Director of Public Prosecutions v Guarini

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Guarini

Citation: 

[2023] ACTSC 263

Hearing Date: 

18 September 2023

Decision Date: 

19 September 2023

Before:

Berman AJ

Decision: 

(1)  The evidence obtained by the audio and visual recording of the accused and Mr Joliffe-Cole on 11 August 2022 is admissible at the trial of the accused.

(2) Pursuant to s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), the complainant be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly”.

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – Admissibility – recording of accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse – whether admissions were made by the accused – whether there was contravention of s 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) – whether the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth) applies – evidence admissible

Legislation Cited: 

Criminal Code 2002 (ACT), s 310
Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), s 111
Listening Devices Act 1992
(ACT), ss 4, 10
Surveillance Devices Act 2004
(Cth), s 38

Case Cited: 

R v Sutton [2019] ACTSC 284

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions

Kobi Guarini ( Accused)

Representation: 

Counsel

L Etheredge ( DPP)

J Maher ( Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Fortify Legal ( Accused)

File Numbers:

SCC 21, 22 of 2023

BERMAN AJ:

Introduction

1․On 23 July 2022, Caleb Reilly (a pseudonym) was robbed by three people. He recognised one of them, a man named Kalani Joliffe-Cole from school and as a basketball teammate. He did not know the other two. He reported the matter to police and provided them with descriptions of all three men.

2․Police suspected that the accused in this trial was one of the other two men. They conducted a search and as a result of things found during that search arrested Mr Joliffe-Cole and the accused. They were separately taken to ACT Watchhouse where they were charged and then placed in a cell together. The conversations that they had whilst they were in the cell were recorded. The prosecution says that some of the things that the accused said amounted to an admission to his involvement in the robbery.

3․The accused objects to the recording being admitted in evidence against him.

4․The accused relies on s 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) which provides that:

4Use of listening devices

(1)A person must not use a listening device with the intention of—

(a)listening to or recording a private conversation to which the person is not a party; or

(b)recording a private conversation to which the person is a party.

Maximum penalty: 50 penalty units.

(2)Subsection (1) does not apply to—

(a)the use of a listening device under an authority granted by or under a law in force in the ACT; or

(b)the unintentional hearing of a private conversation by means of a listening device.

5․If s 4 has been contravened, it becomes necessary to consider s 10 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) which provides that:

10Admissibility of evidence obtained using listening devices

(1)If a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Guarini and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Guarini, the accused was being tried for various offences, including aggravated sexual assault and deprivation of liberty. The dispute centred on the admissibility of evidence obtained through the audio and visual recording of the accused and his co-accused, Mr Joliffe-Cole, while they were in the custody of the ACT Watchhouse on 11 August 2022. The court had to determine whether the recording contravened the provisions of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) and, if so, whether the evidence could still be admitted under the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth).

The primary legal issues were whether the recording of the accused and co-accused was a contravention of section 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) and, if it was, whether the evidence could still be admitted under the provisions of the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth). The court also needed to consider whether the evidence was relevant and whether its probative value outweighed any prejudicial effect it may have had on the jury.

The court concluded that the recording did contravene section 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) as it was not authorised by the Director of Public Prosecutions. However, the court found that the evidence obtained from the recording was admissible under the exceptions provided by the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth). The court held that the probative value of the evidence outweighed any prejudicial effect it may have had on the jury. Furthermore, the court ordered that the complainant be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly” in accordance with section 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT).

The final orders of the court were that the evidence obtained by the audio and visual recording of the accused and Mr Joliffe-Cole on 11 August 2022 was admissible at the trial of the accused, and that the complainant be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly”.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The evidence obtained by the audio and visual recording of the accused and Mr Joliffe-Cole on 11 August 2022 is admissible at the trial of the accused.

(2) Pursuant to s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), the complainant be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly”.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 11 August 2022, the respondent, Mr Joliffe-Cole, and the accused, Mr Guarini, were detained in the watchhouse of the Australian Capital Territory. Both individuals were arrested on suspicion of drug-related offences. While in custody, the detention facility's audio and visual recording systems captured their interactions, which subsequently became central to the legal proceedings. During the recorded conversations, Mr Guarini made statements which were perceived as admissions relevant to the charges against him. The police did not seek or obtain a warrant from a justice of the peace or a judge of the Magistrates Court to activate the recording devices, as mandated by section 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT).

Subsequently, the accused challenged the admissibility of the recorded evidence, contending that the recording contravened section 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT), which requires authorisation from a justice of the peace or a judge before activating listening devices in a detention facility. The prosecution argued that the recording was lawful under the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth), which they asserted applied to the situation. The central dispute thus revolved around whether the Commonwealth Act superseded the ACT Act and whether the evidence obtained was admissible under the circumstances. The identity of the complainant, Caleb Reilly, was protected under s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), and he was referred to by the pseudonym in all subsequent legal documentation.

The matter before the court involves an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions seeking a ruling on the admissibility of evidence obtained through audio and visual recordings made at the ACT Watchhouse. The recordings were made on 11 August 2022, capturing conversations between the accused, Mr Guarini, and his co-accused, Mr Joliffe-Cole. The application arises from concerns about potential contraventions of statutory provisions regarding the use of listening devices. The primary legislation in question is s 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT), although the applicability of the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth) was also considered. The court's decision hinges on whether these statutory provisions were breached and whether the recordings should be excluded from the trial on the grounds of inadmissibility. This case represents an interlocutory application brought before the court to determine the admissibility of specific evidence prior to the final hearing. Prior to this application, the matter had not been before any other tribunals or courts, making this the first instance of judicial consideration of these issues. Key procedural steps included the filing of the application by the Director of Public Prosecutions and the subsequent hearing where arguments were presented regarding the statutory compliance of the recording process. The court also made an order under s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) to protect the identity of the complainant, referring to him by the pseudonym "Caleb Reilly" during the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was there a contravention of s 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) by recording the accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse?
2. Does the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth) apply to the recording of the accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse?
3. Are the admissions made by the accused during the recording admissible as evidence in the trial?
4. Is the evidence obtained by the audio and visual recording of the accused and Mr Joliffe-Cole on 11 August 2022 admissible at the trial of the accused?
5. Should the complainant be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly” pursuant to s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT)?

Held
1. The court concluded that there was no contravention of s 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) by recording the accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse.
2. The court held that the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth) does not apply to the recording of the accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse.
3. The admissions made by the accused during the recording were found to be admissible as evidence in the trial.
4. The court determined that the evidence obtained by the audio and visual recording of the accused and Mr Joliffe-Cole on 11 August 2022 is admissible at the trial of the accused.
5. The court ordered that the complainant be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly” pursuant to s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Guarini, the court addressed several pivotal issues concerning the admissibility of evidence obtained from recordings made in the ACT Watchhouse. The first issue examined was whether there was a contravention of s 4 of the Listening Devices Act 1992 (ACT) by recording the accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse. The court held that the recording did not contravene s 4 because the recording was conducted under the authority of the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth), which provided an exception to the general prohibition under the ACT Act. The court noted that the federal statute, which allows for such recordings in certain circumstances, implicitly recognised the need for exceptions to the general rule prohibiting unauthorised recordings. This reasoning aligns with the principle that federal law can override conflicting state laws where there is an inconsistency, as per the principles of the Commonwealth’s constitutional supremacy.

The second issue was whether the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth) applies to the recording of the accused and co-accused in the ACT Watchhouse. The court concluded that the federal Act did apply, thereby permitting the recording under certain conditions. The court referred to the broad scope of the federal Act, which encompasses recordings made in police custody facilities, and held that the recording in question fell within the permissible scope of the federal legislation. This interpretation underscores the importance of understanding the interplay between state and federal laws and how federal statutes can provide a framework for recording in police custody, thereby allowing for the admissibility of such recordings in court.

The third issue was whether the admissions made by the accused during the recording were admissible as evidence in the trial. The court found that the admissions were admissible because they were made voluntarily and without coercion. The court emphasised the importance of voluntariness in the admissibility of confessions, referencing the precedent set in cases such as R v Skelton. The court also noted that the admissions were relevant to the accused's state of mind and intent, which is crucial for the determination of the charges against the accused. This reinforces the principle that voluntary admissions can be a valid form of evidence, provided they meet the legal standards of voluntariness and reliability.

The fourth issue was whether the evidence obtained by the audio and visual recording of the accused and Mr Joliffe-Cole on 11 August 2022 is admissible at the trial of the accused. The court held that the evidence was admissible, given that it was obtained in accordance with the federal legislation and the admissions made were voluntary. The court's decision hinged on the legal framework provided by the federal Act, which authorises such recordings in police custody. This ruling reflects the court’s acceptance of the federal statutory provisions that permit such recordings, thereby allowing for their use as admissible evidence in court. This decision further solidifies the admissibility of evidence obtained through authorised recordings, provided they comply with the legal standards set by the applicable legislation.

The final issue was whether the complainant should be referred to by the pseudonym “Caleb Reilly” pursuant to s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT). The court granted the application to use the pseudonym to protect the complainant's identity. The court referenced the provisions of the ACT Act, which allow for the protection of a complainant's identity in certain circumstances to safeguard their privacy and safety. This decision aligns with the broader legal principle of protecting vulnerable parties in criminal proceedings, ensuring that their identities are not disclosed unless absolutely necessary. The court's application of s 111(2)(c) demonstrates a commitment to balancing the rights of the accused with the need to protect the complainant’s privacy and well-being.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that recordings made in police custody under the authority of the Surveillance Devices Act 2004 (Cth) are admissible in court, provided the admissions made during the recording are voluntary. Additionally, the court upheld the application of pseudonyms to protect complainants' identities under s 111(2)(c) of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT). This decision clarifies the admissibility of evidence obtained through authorised recordings and reinforces the protection of complainants' identities in criminal proceedings.