Director of Public Prosecutions v Matthews

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Director of Public Prosecutions v Matthews (No 2)

Citation:

[2023] ACTSC 52

Hearing Dates:

28 February; 17 March 2023

DecisionDate:

21 March 2023

Before:

McCallum CJ

Decision:

(1) For the offence of causing grievous bodily harm to Alun Mills by a negligent act contrary to s 25 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), the offender is convicted and sentenced to a            term of imprisonment for twenty months commencing on            11 November 2021 and expiring on 10 July 2023.

(2) For the offence of causing grievous bodily harm to Alyce Mueck by a negligent act contrary to s 25 of the Crimes            Act 1900 (ACT), the offender is convicted and sentenced to a term of imprisonment commencing on 11 February 2022 and expiring on 10 October 2023 and a good behaviour order for a period of 12 months commencing on 11 October 2023 subject to the condition that, should he, during that period, no longer be subject to an order of the ACAT under s 58(2) of the Mental Health Act2015            (ACT), he accept such treatment as may be            recommended by his general medical practitioner, Dr            Anthony Morris, or any general medical practitioner or            specialist acting instead of     him, in relation to his            diagnosed condition of schizophrenia including            recommendations as to appropriate medication.

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – Act of negligence causing grievous bodily harm – driving at police officers – schizophrenia – mis-prescribed medication – whether moral culpability is reduced by the Verdins principles – where the s 10 threshold has been crossed   

Legislation Cited:

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 25, 321(2), 323

Crimes (Sentencing) 2005 (ACT) ss 7, 10(2), 35, 49, 53(1)(b)

Mental Health Act 2015 (ACT) s 58(2)

Cases Cited:

Director of Public Prosecutions (Commonwealth) v De La Rosa [2010] NSWCCA 194; 79 NSWLR 1

Hughes v Grieve [2006] ACTSC 92
R v De Simoni [1981] HCA 31; 147 CLR 383
R v Massey [2022] ACTSC 3
R v Matthews [2022] ACTSC 105

R v Verdins [2007] VSCA 102; 16 VR 240

Parties:

Director of Public Prosecutions

Thomas Matthews ( Offender)

Representation:

Counsel

A Williamson ( DPP)

J Pappas ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Hugo Law Group ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 281 of 2021

SCC 282 of 2021

McCALLUM CJ:

  1. These proceedings raise a difficult sentencing task.  On 11 July 2021 the offender, Thomas Matthews, was driving along Lady Denman Drive about to merge right when he suddenly swerved left and ploughed into three uniformed police officers standing on the side of the road.  The officers were performing routine traffic duties.  They had just pulled another driver over for failing to stop at a stop sign and had issued him with a caution.  At the time of the collision, they were standing between the other driver’s car and the police car.  Two were very new to the police force, having…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Matthews and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, McCallum CJ presided over the case of the Director of Public Prosecutions v Matthews. The offender, Thomas Matthews, was convicted and sentenced for causing grievous bodily harm to two police officers by a negligent act, contrary to s 25 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). Matthews was driving negligently, knowing the deleterious effects of his medication, when he collided with the three police officers. The prosecution accepted that the collision was unintentional and filed a notice declining to proceed with the charges of attempted murder. Matthews pleaded guilty to the reduced charges of causing grievous bodily harm by a negligent act. The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the threshold for imprisonment was met and whether the Verdins principles should apply in this case.

The court found that the threshold for imprisonment was met, considering the nature of the injuries suffered by the victims, the impact of the offences on them, and the degree of departure from the standard of care that a reasonable person would have exhibited. The court also found that while Verdins principles were engaged, the offender's mental illness did not contribute to the commission of the offences in a material way. The court accepted that a custodial sentence may weigh more heavily on a mentally ill person but found that the danger to the community required a sentence that would protect the community, increasing the need for general deterrence or specific deterrence.

The court took into account the offender's guilty pleas, his expressed remorse, and the support he received from his family. It was also noted that Matthews had already spent a substantial period in custody. The court ultimately decided to impose a combination sentence for the second offence, consisting of a term of imprisonment combined with a 12-month good behaviour order. The aggregate sentence expired on 10 October 2023.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thomas Matthews, a 33-year-old man, experienced a decline in his mental health around 2019, leading to a diagnosis of schizophrenia. In May 2021, Matthews was subject to an emergency intervention under the Mental Health Act 2015 (ACT) and was arrested and charged with arson and using an offensive weapon to endanger life after hitting a police officer with a knife and setting fire to his unit. He was subsequently released on bail and placed under a treatment order, receiving anti-psychotic medication.

On 11 July 2021, Matthews was driving along Lady Denman Drive when he suddenly swerved left and collided with three uniformed police officers who were standing on the side of the road. The officers were discussing ways to deal with members of the public when they were unexpectedly and violently hit by Matthews' car. The collision caused serious physical injuries and ongoing psychological harm to the police officers. Matthews was charged with three counts of attempted murder and one count of culpable driving causing grievous bodily harm with alternative counts of driving a motor vehicle at police. However, the prosecution later changed the charges to two counts of causing grievous bodily harm by a negligent act.

Expert evidence revealed that Matthews' car was slowing down before the swerve to the left, suggesting that he did not initially see the police officers and reacted to avoid the collision. The prosecution accepted that this evidence was inconsistent with an intention to kill and supported Matthews' case that the collision was not deliberate. Matthews pleaded guilty to the two reduced charges, and the Court accepted the pleas on the basis that he was negligent in driving at a time when he was aware of the deleterious effects of his medication.

The impact of the collision on the police officers was severe. Detective Leading Senior Constable Alun Mills sustained an acute compressive fracture to his T12 vertebral body and experienced ongoing back and muscular pain. Constable Alyce Mueck sustained three separate fracture injuries to her right leg and underwent a surgical procedure for the insertion of a right tibial nail. Constable Melanie Miller, who was also injured in the collision, suffered an undisplaced fracture of the lateral tibial plateau, minor tearing and a strain. The significant physical and psychological injuries caused to the police officers played a crucial role in the sentencing decision.

The proceedings in Director of Public Prosecutions v Matthews before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory represent a significant development in the case following the initial charges of attempted murder and culpable driving causing grievous bodily harm. Initially, Thomas Matthews was charged with attempted murder and culpable driving causing grievous bodily harm, following a collision with three police officers on 11 July 2021. However, the prosecution subsequently altered its case, withdrawing the more serious charges and proceeding with lesser charges of causing grievous bodily harm by a negligent act under s 25 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). Matthews pleaded guilty to these reduced charges. The case came before McCallum CJ on 28 February and 17 March 2023 for sentencing, with the decision delivered on 21 March 2023. This decision followed an earlier case, R v Matthews [2022] ACTSC 105, where Matthews was found not guilty by reason of mental impairment for offences arising from an arson incident. Matthews's plea of guilty was accepted by the prosecution on the condition that Matthews was negligent in driving while being aware of the deleterious effects of his medication. The Court was required to consider the degree of negligence and the impact of Matthews's schizophrenia and its treatment on his culpability and the appropriate sentence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should consider the offender’s mental state and the side effects of his medication as mitigating factors in determining the degree of negligence.
2. Whether the court should be satisfied that no other penalty than imprisonment is appropriate, considering the nature of the injuries suffered by the victims and the impact of the offences on them.
3. Whether the Verdins principles should be applied to reduce the offender’s moral culpability and the need for general deterrence due to his mental illness.
4. Whether the offender’s guilty plea should result in a reduction of sentence and, if so, what percentage reduction is appropriate.
5. Whether the offender’s expressions of remorse and his prospects for rehabilitation should be taken into account in determining the appropriate sentence.

Held
1. Whether the court should consider the offender’s mental state and the side effects of his medication as mitigating factors in determining the degree of negligence. The court concluded that the offender’s awareness of the side effects of his medication and his decision to drive despite that knowledge constituted a high degree of negligence. Result: No, the court did not consider these factors as mitigating.
2. Whether the court should be satisfied that no other penalty than imprisonment is appropriate, considering the nature of the injuries suffered by the victims and the impact of the offences on them. The court concluded that imprisonment was necessary to denounce the high degree of negligence and the substantial harm done to the victims. Result: Yes, the court was satisfied that no other penalty was appropriate.
3. Whether the Verdins principles should be applied to reduce the offender’s moral culpability and the need for general deterrence due to his mental illness. The court concluded that the offender’s mental illness did not materially contribute to the commission of the offences and therefore did not reduce his moral culpability. Result: No, the Verdins principles were not applied to reduce the offender’s culpability or the need for general deterrence.
4. Whether the offender’s guilty plea should result in a reduction of sentence and, if so, what percentage reduction is appropriate. The court concluded that the offender was entitled to a 15% reduction in sentence for pleading guilty. Result: Yes, a 15% reduction is appropriate.
5. Whether the offender’s expressions of remorse and his prospects for rehabilitation should be taken into account in determining the appropriate sentence. The court considered the offender’s expressions of remorse and his prospects for rehabilitation, supported by his stable mental state and strong family support, in determining the sentence. Result: Yes, these factors were taken into account in sentencing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered several key issues in sentencing Thomas Matthews, including the relevance of his mental state and side effects of his medication, the appropriateness of imprisonment, the application of Verdins principles, the effect of his guilty plea, and the impact of his remorse and prospects for rehabilitation.

First, the court rejected the argument that Matthews' mental state and side effects of his medication should substantially mitigate his culpability. Although Matthews had been diagnosed with schizophrenia and was on medication known to cause side effects like blurred vision, he had been aware of these side effects for some time and had been trying to minimize his driving. The court found that Matthews' decision to drive despite knowing he was at risk of blurred vision demonstrated a high degree of negligence. Therefore, his mental state and side effects did not significantly reduce his moral culpability.

Second, the court concluded that no penalty other than imprisonment was appropriate. The victims had suffered serious and lasting injuries and psychological harm. Given the objective seriousness of the offences and the impact on the victims, imprisonment was necessary to adequately denounce the offences and protect the community.

Third, the court considered the Verdins principles, which state that an offender's mental illness may reduce moral culpability and the need for general deterrence. However, the court found that Matthews' mental illness did not materially contribute to the commission of the offences. While a custodial sentence may weigh more heavily on a mentally ill person, Matthews was not considered a danger to the community so long as his medication was properly managed.

Fourth, the court accepted that Matthews was entitled to a 20% reduction in sentence for his early guilty plea. While the prosecution agreed that no further custodial sentence was needed, the court found that the need to denounce Matthews' high degree of negligence and recognize the harm done to the victims warranted some period of imprisonment.

Finally, the court noted Matthews' expressions of remorse and good prospects for rehabilitation, given his stable mental state and strong family support. However, these factors did not outweigh the need for some custodial sentence.

In summary, the key legal principles applied were the objective seriousness of the offences, the impact on the victims, the purposes of sentencing, and the Verdins principles regarding mental illness. The ratio decidendi is that an offender's mental illness may reduce moral culpability and the need for general deterrence, but this does not necessarily preclude some period of imprisonment if the offences demonstrate a high degree of negligence and cause serious harm to victims.