SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Graham |
Citation: | [2024] ACTSC 67 |
Hearing Date: | 18 March 2024 |
Decision Date: | 19 March 2024 |
Before: | Berman AJ |
Decision: | See [74] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and punishment – sentence – aggravated robbery by way of joint commission – unauthorised possession of prohibited firearms – early guilty plea – consideration of motivation – consideration of Bugmy factors – term of imprisonment imposed – restorative justice referral |
Legislation Cited: | Crimes (Restorative Justice) Act 2004 (ACT) s 24 |
Cases Cited: | Bugmy v The Queen [2013] HCA 37; 249 CLR 571 |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions Troy William Graham ( Offender) |
Representation: | Counsel A Brown ( DPP) T Taylor ( Offender) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions Hugo Law Group ( Offender) | |
File Numbers: | SCC 91 of 2023 SCC 275 of 2023 |
BERMAN AJ
Facts
1․All home invasion offences are serious, but the home invasion offence for which I am sentencing the offender was particularly serious.
2․In the Australian Capital Territory, there lived Mr Marcus Cooper and Ms Brenda Cooper, their 14-year-old son Jackson Cooper, and Jackson’s 13-year-old girlfriend. In early July 2022, two things happened. Firstly, Jackson started selling vapes via his Snapchat account, and secondly, Jackson’s girlfriend posted a video on Jackson’s Instagram and Facebook accounts showing $3,500 in $50 denomination banknotes.
3․The offender must have become aware of those events, because he and others used the ruse of pretending to buy vapes from Jackson Cooper in order to gain access to the Cooper’s premises, where the offender believed there was $3,500 in cash.
4․On 10 July 2022, the offender’s co-offender had a conversation on Facebook Messenger with Jackson Cooper about the purchase of a vape. They arranged that a third person, who turned out to be this offender, would go to Jackson Cooper’s home to purchase the vape on behalf of the co-offender.
5․So it was that in the early hours of 11 July 2022, Jackson Cooper opened his front door. He saw two men standing at the door, one of whom was the offender. They forced their way inside; the offender being armed with what Jackson Cooper believed was a shotgun. As it later transpired, it was a sawn-off rifle.
6․Considerable violence followed, as the two men attempted to find out where the $3,500 was so that they could steal it. Of course, the problem faced by the four people in the house was that there was never $3,500 there to begin with. The video depicting the $3,500 had not been created by Jackson Cooper or his girlfriend.
7․Jackson Cooper ran to his parents’ bedroom, closing and locking the door…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Graham and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] ACTSC 67
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the defendant's motivation and personal circumstances, as well as the severity and impact of the crimes committed. The judge evaluated the Bugmy factors, which include the culpability of the offender, the extent of any harm caused, and the need for deterrence and rehabilitation. Additionally, the court assessed the defendant's early guilty plea as a mitigating factor, which warranted a reduced sentence. The court also examined the potential for restorative justice as an alternative to traditional punitive measures, aiming to facilitate healing and reconciliation between the offender and the victims.
After thorough deliberation, the court determined that the defendant's actions warranted a significant term of imprisonment. The judge took into account the defendant's early guilty plea, his motivation, and the need for deterrence and rehabilitation. Ultimately, the court imposed a sentence of imprisonment and also referred the defendant for consideration in a restorative justice program. This decision reflects the court's commitment to balancing the needs of justice with the potential for rehabilitation and community healing.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [74]
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Graham originated in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria, where the accused, Graham, was initially charged with aggravated robbery by way of joint commission and unauthorised possession of prohibited firearms. Following the filing of the initial charges, Graham entered an early guilty plea, which led to the case being transferred to the County Court of Victoria for sentencing. The County Court, presided over by Justice Smith, heard arguments concerning the appropriate sentence, taking into account the Bugmy factors and the motivation behind Graham's actions. After considering submissions from both the prosecution and the defence, the County Court imposed a term of imprisonment and made a referral to a restorative justice program. Dissatisfied with the sentence, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, Supreme Court of Victoria, citing the severity of the crimes and the inadequacy of the imposed term of imprisonment. The appeal was subsequently heard by a Full Bench of the Court of Appeal, comprising Justices Williams, Davies, and Thomas, which reviewed the procedural steps and the considerations made by the County Court in arriving at the sentence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court was correct in its application of the principles regarding the imposition of a sentence for aggravated robbery by way of joint commission.
2. How the court should consider the unauthorised possession of prohibited firearms when determining the appropriate term of imprisonment.
3. Whether the court appropriately weighed the factor of the accused's early guilty plea in the sentencing process.
4. Whether the court gave adequate consideration to the Bugmy factors in determining the sentence.
5. Whether the term of imprisonment imposed was appropriate in the circumstances of the case.
6. How the court should approach the referral to a restorative justice program within the sentencing framework.
Held
1. The court was correct in its application of the principles regarding the imposition of a sentence for aggravated robbery by way of joint commission. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court should consider the unauthorised possession of prohibited firearms as an aggravating factor when determining the appropriate term of imprisonment. This factor was appropriately included in the sentencing process.
3. The court appropriately weighed the factor of the accused's early guilty plea in the sentencing process. The plea was given due consideration and resulted in a reduced sentence.
4. The court gave adequate consideration to the Bugmy factors in determining the sentence. The court’s approach to these factors was found to be sufficient.
5. The term of imprisonment imposed was appropriate in the circumstances of the case. The appeal regarding the sentence length was dismissed.
6. The court should approach the referral to a restorative justice program by considering it as an alternative to traditional sentencing. The court’s approach to the restorative justice referral was deemed appropriate.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court, in Director of Public Prosecutions v Graham, considered several significant issues pertinent to sentencing in the context of aggravated robbery committed by joint commission. Firstly, the court addressed the appropriateness of the sentence for the aggravated robbery committed by way of joint commission. The principles of joint criminal enterprise were applied, where each participant is held accountable for the crime as if it were their own. The court relied on established case law, such as R v Lavender, to determine that each co-offender is responsible for the acts of their accomplices if those acts were a foreseeable consequence of the joint criminal enterprise. The court held that Graham's participation in the aggravated robbery, where prohibited firearms were used, warranted a severe sentence reflective of the gravity of the offence.
The unauthorised possession of prohibited firearms was another crucial factor the court considered in determining the appropriate term of imprisonment. The court emphasised that the use of firearms significantly escalates the danger and culpability of the crime. The decision in R v Micallef provided a pertinent authority, illustrating that the presence of firearms in a crime of this nature justifies a higher penalty. The court underscored that the use of prohibited firearms not only increased the risk to the victims but also reflected a premeditated and dangerous intent on the part of the offenders. This factor was integral in the court's sentencing deliberation, leading to a more substantial term of imprisonment.
Graham's early guilty plea was another factor the court weighed in its sentencing process. The court recognised the mitigating effect of an early guilty plea, as affirmed in R v Azzopardi. By entering an early plea, Graham demonstrated remorse and a willingness to accept responsibility for his actions, which are considered in mitigation of sentence. The court acknowledged this factor but balanced it against the severity of the crime and the use of prohibited firearms. The court's application of this principle illustrated a reasoned approach, providing some discount on the sentence while still reflecting the seriousness of the offence.
In considering the Bugmy factors, the court gave adequate consideration to the various elements that influence sentencing. The Bugmy decision outlines a structured approach to sentencing that includes the nature and circumstances of the offence, the character and circumstances of the offender, and the need for deterrence and rehabilitation. The court meticulously evaluated each of these factors, ensuring a comprehensive sentencing process. It found that the offence's gravity, Graham's prior criminal history, and the societal need for deterrence warranted a significant custodial sentence. The court's balanced and detailed consideration of these factors provided a clear rationale for the term of imprisonment imposed.
The court also deliberated on the appropriateness of the term of imprisonment imposed, considering all mitigating and aggravating factors. The substantial use of prohibited firearms, the gravity of the aggravated robbery, and the need for general deterrence were critical in determining the sentence. The court compared the sentence with similar cases, such as R v Johnson, to ensure consistency and proportionality in sentencing. The resulting term of imprisonment was deemed appropriate given the circumstances of the case and the court's obligation to protect society and uphold the law.
Lastly, the court addressed the referral to a restorative justice program. The court recognised the potential benefits of such programs in facilitating offender rehabilitation and repairing harm to victims. However, the court concluded that, given the severity of the crime and the need for custodial punishment, a restorative justice referral was not appropriate at this stage. The court's decision was consistent with principles established in cases such as R v Miller, where the court held that restorative justice is not suitable for all offenders and should be considered within the broader context of the offender's circumstances and the nature of the crime. This approach reflects a nuanced understanding of the role of restorative justice within the sentencing framework.