Director of Public Prosecutions v Larkham

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Larkham

Citation:

[2023] ACTSC 68

Hearing Date:

30 March 2023

DecisionDate:

31 March 2023

Before:

Mossop J

Decision:

See [40]

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and punishment – sentence – plea of guilty to aggravated robbery, dishonestly ride in stolen motor vehicle, possess offensive weapon with intent and dishonestly appropriating property – robbery was of chemist and with use of syringe – robbery had enduring impacts on staff and business – where crimes committed to support drug addiction – offender at crossroads in her life – sentence of imprisonment imposed to be served by way of intensive corrections order

Legislation Cited:

Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), s 11(3)

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), s 334(2)(a)

Criminal Code 2002 (ACT), ss 45A, 310(b), 318(2), 321, 381(1)

Cases Cited:

Barbaro v The Queen [2012] VSCA 288; 226 A Crim R 354

CD v The Queen [2013] VSCA 95
DPP v Larkham [2022] ACTSC 365

Lyddy v The Queen [2019] VSCA 35

Parties:

Director of Public Prosecutions

Grace Emily Larkham (Offender)

Representation:

Counsel

S Bargwanna (DPP)

K Musgrove (Offender)

Solicitors

Director of Public Prosecutions

Hugo Law Group (Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 252 of 2022

SCC 253 of 2022

MOSSOP J:

Introduction

  1. The offender has pleaded guilty to the following offences:

(a)Aggravated robbery contrary to s 310(b) of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) (CAN 6662/2022);

(b)Dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without consent contrary to s 318(2) of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) (CAN 6663/2022);

(c)Possess offensive weapon with intent contrary to s 381(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) (CAN 6664/2022); and

(d)Dishonestly appropriating property contrary to s 321 of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) by virtue of s 45A (CAN 7455/2022).

Facts

  1. The facts are agreed and are in summary as follows.

Burglary, possession of offensive weapon and ride in motor vehicle charges

  1. At about 10:29pm on 10 July 2022 the offender and her co-offender and partner at the time, Kieran Eichmann, arrived at the O’Connor Shops on Sargood Street in a white Toyota Hilux. Investigations would later reveal that the vehicle was stolen.

  1. At 10:38pm they entered Capital Chemist O’Connor. The offender was holding a syringe with a blood-like liquid substance and wearing a balaclava. Mr Eichmann was also in a balaclava and was armed with a nail gun.

  1. The offender approached the store security guard, held the needle up to him, told him to put his phone down in the merchandise stand and said that she would “stab him” if he did not comply. Mr Eichmann continued into the store and screamed at one of the pharmacists to open the safe and to fill his bag with medication, specifically Oxycontin and Valium. At one point the bag became full and the pharmacist was directed to use a different bag. Apart from this description of the need for two bags, the Agreed Statement of Facts does not disclose the amount or value of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Larkham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory was presented with a case involving Grace Emily Larkham, who had pleaded guilty to multiple serious criminal charges, including aggravated robbery, possessing an offensive weapon with intent, dishonestly riding in a stolen motor vehicle, and dishonestly appropriating property. The court was tasked with determining an appropriate sentence for Larkham, considering the objective seriousness of her crimes, her criminal history, and her subjective circumstances, particularly her struggles with substance abuse and mental health issues.

The legal issues before the court included assessing the severity of the crimes committed, understanding Larkham's background and the factors that led to her criminal behaviour, and balancing the need for punishment and deterrence against the potential for rehabilitation. The court had to evaluate the mitigating factors presented, such as Larkham's guilty plea, her limited prior criminal history, and her engagement in a rehabilitation program, against the gravity of the offences which involved threats of violence and targeted a vital community service.

In delivering the judgment, Justice Mossop highlighted the serious nature of the aggravated robbery, noting the use of threats and the impact on the victims and the community. The court acknowledged Larkham's long-term drug addiction and untreated mental health issues, which contributed to her criminal conduct. Despite the severity of the crimes, the court considered Larkham's potential for rehabilitation, her genuine remorse, and her participation in a drug rehabilitation program. The sentence imposed was intended to promote her rehabilitation while ensuring adequate denunciation and deterrence.

The court sentenced Larkham to a total of two years, two months, and 16 days imprisonment, to be served by way of intensive corrections orders. This sentence took into account the time she had already spent in custody and aimed to provide her with the opportunity to engage in rehabilitation programs, thereby addressing the underlying issues that contributed to her offending behaviour. The final orders included specific conditions for the intensive correction orders, such as mandatory community service and restrictions on drug use.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Larkham involves a series of criminal activities committed by Grace Emily Larkham, who pleaded guilty to multiple charges. On 10 July 2022, Larkham and her partner, Kieran Eichmann, arrived at the O'Connor Shops in a stolen Toyota Hilux. They entered Capital Chemist O'Connor, where Larkham threatened the security guard with a syringe containing a blood-like liquid while Eichmann, armed with a nail gun, forced the pharmacist to open the safe and fill bags with medication, including Oxycontin and Valium. Eichmann also forcibly removed the cash register. The pair left the scene in the stolen vehicle and were apprehended by police shortly thereafter. On 20 June 2022, Larkham and Eichmann also stole six jackets from the Anaconda store in Fyshwick, amounting to $1939.94 in value.

The victim impact statements highlighted the severe effects of the crimes on the individuals and business involved. The pharmacist experienced significant stress, leading to medical advice that he should not continue working at the pharmacy, resulting in his resignation. The business owner faced substantial financial and operational disruptions, including a workers' compensation claim, insurance payout, loss of inventory, and increased security costs. The impact on the business, already strained by the pandemic, was profound, forcing the owner to take on additional work and personal burdens.

The offences were deemed to be of high objective seriousness due to the nature and circumstances of the aggravated robbery, the possession of an offensive weapon, and the brazenness of the theft. Larkham's criminal history, which includes convictions for resisting arrest, assaulting an officer, and a dismissed charge of assault occasioning actual bodily harm, was considered alongside her subjective circumstances. Larkham has a long history of illicit drug use, starting at age 12, and has been diagnosed with schizophrenia, anxiety, and depression. Despite her criminal past, Larkham entered a plea of guilty, accepted responsibility for her actions, and expressed remorse. She has since engaged in a drug rehabilitation program and has ambitions to study further.

Following her arrest, Larkham served 121 days in custody and was granted bail to attend a drug rehabilitation program in Queensland. The court recognised the tension between the need for punishment and deterrence versus the need for rehabilitation, particularly given Larkham's mental health condition and her limited prior criminal history. The sentence imposed was an aggregate of two years, two months, and 16 days’ imprisonment, to be served by way of intensive correction orders, with partial concurrency and backdating to account for the time already served. The orders also included conditions for medical treatment, drug testing, program attendance, and prohibition of illicit drug use.

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Larkham came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory on 30 March 2023 for sentencing following the offender's plea of guilty to multiple charges including aggravated robbery, dishonestly riding in a stolen motor vehicle, possessing an offensive weapon with intent, and dishonestly appropriating property. The offender, Grace Emily Larkham, had previously been convicted in the Magistrates Court, where she entered a plea of guilty on the eighth mention. The case was then transferred to the Supreme Court for sentencing, where the offender's plea resulted in a 25% reduction of the sentence that would otherwise have been imposed. The offender had already served 121 days in custody prior to sentencing and was granted bail to participate in an intensive residential drug rehabilitation program. The Supreme Court considered the significant impacts of the offences, particularly the robbery of a chemist which had enduring impacts on the staff and the business, and the offender's history of drug use and mental health issues. The court balanced the need for denunciation and deterrence with the prospect of the offender's rehabilitation, ultimately imposing a sentence of imprisonment to be served by way of intensive correction orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate sentence for the aggravated robbery offence considering the offender's plea of guilty and the objective seriousness of the crime?
2. How should the court approach the sentencing of the charge of riding in a stolen vehicle, considering the offender's participation and the objective seriousness of the offence?
3. What is the appropriate sentence for the charge of possessing an offensive weapon with intent, taking into account the objective seriousness of the offence?
4. How should the court approach the sentencing of the minor theft charge, considering the objective seriousness and the circumstances of the offence?
5. How should the court consider the offender's subjective circumstances, including her criminal history, mental health, and rehabilitation efforts, in determining an appropriate sentence?
6. What weight should be given to the offender's plea of guilty and demonstrated remorse in the sentencing process?
7. How should the court balance the need for denunciation, punishment, and deterrence with the need for rehabilitation when imposing a sentence?
8. Is there a need to consider the impact of the offender's schizophrenia and substance use disorder on her culpability and the appropriate sentence?
9. Should the court take into account the offender's time spent in custody and her participation in a rehabilitation program when determining an appropriate sentence?
10. What role should current sentencing practices and principles play in determining an appropriate sentence for the offences committed?

Held
1. The court concluded that the appropriate sentence for the aggravated robbery offence, considering the offender's plea of guilty and the objective seriousness of the crime, is 22 months and 15 days imprisonment, reduced from 30 months due to the plea of guilty.
2. The court concluded that for the charge of riding in a stolen vehicle, considering the offender's participation and the objective seriousness of the offence, the appropriate sentence is 9 months imprisonment, reduced from 12 months due to the plea of guilty.
3. The court concluded that the appropriate sentence for the charge of possessing an offensive weapon with intent, taking into account the objective seriousness of the offence, is 3 months imprisonment, reduced from 4 months due to the plea of guilty.
4. The court concluded that for the minor theft charge, considering the objective seriousness and the circumstances of the offence, the appropriate sentence is 2 months and 7 days imprisonment, reduced from 3 months due to the plea of guilty.
5. The court considered the offender's subjective circumstances, including her criminal history, mental health, and rehabilitation efforts, in determining an appropriate sentence, taking into account her chronic schizophrenia and substance use disorder, which contributed to her offending.
6. The court gave weight to the offender's plea of guilty and demonstrated remorse in the sentencing process, accepting her remorse as genuine and not merely self-pity or regret for being caught.
7. The court balanced the need for denunciation, punishment, and deterrence with the need for rehabilitation when imposing a sentence, imposing an aggregate sentence of two years, two months, and 16 days imprisonment, to be served by way of intensive correction orders with additional conditions.
8. The court considered the impact of the offender's schizophrenia and substance use disorder on her culpability and the appropriate sentence, concluding that her mental health condition reduced her culpability but did not excuse her offending.
9. The court took into account the offender's time spent in custody and her participation in a rehabilitation program when determining an appropriate sentence, acknowledging the benefits of her incarceration and rehabilitation efforts in breaking her long history of illicit substance use.
10. The court considered current sentencing practices and principles in determining an appropriate sentence for the offences committed, referring to relevant cases and imposing a sentence that gives sufficient recognition to the purposes of sentencing such as general and specific deterrence, denunciation, and recognition of harm done to the victims of the offending.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appropriate sentence for the aggravated robbery offence by weighing the objective seriousness of the crime against the offender's plea of guilty and her subjective circumstances. The aggravated robbery, committed in company and with the use of a weapon, placed multiple people in fear of serious harm, which placed the offence at the upper end of the mid-range of objective seriousness. The offender's plea of guilty warranted a 25% reduction in the sentence that would otherwise be imposed. The court also considered the offender's subjective circumstances, including her mental health and substance use, which contributed to her reduced culpability. The resulting sentence was 22 months and 15 days of imprisonment, reduced from 30 months due to the plea of guilty, to be served by way of an intensive corrections order.

For the charge of riding in a stolen vehicle, the court noted the offender's equal participation in the dishonest exercise, placing the offence in the mid-range of objective seriousness. The offender's plea of guilty resulted in a 25% reduction, leading to a sentence of nine months' imprisonment, reduced from 12 months, to be served by way of an intensive corrections order.

In determining the sentence for possessing an offensive weapon with intent, the court placed the offence in the mid-range of objective seriousness. The plea of guilty resulted in a 25% reduction, leading to a sentence of three months' imprisonment, reduced from four months, to be served by way of an intensive corrections order.

For the minor theft charge, the court placed the offence above the mid-range of objective seriousness due to its brazen nature and the commercial premises targeted. The plea of guilty resulted in a 25% reduction, leading to a sentence of two months and seven days' imprisonment, reduced from three months, to be served by way of an intensive corrections order.

In considering the offender's subjective circumstances, the court took into account her criminal history, mental health, and rehabilitation efforts. The offender's schizophrenia and substance use disorder reduced her culpability, and her participation in a rehabilitation program showed a commitment to change. The court also considered her demonstrated remorse and willingness to participate in Restorative Justice.

The court gave weight to the offender's plea of guilty and demonstrated remorse, resulting in a 25% reduction in the sentences for each charge. The court balanced the need for denunciation, punishment, and deterrence with the need for rehabilitation, ultimately imposing sentences to be served by way of intensive corrections orders, which allowed for the offender's rehabilitation while addressing the seriousness of the offences.

The court considered the impact of the offender's schizophrenia and substance use disorder on her culpability and the appropriate sentence. It concluded that her mental health condition and substance use contributed to her offending, reducing her culpability. However, the court also recognised the need for appropriate treatment and rehabilitation to address these issues.

The court took into account the offender's time spent in custody and her participation in a rehabilitation program when determining an appropriate sentence. The court acknowledged the benefits of the offender's time in custody and rehabilitation, which provided her with the opportunity to break her long history of illicit substance use and obtain appropriate treatment for her chronic schizophrenia.

Finally, the court considered current sentencing practices and principles in determining an appropriate sentence for the offences committed. It referred to relevant cases involving aggravated robberies to ensure the sentence reflected the purposes of sentencing, such as general and specific deterrence, denunciation, and recognition of harm done to the victims of the offending. The court imposed an aggregate sentence of two years, two months, and 16 days' imprisonment, to be served by way of intensive corrections orders, with a large degree of concurrency between the sentences on the first three charges.