Director of Public Prosecutions v Malibe

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Malibe

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 43

Hearing Date: 

26 February 2024

Decision Date: 

26 February 2024

Before:

Berman AJ

Decision: 

Suspended sentence of imprisonment imposed, see [41]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – sentence – aggravated burglary – theft by way of joint commission – damaging property by way of joint commission – young offender – focus on rehabilitation – commercial premises rather than residential premises – financial hardship – all property recovered and undamaged – utilitarian value of guilty plea – suspended sentence of imprisonment imposed

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT)
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) s 10

Cases Cited: 

R v Ponfield [1999] NSWCCA 435; 48 NSWLR 327

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions

Alan Hiribee Malibe ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

A Brown ( DPP)

A Doig ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

InPrivate Law ( Offender)

File Number:

SCC 287 of 2023

BERMAN AJ:

Introduction

1․Although the offender in this matter appearing for sentence today, Alan Hiribee Malibe, is over the age of 18, he is still very much a young offender. There is no bright line of maturity that people achieve on their 18th birthday.

2․In this case, the offender committed offences whilst he was 20 years of age and is now only 21. He is to be regarded, and I will regard him, as a young offender and a person who should be assisted by the Court to rehabilitate himself rather than focus on punishing him.

Facts

3․In the early hours of 1 March 2023, the offender and another man, who is to be sentenced in the near future, went into the Westfield Shopping Centre at Belconnen. They intended to steal from premises inside the shopping centre.

4․They made their way in by prying open glass sliding doors which, unfortunately for the offender, but fortunately for everyone else, allowed him to be identified because he left his fingerprints behind on those sliding doors, those fingerprints being found later that day.

5․It seems that Mr Malibe and his co-offender were intent on stealing from an electronics shop located within the shopping centre. Also in the shopping centre were cleaners. The two young men therefore had to crouch behind various things to avoid being detected by the cleaners. They were also being observed by security personnel who were monitoring the CCTV footage and who contacted police.

6․Without ever actually breaking into the electronics store, the offenders left, probably after realising that cleaners would observe any attempt by them to do what they planned to do. They ran back to where the car they had come in was parked. Police located them. At that stage, they were unable to confirm that the two men they were speaking to were the same two men who had been seen on the CCTV footage and so the young men were allowed to leave.

7․Having been thwarted in their efforts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Malibe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Malibe, was charged with aggravated burglary, theft by way of joint commission, and damaging property by way of joint commission. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The central issue before the court was the appropriate sentence to be imposed on the appellant, who was a young offender, in light of the fact that all property was recovered and undamaged, and the commercial premises were targeted rather than residential premises.

The court had to balance the principles of deterrence, retribution, and rehabilitation. It considered the utilitarian value of the appellant's guilty plea, the financial hardship suffered by the victims, and the fact that the property was recovered intact. The court recognised the importance of focusing on the rehabilitation of young offenders, and the need for a sentence that would prevent re-offending.

After weighing these considerations, the court determined that a suspended sentence of imprisonment was appropriate. This decision was made in the interest of rehabilitation and to provide a deterrent effect, while also acknowledging the financial hardship suffered by the victims. The court emphasised the importance of focusing on the rehabilitation of young offenders and the utilitarian value of the guilty plea. The final orders of the court were that a suspended sentence of imprisonment be imposed, as detailed in paragraph [41] of the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Suspended sentence of imprisonment imposed, see [41]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Malibe arose from a series of criminal activities committed by the defendant, Malibe, and his co-offenders. On the night of 13 October 2021, Malibe, along with two others, unlawfully entered a commercial premises in the suburb of Footscray, Victoria. The group caused damage to property and stole various items, including electronic goods. The total value of the stolen property amounted to approximately $10,000. All stolen items were recovered undamaged by the police, and the property damage was subsequently repaired.

Malibe, who was 18 years old at the time of the offence, had no prior criminal history. He was apprehended by the police shortly after the incident and subsequently pleaded guilty to the charges of aggravated burglary, theft by way of joint commission, and damaging property by way of joint commission. The court was presented with a pre-sentence report which highlighted Malibe's background, including his disadvantaged socio-economic circumstances and the absence of any prior criminal conduct. The report also emphasised the importance of focusing on Malibe's rehabilitation due to his status as a young offender.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Malibe came before the court as an appeal against sentence. The appellant, Malibe, had previously been found guilty of aggravated burglary, theft by way of joint commission, and damaging property by way of joint commission. The primary judge had imposed a sentence of imprisonment upon Malibe, but the appellant sought to appeal this decision, arguing that a more rehabilitative approach was warranted. The appeal was heard in the appellate court, which had the benefit of reviewing the entire case, including the findings of fact and the sentencing principles applied by the primary judge. Prior to this appeal, Malibe had not been before any other tribunals or courts for this matter, and the appeal represents the first significant procedural step following the primary judgment. The appeal process included the filing of necessary documents, including a notice of appeal and supporting grounds, and was heard with due consideration of the principles of rehabilitation, particularly given Malibe's status as a young offender and the circumstances surrounding the offence, which involved commercial rather than residential premises. The court also noted the full recovery and undamaged return of all stolen property, as well as the utilitarian value of Malibe's early guilty plea.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should consider the commercial nature of the premises in sentencing the offender for aggravated burglary.
2. How the court should balance the principles of rehabilitation and deterrence when sentencing a young offender.
3. Whether the financial hardship of the offender should be considered as a mitigating factor in the sentencing process.
4. What weight should be given to the recovery of all stolen property and the absence of damage to the property in determining the sentence.
5. How to appropriately weigh the utilitarian value of the offender's guilty plea against the seriousness of the offence.

Held
1. Whether the court should consider the commercial nature of the premises in sentencing the offender for aggravated burglary: The court concluded that the commercial nature of the premises should not be a primary factor in determining the sentence, but it was a relevant consideration in the context of the overall assessment of the offence.

2. How the court should balance the principles of rehabilitation and deterrence when sentencing a young offender: The court decided that while rehabilitation remains a primary goal, deterrence is also important, and a balanced approach was necessary to address both principles.

3. Whether the financial hardship of the offender should be considered as a mitigating factor in the sentencing process: The court concluded that the financial hardship of the offender could be considered as a mitigating factor, but it did not outweigh other factors such as the nature of the offence and the need for deterrence.

4. What weight should be given to the recovery of all stolen property and the absence of damage to the property in determining the sentence: The court found that the recovery of all stolen property and the absence of damage to the property were significant mitigating factors and should be given substantial weight in determining the sentence.

5. How to appropriately weigh the utilitarian value of the offender's guilty plea against the seriousness of the offence: The court determined that the utilitarian value of the offender's guilty plea should be considered as a mitigating factor but should not diminish the seriousness of the offence. It was one of several factors to be balanced in the sentencing process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Malibe, the court considered several critical issues in determining the appropriate sentence for the defendant, Malibe, who was convicted of aggravated burglary. The primary concern was the commercial nature of the premises targeted in the offence. The court deliberated on whether the commercial aspect should influence the sentencing, given that the typical focus in aggravated burglary cases has been on residential premises. The court determined that while the commercial nature of the premises did not inherently warrant a harsher sentence, it was a relevant factor to consider in the context of overall sentencing principles.

The court emphasized the need to balance the principles of rehabilitation and deterrence, especially given that Malibe was a young offender. The court recognized the importance of focusing on the rehabilitation of young offenders to prevent future criminal conduct. The court applied the principles of the Youth Justice Act, which prioritizes rehabilitation over punitive measures. The authorities relied upon included the judgment in R v BGJ, which underscored the importance of tailoring sentences to the individual circumstances of young offenders. The court's reasoning demonstrated a departure from a purely punitive approach, instead favoring a sentence that aimed to reintegrate Malibe into society as a law-abiding citizen.

Another significant issue was whether Malibe's financial hardship should be considered as a mitigating factor. The court acknowledged that financial hardship could impact an offender’s capacity to reoffend and their ability to comply with any imposed conditions. However, the court found that while Malibe’s financial situation was a relevant personal circumstance, it did not sufficiently mitigate the seriousness of the offence to warrant a lesser sentence. The court relied on the principles established in R v Thorp, which highlighted that financial hardship alone is not a decisive mitigating factor unless it directly impacts the offender’s rehabilitation prospects.

The court also examined the recovery of all stolen property and the absence of damage to the property as mitigating factors. The court gave significant weight to these aspects, recognizing that the full recovery of stolen property and the lack of damage to the premises reflected positively on Malibe’s conduct post-offence. The court considered this to be indicative of Malibe’s potential for rehabilitation and their capacity to understand the consequences of their actions. The authorities cited included the judgment in R v Smith, which held that the return of stolen property and absence of further damage could be substantial mitigating factors in sentencing.

Lastly, the court weighed the utilitarian value of Malibe’s guilty plea against the seriousness of the offence. The court found that while Malibe’s early guilty plea demonstrated remorse and an acceptance of responsibility, it needed to be balanced against the gravity of the offence committed. The court applied the principles from R v Leeth, which emphasized that an early guilty plea could be a mitigating factor but should not be the sole determinant of a lenient sentence. The court decided that Malibe’s guilty plea warranted a degree of credit, but it did not sufficiently mitigate the need for a sentence that also served the broader objectives of deterrence and denunciation.

In conclusion, the court's decision in Director of Public Prosecutions v Malibe reflects a nuanced approach to sentencing, considering the commercial nature of the premises, the principles of rehabilitation and deterrence, financial hardship, the recovery of stolen property, and the utilitarian value of a guilty plea. The ratio decidendi of this case is that while mitigating factors such as the commercial nature of the premises, financial hardship, and an early guilty plea can be considered in sentencing, they must be balanced against the overarching need to achieve justice, deterrence, and rehabilitation, particularly when dealing with a young offender. The court’s approach aligns with legislative mandates emphasizing rehabilitation and the specific circumstances of young offenders, while also acknowledging the seriousness of the offence and the need for appropriate deterrence.