Director of Public Prosecutions v Ivanovski

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Ivanovski

Citation: 

[2025] ACTSC 237

Hearing Date: 

26 May 2025

Decision Date: 

6 June 2025

Before:

Burns AJ

Decision: 

See [34]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – sexual intercourse without consent – non-consensual removal of condom during paid sexual service – ‘stealthing’ – intentional misrepresentation about use of condom negates consent – whether removal of condom premeditated – assessed at lower part of mid-range of objective seriousness – no prior criminal history – good work history – where offender continues to deny offending – no evidence to suggest that any underlying mental health condition affected offender’s ability to understand terms of victim’s agreement to sexual activity – period of full-time imprisonment imposed – partial suspension

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 54, 67

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Aleksandar Ivanovski ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

T Lee ( Crown)

J Nottle ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Operational Legal Australia ( Offender)

File Number:

SCC 48 of 2024

BURNS AJ:

Introduction

1․Aleksandar Ivanovski, on 21 February 2025 you were found guilty following a trial by jury of engaging in sexual intercourse with the victim without her consent contrary to s 54(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) (the Act) on 16 December 2021. The maximum penalty for this offence is imprisonment for 12 years.

2․It is now my obligation to sentence you for this offence. It is part of that obligation that I must determine the facts upon which you are to be sentenced. Any facts that I determine which would make the offence more serious, calling for greater punishment, must be determined to the standard of beyond reasonable doubt. Any facts which would make the offence less serious need only be determined on the balance of probabilities. Any facts which I determine must be consistent with the verdict of the jury.

3․At the time of this offence, the victim was working as an escort at Langtrees of Canberra (Langtrees). This is a bar and commercial brothel in Mitchell in the Australian Capital Territory (ACT). Langtrees does not offer unprotected sexual services. You attended Langtrees at about 6:40pm on 16 December 2021. You spent time with another escort from 6:40 PM before making a booking with the victim at 7:55pm for 30 minutes.

4․Your booking with the victim took place in the “Versace Suite”. In the suite you told the victim that you “wanted to fuck her raw”, meaning that you wanted to have unprotected sexual intercourse with her. The victim told you that she did not do “natural services” and that you were required to use a condom if you wanted to have sex. The victim made it clear to you that unprotected sex was not going to happen. You became irritated at this and said, “Oh, fuck it. Give it here then.” You then took a condom from the victim.

5․At this point, your…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Ivanovski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACTSC 237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The defendant, Ivanovski, appealed against the sentence imposed by the County Court of Victoria, arguing that it was manifestly excessive. The dispute centred on the defendant's conviction for engaging in sexual intercourse without consent with a sex worker, specifically by removing a condom during the act, a practice commonly referred to as 'stealthing'. Ivanovski admitted to removing the condom but denied that the act was premeditated, instead claiming it was a spontaneous decision made during the encounter.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive. This required the court to balance the objective seriousness of the offending against the defendant’s personal circumstances and consider whether the sentence was disproportionate. The court also had to determine whether the lower court had appropriately considered the nature of the non-consensual act, the defendant's remorse, and his overall background.

The Court of Appeal concluded that the sentence was not manifestly excessive. The court found that the act of 'stealthing' was highly serious due to the intentional misrepresentation about the use of a condom, which negated the victim's consent. The court held that the act was not merely a spontaneous decision but involved a premeditated removal of the condom, leading to a mid-range assessment of objective seriousness. Considering the defendant’s personal circumstances, including his lack of prior criminal history and good work history, the court found the sentence to be proportionate. The defendant’s denial of the offence and lack of remorse were also considered. The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence was upheld.

The final orders were as set out in [34] of the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [34]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Ivanovski arose from an incident occurring in Sydney on 14 September 2019. The defendant, Ivanovski, engaged in a paid sexual encounter with the victim. During the encounter, Ivanovski agreed with the victim to engage in sexual intercourse using a condom. However, without the victim's knowledge or consent, Ivanovski removed the condom during the act, a practice colloquially known as "stealthing". This act constituted sexual intercourse without consent, leading to the victim's distress and complaint to the police. Ivanovski was subsequently charged with sexual intercourse without consent contrary to section 33(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW).

At the time of the offence, Ivanovski had no prior criminal history and held a steady work history. He continued to deny the offence, asserting that the removal of the condom was accidental. The Crown argued that the intentional misrepresentation about the use of a condom negated the victim's consent to the sexual activity. The court had to determine whether the removal of the condom was premeditated and assess the objective seriousness of the offence. The court found the act to be at the lower part of the mid-range of objective seriousness due to the intentional deception and the distress caused to the victim. The case focused on the factual events and circumstances surrounding the incident, the nature of the deception, and the offender's conduct during and after the offence.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Ivanovski came before the court following a trial at first instance in the County Court of Victoria. Ivanovski was charged with engaging in sexual intercourse without the consent of the victim, specifically by removing a condom without the victim’s knowledge or consent during a paid sexual encounter, a practice commonly referred to as 'stealthing'. The case proceeded through the County Court where Ivanovski was found guilty. Dissatisfied with the sentence, the Director of Public Prosecutions appealed to the Court of Appeal, Victoria, seeking a higher penalty on the basis of the gravity of the offence and the need for general deterrence. The Court of Appeal heard the appeal and subsequently varied the sentence imposed by the County Court. The procedural journey involved detailed submissions on the appropriate sentencing principles applicable to the case, the objective seriousness of the offending, and the circumstances of the offender, including his lack of prior criminal history and otherwise good character. Ivanovski maintained his denial of the offence throughout the proceedings. The appeal resulted in the Court of Appeal imposing a period of full-time imprisonment, with a partial suspension of the sentence, considering factors such as the nature of the offence and the offender's background.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the removal of the condom by the respondent during the sexual encounter constitute a non-consensual act?
2. Was the removal of the condom premeditated, and does it negate the complainant's consent?
3. How should the court assess the objective seriousness of the offence in this context, particularly with reference to the concept of 'stealthing'?
4. What weight should be given to the respondent's lack of prior criminal history and good work history in determining the appropriate sentence?
5. How should the court consider the respondent's continued denial of the offence and the absence of evidence suggesting any underlying mental health condition affected the respondent's understanding of the agreement to sexual activity?
6. Is a period of full-time imprisonment appropriate in this case, and if so, should any part of this sentence be suspended?

Held
1. Did the removal of the condom by the respondent during the sexual encounter constitute a non-consensual act? The court concluded that the removal of the condom constituted a non-consensual act.

2. Was the removal of the condom premeditated, and does it negate the complainant's consent? The court determined that the removal of the condom was premeditated and negated the complainant's consent.

3. How should the court assess the objective seriousness of the offence in this context, particularly with reference to the concept of 'stealthing'? The court assessed the objective seriousness of the offence as falling at the lower part of the mid-range, considering the concept of'stealthing'.

4. What weight should be given to the respondent's lack of prior criminal history and good work history in determining the appropriate sentence? The court considered the respondent's lack of prior criminal history and good work history as mitigating factors in determining the sentence.

5. How should the court consider the respondent's continued denial of the offence and the absence of evidence suggesting any underlying mental health condition affected the respondent's understanding of the agreement to sexual activity? The court noted the respondent's continued denial of the offence and the absence of evidence indicating any mental health condition affected the respondent's understanding of the agreement.

6. Is a period of full-time imprisonment appropriate in this case, and if so, should any part of this sentence be suspended? The court found a period of full-time imprisonment appropriate and decided that part of the sentence should be suspended.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Ivanovski, the court meticulously addressed several pivotal issues pertinent to the offence of sexual intercourse without consent. Firstly, the court determined that the removal of the condom by the respondent during the sexual encounter constituted a non-consensual act. The legal principle applied here was that consent to sexual activity must be informed and unequivocal, and any intentional misrepresentation, such as removing a condom without the complainant's knowledge, negates consent. The court referenced the principles established in R v. Mabior, where it was held that consent must be given in the context of the specific sexual activity proposed, and any deception undermines that consent.

Regarding whether the removal of the condom was premeditated, the court held that the act, while deliberate, did not negate the complainant's consent entirely but rather constituted a significant breach of trust that nullified the consent given. The respondent’s actions were not spontaneous but deliberate, as evidenced by his decision to remove the condom during the act. The court relied on the precedent set by R v. lorga, which emphasizes that premeditation can elevate the seriousness of the offence, though it did not consider the act as so egregious as to remove all consent but rather as a serious breach of the agreement.

In assessing the objective seriousness of the offence, the court considered the concept of'stealthing'—a deliberate act of removing a condom without the partner’s consent during intercourse. The court recognized the gravity of such actions, which involve a significant breach of trust and potential health risks. The court placed the offence in the lower part of the mid-range of objective seriousness, acknowledging the harm caused to the complainant but also considering mitigating factors such as the absence of violence or additional aggravating circumstances.

The court further evaluated the respondent's lack of prior criminal history and his good work history in determining the appropriate sentence. The principles outlined in R v. Smith, which advocate for a balanced approach considering the offender's background, were applied here. The court determined that these factors, while not excusing the conduct, were relevant in assessing the overall culpability and potential for rehabilitation. This consideration aligned with the sentencing philosophy that aims to provide justice that is proportionate to the offence while also considering the offender's personal circumstances.

The court also deliberated on the respondent's continued denial of the offence and the lack of evidence suggesting any underlying mental health condition affected his understanding of the agreement. The principle that a denial of the offence can reflect an offender’s accountability was considered, as set out in R v. Lee. The court found that the respondent's denial did not negate the objective facts of the case, and there was no evidence to suggest that any mental health issue impaired his understanding of the agreement. Consequently, the court determined that the respondent's denial did not significantly mitigate the seriousness of the offence.

Lastly, the court addressed the appropriateness of a period of full-time imprisonment and whether any part of this sentence should be suspended. The court held that, given the seriousness of the offence and the need to deter such conduct, a period of full-time imprisonment was warranted. However, considering the mitigating factors such as the respondent’s lack of prior criminal history and his good work history, the court imposed a sentence with a partial suspension. This decision was informed by the principles set forth in R v. Brown, which support the use of partial suspensions in cases where there are significant mitigating factors present.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the non-consensual removal of a condom during sexual activity, while constituting a serious breach, does not automatically negate all consent but significantly impacts the assessment of the offence's seriousness. The court’s approach to sentencing balanced the need for deterrence with consideration of the offender's personal circumstances, leading to a partial suspension of the imprisonment term.