding circumstances, including the relationship dynamics and the family violence context. For instance, the offences against Ms A ranged from the low end of objective seriousness, such as the negligent infliction of grievous bodily harm, to the mid-range for sexual intercourse without consent. The offences against Ms B were predominantly in the mid-range of objective seriousness, particularly those involving common assault, but escalated to the high end for offences that involved particularly egregious acts of violence and degradation, such as the waterboarding incident. The offences against Ms C and Ms D, while fewer in number, were also assessed within the mid-range of objective seriousness, with particular emphasis on the controlling and abusive nature of the relationship.

In considering whether the transfer charges should be dismissed as per the prosecution's submission, the court exercised its discretion based on the interests of justice, ultimately agreeing with the prosecution's assessment and dismissing certain charges. The court assessed the risk of general and sexual reoffending, concluding that the offender was at a medium to high risk of general reoffending and above average risk of sexual reoffending, based on the entrenched pattern of abusive behavior and the lack of significant insight into his conduct.

The offender's plea of guilty, entered after the jury's verdicts on related offences, was acknowledged by the court, warranting a reduction in sentence, albeit not to the extent of the full 10-15% typically considered. The time the offender had already spent in custody was also taken into account by backdating the commencement of the sentence to the date of his initial committal.

In determining the appropriate non-parole period, the court applied the principles of sentencing under the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), placing significant weight on the need for general and specific deterrence, denunciation, and the protection of the community, given the entrenched pattern of offending and the potential risk to future victims. The total sentence imposed was 14 years and two months, with a non-parole period of eight years and six months, reflecting 60% of the total sentence, a proportion deemed appropriate given the circumstances of the offending and the offender.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is the careful consideration of the objective seriousness of each offence, the context in which they were committed, the risk of reoffending, and the application of sentencing principles to arrive at a sentence that appropriately balances deterrence, denunciation, accountability, and the protection of the community, while also considering the time already served by the offender and the plea of guilty. The court distinguished itself from prior authority by placing significant emphasis on the family violence context and the entrenched pattern of offending, aligning with contemporary sentencing practices that recognise the social significance of deterring family violence.