Local Court of New South Wales
CITATION: DPP v Mark Daniel SMILLIE [2010] NSWLC 12 JURISDICTION: Criminal PARTIES: NSW Director of Public Prosecutions
Mark Daniel SMILLIEFILE NUMBER: PLACE OF HEARING: Albury Local Court DATE OF DECISION: 05/14/2010 MAGISTRATE: Magistrate Lerve CATCHWORDS: Identification – identification from CCTV footage – displacement effect – discharge after defended committal LEGISLATION CITED: Criminal Procedure Act 1986
Crimes Act 1900CASES CITED: Allen & Saffron (1989) 43 A Crim R 1
Festa v The Queen (2001) 76 ALJR 291
R v Clarke (1997) 97 A Crim R 414
R v Ilioski [2006] NSWCCA 164
R v Marshall (2000) 113 A Crim R 190
R v Mendoza [2007] VSCA 120
R v Pretorius [2007] QCA 432
Smith v The Queen (2001) 125 A Crim R 10TEXTS CITED: Odgers – Uniform Evidence Law 8th Edition REPRESENTATION: Ms. M. Shields for the Director of Public Prosecutions
Mr. C. Murnane of the Legal Aid Commission for and with the accused.ORDERS: The evidence of identification is so unsatisfactory that the accused should be discharged. Therefore, the formal orders I made are:
(1) I am of the opinion that the prosecution evidence is capable of satisfying a jury, properly instructed, beyond reasonable doubt that the accused person has committed an indictable offence; however
(2) For the reasons set out above, I am not of the opinion that there is a reasonable prospect of a reasonable jury, properly instructed would convict the accused of an indictable offence; and accordingly
(3) The Accused is discharged in respect of the charge of Break and Enter and Commit the Serious Indictable Offence of Assault Occasioning Actual Bodily Harm that is before the Court.
Reasons for Decision
1. The accused stands charged with the five matters set out above. The most serious of the charges is Sequence 1, i.e. the Break and Enter and Commit Serious Indictable Offence, namely, assault occasioning actual bodily harm. This matter is strictly indictable because of the nature of the serious indictable offence that is alleged to have been committed. The remaining four mattes are purely summary matters. However, the difficulties faced by the Crown with the issue of identification will also be present with the four summary charges. I had intended to give this decision on 19 April 2010; however, the transcript of the evidence of the two witnesses called at committal did not come to hand until the afternoon of 15 April 2010.
Facts
2. In this matter it is uncontroversial that shortly after 11pm on 6 May 2009 a male broke into the premises at 350 Stephen Street, Albury. Ms. Katherine Doogood, one of the new tenants at those premises disturbed the intruder when she heard rattling at the rear of the house. She said to the intruder, “what are you doing in my house, you’re breaking into my house”. The intruder replied, “Oh shit, wrong house”. The intruder grabbed Ms. Doogood on the right forearm, scratched her and pulled her into the door. The intruder…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Mark Daniel Smillie and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NSWLC 12
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court needed to resolve involved the reliability and sufficiency of CCTV identification evidence, particularly in light of the so-called "displacement effect," which refers to the potential for a witness's memory of an event to be influenced by the viewing of CCTV footage. The court had to assess whether the evidence of identification from the CCTV footage was compelling enough to support a conviction beyond reasonable doubt. The primary focus was on whether the jury, properly instructed, would have a reasonable prospect of convicting the accused based on the evidence presented.
The court concluded that the CCTV identification evidence was unsatisfactory due to the displacement effect and other factors impacting its reliability. The footage was of poor quality, and there were other inconsistencies in the evidence that undermined its probative value. Consequently, the court held that there was not a reasonable prospect of a reasonable jury convicting the accused based on the identification evidence. As a result, the court discharged the defendant from the charge of break and enter and commit the serious indictable offence of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.
Orders
Orders of the court
The evidence of identification is so unsatisfactory that the accused should be discharged. Therefore, the formal orders I made are:
(1) I am of the opinion that the prosecution evidence is capable of satisfying a jury, properly instructed, beyond reasonable doubt that the accused person has committed an indictable offence; however
(2) For the reasons set out above, I am not of the opinion that there is a reasonable prospect of a reasonable jury, properly instructed would convict the accused of an indictable offence; and accordingly
(3) The Accused is discharged in respect of the charge of Break and Enter and Commit the Serious Indictable Offence of Assault Occasioning Actual Bodily Harm that is before the Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi