SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Manns |
Citation: | [2023] ACTSC 71 |
Hearing Date: | 10 March 2023 |
DecisionDate: | 31 March 2023 |
Before: | Mossop J |
Decision: | See [35] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Nonpublication orders – whether nonpublication orders should be made – witnesses concerned with repercussions of giving evidence if identities disclosed – orders made until the conclusion of the trial of the accused CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – Admissibility of photographs which form basis of opinions – photographs of firearm found on accused’s phone – opinions of firearm examiner and fingerprint examiner – whether temporal connection between photographs and charged offence gives rise to unfair prejudice – significant strand in prosecution’s circumstantial case – photographs and opinions not inadmissible |
Legislation Cited: | Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), s 111 Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), ss 135, 137 |
Cases Cited: | Arico v The Queen [2018] VSCA 135; 272 A Crim R 450 R v Debs [2008] VSCA 240; 191 A Crim R 231 |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions Connor John Manns ( Accused) |
Representation: | Counsel T Hickey (DPP) J Maher ( Accused) |
| Solicitors Director of Public Prosecutions Hugo Law Group ( Accused) | |
File Numbers: | SCC 79 of 2022 SCC 105 of 2022 SCC 106 of 2022 SCC 107 of 2022 |
MOSSOP J:
Introduction
The accused, Mr Connor John Manns, is facing five charges:
(a)Count 1 - Attempted murder;
(b)Count 2 - Attempting to intentionally inflict grievous bodily harm (alternative to count 1);
(c)Count 3 - Intentionally and unlawfully discharging loaded arms at another person so as to cause another person reasonable apprehension for their safety (alternative to count 2);
(d)Count 4 - Using a carriage service to make a threat to cause serious harm; and
(e)Count 5 - Using a carriage service in a way that reasonable persons would regard as being, in all the circumstances, menacing, harassing or offensive (alternative to count 4).
These reasons relate to two applications brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) and one application brought by the accused.
The DPP seeks orders pursuant to s 111 of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) (EMP Act) forbidding publication of the names of two witnesses who the DPP proposes to call at the trial.
The accused seeks orders excluding evidence of opinion contained in various paragraphs of a report prepared by a forensic firearms and toolmark examiner, Mr Clive Roberts, and excluding the evidence of opinion expressed in a report of Mr Andrew Cross, a fingerprint examiner.
Part of the challenge to the evidence of Mr Roberts was based upon the decision of the Court of Appeal in Sidaros v The Queen [2020] ACTCA 11. In response to that application the DPP has sought a supplementary report from Mr Roberts elaborating upon the reasons for his conclusions. That report is not yet available and the parties approached the application on the basis that this aspect of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Manns and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] ACTSC 71
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Regarding the nonpublication orders, the court found that both witnesses had reasonable apprehensions of harassment if their identities were disclosed. The court determined that the witnesses' identities should not be published until the conclusion of the trial. The court also found that the photographic evidence and the opinions of the expert witnesses were not inadmissible, as they had significant probative value in the prosecution's circumstantial case.
The court ruled that the publication of the names of the two witnesses should be forbidden until the conclusion of the trial. The evidence of the opinions expressed by the two expert witnesses was deemed admissible under the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT). The court granted liberty to apply to relist the accused's amended application before Mossop J on two days' notice.
Background
Background to the litigation
The accused has challenged the admissibility of expert evidence regarding photographs of a pistol found on his phone. These photographs were taken in March 2021, well before the alleged shooting incident in November 2021. The prosecution argues that these photographs are crucial as they link Mr Manns to the firearm, which they contend could have been the weapon used in the shooting. The accused contends that the temporal gap between the possession of the firearm and the alleged offending, coupled with the removal of the firearm's serial number, would unfairly prejudice the jury against him. However, the court found that the probative value of this evidence outweighs any potential prejudice, given its significance in establishing Mr Manns's possession of a weapon capable of committing the alleged crimes. The court also determined that nonpublication orders for the witnesses' identities should be in place until the conclusion of the trial to protect them from potential harassment and ensure their willingness to testify.
This case, Director of Public Prosecutions v Manns, was brought before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as a result of two applications: one brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) seeking nonpublication orders in relation to the names of two witnesses, and another brought by the accused seeking to exclude certain expert evidence. The matter came before the Court for a hearing on 10 March 2023, with the decision handed down on 31 March 2023. The Court's decision dealt with the procedural aspects of the case, including the admissibility of evidence and the making of nonpublication orders, without delving into the substantive legal issues, reasoning, or outcome of the case.
The DPP's application sought nonpublication orders to protect the identities of two witnesses, who were concerned about potential repercussions, including harassment and damage to their employment prospects, if their involvement in the case became public knowledge. The accused opposed these orders, arguing that the witnesses' identities were already known to him and those close to him. However, the Court found that there was a real risk of harassment and other repercussions for the witnesses if their identities were widely published, and thus, it was in the interests of the administration of justice to make nonpublication orders until the conclusion of the trial.
The accused's application sought to exclude expert evidence from a forensic firearms and toolmark examiner, as well as a fingerprint examiner. The admissibility of this evidence turned on the admissibility of photographs of a pistol that formed the basis of the experts' opinions. The accused argued that the evidence was of slight probative value and carried a high risk of unfair prejudice due to the significant temporal gap between the possession of the weapon and the alleged offending. The prosecution, however, contended that the evidence was a significant strand in the circumstantial case against the accused and that the risk of unfair prejudice could be appropriately addressed by directions to the jury. The Court found that the probative value of the evidence was not slight and that the risk of unfair prejudice was minimal, given the context of the case. Consequently, the evidence was deemed admissible.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether nonpublication orders should be made in relation to the identities of the two witnesses, Person A and Person B, to protect them from potential harassment and to ensure their willingness to give evidence without fear of repercussions?
2. Whether the photographs of a pistol found on the accused's phone, which form the basis of expert opinions, are inadmissible due to unfair prejudice under ss 135 or 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT)?
Held
1. Whether nonpublication orders should be made in relation to the identities of the two witnesses, Person A and Person B, to protect them from potential harassment and to ensure their willingness to give evidence without fear of repercussions?
The court concluded that it is in the interests of the administration of justice to make nonpublication orders in relation to Person A and Person B until the conclusion of the trial. As a result, the orders were made and will remain in effect until the conclusion of the trial.
2. Whether the photographs of a pistol found on the accused's phone, which form the basis of expert opinions, are inadmissible due to unfair prejudice under ss 135 or 137 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT)?
The court concluded that the photographs and the evidence of the experts are not inadmissible under ss 135 or 137 of the Evidence Act. As a result, the evidence should not be excluded under s 135, nor should it be excluded under s 137.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning regarding the nonpublication orders involved a careful consideration of the potential risks to the witnesses, Persons A and B, if their identities were to be made public. The judge acknowledged the witnesses' concerns about harassment and the potential impact on their employment prospects and personal safety. Despite the accused's argument that the witnesses' identities were already known to him, the judge held that the publicity and availability of photographs would likely increase the risk of harassment. The judge determined that the interests of justice were served by making nonpublication orders until the conclusion of the trial, balancing the witnesses' safety and willingness to testify against the public's right to know.
The court applied s 111 of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) which allows for nonpublication orders if it is in the interests of the administration of justice. The judge found that the potential for harassment and its impact on the witnesses' willingness to testify justified the making of such orders. The judge relied on the witnesses' testimonies and concerns to establish the necessity of the orders, distinguishing the case from the accused's submission that the "horse had bolted" since the accused already knew their identities.
In considering the admissibility of the photographic evidence, the court had to balance the probative value of the evidence against the danger of unfair prejudice. The accused argued that the temporal gap between the possession of the weapon and the alleged offence would lead to unfair prejudice. The judge examined the prosecution's circumstantial case, which relied heavily on the photographs and expert opinions as a significant strand of evidence. The judge held that the probative value was not slight and that the danger of unfair prejudice could be managed with appropriate jury directions.
The judge relied on the decision in R v Debs [2008] VSCA 240; 191 A Crim R 231, which dismissed an appeal against the admissibility of weapons found years after the offence. The judge distinguished the present case from Arico v The Queen [2018] VSCA 135; 272 A Crim R 450, where the possession of a weapon was indirectly relevant to the charges. In the present case, the possession of a similar weapon was an essential fact in the prosecution's case, and the temporal gap did not render the evidence of limited probative value.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that nonpublication orders may be made to protect witnesses from potential harassment and ensure their willingness to give evidence without fear of repercussions, and that photographs and expert opinions based on those photographs are not inadmissible due to unfair prejudice if their probative value significantly outweighs the danger of prejudice, particularly when they form a crucial part of the prosecution's circumstantial case.