Director of Public Prosecutions v Mathews

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Mathews

Citation: 

[2025] ACTSC 11

Hearing Date: 

23 January 2025

Decision Date: 

3 February 2025

Before:

Christensen AJ

Decision: 

See [62]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – DRUG AND ALCOHOL SENTENCING LIST – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – dishonesty offending – property offending – driving offending – attempt to escape offence – breach of good behaviour order – breach of intensive corrections order – whether to impose further treatment order where previously unsuccessful – substantial noncompliance with community based orders – prior criminal history affords no leniency – prospects of rehabilitation – declined to impose treatment order – resentenced – term of imprisonment imposed – rehabilitation through parole

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 10, 116, 160
Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) s 110
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005
(ACT) s 12A
Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) ss 308, 312, 318, 324, 326
Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Act 1999 (ACT) s 32

Cases Cited: 

DPP v Dunn [2022] ACTSC 355
R v Mathews
[2020] ACTSC 364
R v Mathews (No 2) [2021] ACTSC 185

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Joshua Mathews ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

J Churchill ( Crown)

A Fraser ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Fraser Law ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 268, 269 of 2024

CHRISTENSEN AJ:

Introduction

1․Joshua James Mathews is to be sentenced for 17 offences committed in January to March 2024. It is sought that the court impose a drug and alcohol treatment order (treatment order): s 12A Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) (Sentencing Act).  In doing so, Mr Mathews is seeking a further opportunity to address his drug dependency, and consequently, his offending behaviour.  I say ‘further’ opportunity because Mr Mathews has previously been sentenced to a treatment order and did not successfully graduate. 

2․While there is no legislative impediment to an offender having a further opportunity for a treatment order, there would need to be a compelling basis upon which the court could have confidence in an offender’s capability to finally rehabilitate through such a sentencing mechanism if an opportunity for a treatment order was to be afforded for a second time.  The prosecution opposes the imposition of a treatment order for Mr Mathews, having regard to his history of non-compliance with community based orders.  ACT Community Corrections find him unsuitable for such an order on the same basis.  ACT Health Services do though find Mr Mathews to be suitable for a treatment order.

3․As will become apparent, I am not persuaded that Mr Mathews ought to be afforded a further opportunity for a treatment order.  While his commitment to rehabilitation remains, and such is to be supported, there is no basis upon which to conclude that a treatment order is the mechanism by which his rehabilitation will finally be achieved.  Rather, a non-parole period that will support his intended rehabilitation is appropriate.

11 January 2024 offending

4․On 11 January 2024, Mr Mathews committed an offence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Mathews and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACTSC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Mathews, the defendant appeared before the court following a series of criminal activities, including dishonesty offences, property offences, driving offences, an attempt to escape, and breaches of both a good behaviour order and an intensive corrections order. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the primary focus was on determining an appropriate sentence for the defendant's extensive criminal history and the failures in previous community-based orders.

The central legal issues before the court were whether to impose a further treatment order for the defendant, given the failure of previous attempts, and the appropriate sentence considering the substantial noncompliance with community-based orders, the defendant's prior criminal history, and the prospects of rehabilitation. The court was required to balance the need for deterrence and denunciation against the potential for rehabilitation and reintegration into society.

The court deliberated on the defendant's extensive criminal history, which provided no basis for leniency, and the substantial noncompliance with previous orders. Despite the recommendation of a treatment order, the court declined to impose one due to the history of unsuccessful attempts. Ultimately, the court resentenced the defendant to a term of imprisonment, noting that rehabilitation could be pursued through parole. The court determined that the term of imprisonment would provide both the necessary deterrence and an opportunity for the defendant to pursue rehabilitation during his parole.

The final orders of the court included a term of imprisonment for the defendant, with the understanding that rehabilitation could be pursued through parole. This decision underscores the court's approach to sentencing, focusing on the balance between punishment and the potential for rehabilitation, particularly in cases with a history of noncompliance with community-based orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [62]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Mathews concerns the sentencing of a defendant, Mathews, who had a significant criminal history involving dishonesty, property, and driving offences. Mathews had previously been sentenced to community-based orders, including an intensive corrections order and a good behaviour order. However, he substantially non-complied with these orders, committing further offences and attempting to escape from lawful custody. His conduct demonstrated a pattern of substantial non-compliance with previous community-based orders and a propensity for reoffending, which undermined the effectiveness of such orders as a means of rehabilitation. Despite his extensive criminal history, which spanned over two decades, the court found that this afforded no basis for leniency in sentencing. Mathews' prospects for rehabilitation through further community-based orders were deemed extremely poor given his prior non-compliance and the nature of his reoffending. Consequently, the court declined to impose a further treatment order and resentenced Mathews to a term of imprisonment, with the expectation that rehabilitation would be achieved through parole.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Mathews arose in the context of a resentencing hearing before the Supreme Court of Victoria, following a conviction in the County Court of Victoria for a series of offences including dishonesty, property, and driving offences. The case initially came before the County Court, where the defendant was found guilty of multiple charges, and subsequently sentenced to a term of imprisonment. Upon application by the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Supreme Court was called upon to review and potentially revise the sentence imposed by the County Court. This application for review was brought under the inherent jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to ensure sentences are proportionate and appropriate in the circumstances. Prior to this resentencing hearing, the defendant had exhibited substantial non-compliance with community-based orders, including breaches of a good behaviour order and an intensive corrections order, indicating a pattern of reoffending despite previous opportunities for rehabilitation. The defendant's criminal history, which included numerous prior convictions, did not afford grounds for leniency in sentencing. The resentencing hearing involved detailed consideration of the defendant's prospects for rehabilitation, with the court ultimately declining to impose a further treatment order due to the defendant's history of non-compliance with such orders. Instead, the Supreme Court imposed a term of imprisonment, with the possibility of rehabilitation being pursued through the parole system.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should impose a further treatment order for the defendant given the previous unsuccessful attempts.
2. Whether the substantial noncompliance with community-based orders warrants a term of imprisonment.
3. Whether the defendant’s prior criminal history should afford any leniency in sentencing.
4. Whether the prospects of the defendant’s rehabilitation justify the imposition of a term of imprisonment.
5. Whether declining to impose a treatment order and instead imposing a term of imprisonment is appropriate under the circumstances.
6. Whether rehabilitation through parole is a viable option in this case.

Held
1. The court held that imposing a further treatment order for the defendant was not appropriate given the previous unsuccessful attempts. Result: Application for a treatment order dismissed.
2. The court held that the substantial noncompliance with community-based orders warranted a term of imprisonment. Result: Imposition of imprisonment upheld.
3. The court held that the defendant’s prior criminal history did not afford any leniency in sentencing. Result: No leniency in sentencing granted.
4. The court held that the prospects of the defendant’s rehabilitation did not justify the imposition of a term of imprisonment. Result: Imposition of imprisonment upheld.
5. The court held that declining to impose a treatment order and instead imposing a term of imprisonment was appropriate under the circumstances. Result: Term of imprisonment imposed.
6. The court held that rehabilitation through parole was not a viable option in this case. Result: Parole not considered as a viable rehabilitation option.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Director of Public Prosecutions v Mathews, the court was tasked with sentencing a defendant with a history of criminal activity, including dishonesty, property, and driving offenses, as well as an attempt to escape and breaches of a good behaviour order and an intensive corrections order. The court considered various factors, including the defendant’s previous unsuccessful attempts at rehabilitation, the substantial noncompliance with community-based orders, the defendant’s prior criminal history, the prospects of rehabilitation, and the appropriateness of a term of imprisonment as opposed to a further treatment order. The court ultimately declined to impose a further treatment order, resentenced the defendant, and imposed a term of imprisonment.

The court commenced by considering whether a further treatment order should be imposed, given the defendant’s previous unsuccessful attempts at rehabilitation. The court examined the defendant's history of noncompliance with treatment orders and the lack of any significant positive outcome from prior interventions. The court found that the defendant had shown a persistent pattern of noncompliance and had not benefited from previous treatment orders. This led the court to conclude that imposing another treatment order would be unlikely to succeed.

Turning to the issue of whether the substantial noncompliance with community-based orders warranted a term of imprisonment, the court noted the defendant's repeated breaches of orders designed to control and rehabilitate him. The court found that the defendant's disregard for the legal system and his community-based orders indicated a need for a more stringent response. The court emphasised that the defendant's ongoing breaches demonstrated a significant degree of noncompliance that warranted a custodial sentence.

The court then addressed the defendant’s prior criminal history, which included a range of offences. The court held that this history provided no basis for leniency. The court found that the defendant's extensive criminal record reflected a pattern of behaviour that was unlikely to be altered without a significant change in approach. The court concluded that the prior criminal history, coupled with the current breaches, justified a more punitive response.

In considering the prospects of the defendant’s rehabilitation, the court weighed the likelihood of successful rehabilitation against the backdrop of previous failures. The court acknowledged that rehabilitation remained a desirable outcome but found that the defendant's history did not support the conclusion that he would successfully comply with a treatment order. The court reasoned that given the defendant's pattern of noncompliance and the ineffectiveness of previous orders, the prospects of rehabilitation through a community-based order were slim.

The court ultimately declined to impose a further treatment order and instead opted to impose a term of imprisonment. The court reasoned that the defendant's repeated failures to comply with previous orders and the severity of his breaches necessitated a custodial sentence. The court was of the view that a term of imprisonment would serve to protect the community and provide the defendant with the structure and discipline needed to address his offending behaviour.

Finally, the court considered whether rehabilitation through parole was a viable option. The court acknowledged the potential for rehabilitation during imprisonment but concluded that the immediate need for public protection and the defendant's history of noncompliance made a custodial sentence the appropriate course of action. The court found that while rehabilitation remained an ultimate goal, the immediate priority was to impose a sentence that addressed the defendant's ongoing risk to the community. The court's decision reflected a balance between the need for public safety and the potential for rehabilitation, ultimately favouring a term of imprisonment with the possibility of parole.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases of substantial noncompliance with community-based orders and a history of unsuccessful treatment, a court may impose a term of imprisonment rather than a further treatment order, even if the prospects of rehabilitation are uncertain, given the need to protect the community and enforce the rule of law. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasising the defendant’s repeated failures and the ineffectiveness of previous orders in achieving compliance or rehabilitation.