Director of Public Prosecutions v Girvan

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Girvan

Citation:

[2023] ACTSC 35

Hearing Date:

6 March 2023

DecisionDate:

6 March 2023

Before:

Mossop J

Decision:

See [40]

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Sentence – various offences of carjacking and aggravated robbery – offences took place in the early hours of the morning – offending involved use of a machete and axe to threaten victims – offending occurred to support drug habit –prospects of rehabilitation are mixed – custodial sentence imposed

Legislation Cited

Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) ss 310, 311, 318, 326

Road Transport (Road Rules) Regulation 2017 (ACT)

Parties:

Director of Public Prosecutions

Corey Girvan ( Offender)

Representation:

Counsel

C Wanigaratne ( DPP)

J Sabharwarl ( Offender)

Solicitors

Director of Public Prosecutions

Fraser Criminal Law ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 206 of 2022

SCC 207 of 2022

SCC 208 of 2022

MOSSOP J:

Introduction

  1. The offender, Corey Girvan, has pleaded guilty to a string of offences committed in the early hours of 21 May 2022. In these reasons the names of the victims are anonymised as their names are not necessary for the understanding of the sentence imposed.

  1. The charges are summarised in the following table.

Count Charge Particulars Max penalty
Count 1 Joint Commission Burglary (SCCAN2022/180); s 311 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) Between 1:36am – 2:00am, trespassing on property of KG through open door. Theft of keys to white Ford Ranger. 14 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $224,000 or both.
Count 2 Joint Commission Take Motor Vehicle (CC2022/5627); s 318 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT)

Between 1:36am – 2:00am, theft of white Ford Ranger belonging to KG.

5 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $80,000 or both.
Count 3 Obtain Property By Deception (CC2022/5628); s 326 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT)

At 3:05am, purchase of two packets of cigarettes using KG’s St George Vertigo Mastercard.

10 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $160,000 or both.
Count 4 Joint Commission
Attempted Aggravated Robbery (CC2022/7115); s 310 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT)

Between 3:30am – 4:00am, attempted carjacking of white taxi belonging to IT. Threatened IT with 30-45 cm knife.

25 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $400,000 or both.
Count 5 Joint Commission
Attempted Aggravated Robbery (CC2022/5629); s 310 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT)
Between 3:45am – 4:20am, attempted carjacking of vehicle belonging to EN. Engaged in car chase with EN. 25 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $400,000 or both.
Count 6 Aggravated Robbery (CC2022/5630); s 310 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) Between 4:30am – 4:45am, carjacking of white taxi, driven by BN and belonging to NT. Attacked the victim’s car with an axe. 25 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $400,000 or both.
Count 7 Joint Commission Aggravated Robbery (CC2022/5631); s 310 Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) Between 4:40am – 4:53am, assault and theft of mobile belonging to UC. 25 years’ imprisonment, a fine of $400,000 or both.
  1. The offender also pleaded guilty to a transfer offence of driving without a seatbelt contravention of the Road Transport (Road Rules) Regulation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Girvan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Corey Girvan pleaded guilty to multiple counts of carjacking and aggravated robbery, as well as a charge of obtaining property by deception and driving without a seatbelt. The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory heard the case and was required to decide on the appropriate sentence for Girvan, considering the severity of the crimes, the circumstances surrounding the offences, and Girvan's potential for rehabilitation. The court found that the offending was driven by Girvan's drug use, and although his youth and lack of prior convictions warranted some leniency, the gravity of the crimes necessitated significant sentences of imprisonment. The court imposed a total sentence of five years and three months, with a non-parole period of 33 months, acknowledging Girvan's potential for rehabilitation and his young age.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the objective seriousness of the offences, which involved random attacks on victims, the use of weapons, and a high degree of violence. The subjective circumstances of Girvan's background, drug use, and potential for rehabilitation were also taken into account. The court recognised that Girvan had a modest criminal history and had shown some willingness to change his ways, but also noted that his attitude towards rehabilitation had been inconsistent. The court decided to allow a significant degree of concurrency between the sentences to reflect the multiple offences committed within a short period, while still imposing a sentence that would deter and denounce the offending behaviour.

Background

Background to the litigation

On the night of 20 May 2022 and into the early hours of 21 May 2022, Corey Girvan, along with two other males, engaged in a series of violent criminal activities in Canberra. At approximately 1:36am, the group trespassed into a house on Galbraith Close in Banks and stole keys to a white Ford Ranger utility belonging to KG. They then stole the vehicle and were later seen removing items from the car and leaving them in a nearby car park. Shortly after, Girvan used KG's stolen credit card to purchase cigarettes at a BP 2go service station in Phillip.

At around 3:15am, Girvan and the other males attempted to carjack a taxi driver, IT, who was asleep in his vehicle in the Phillip District Playing Field car park. Girvan threatened IT with a knife and attempted to smash the taxi window before being thwarted when IT drove off. Girvan then pursued IT's taxi at high speeds until IT reached the Woden police station. Shortly after, Girvan and the group attempted to carjack another driver, EN, threatening him with a machete before engaging in a prolonged high-speed chase until EN reached the Woden police station.

At approximately 4:30am, Girvan and the group carjacked a taxi driver, BN, using an axe to shatter the vehicle window and steal the keys. They then drove off in the taxi. Shortly after, Girvan and the group assaulted a man, UC, who was making a phone call outside his residence. Girvan punched UC several times and stole his mobile phone. New South Wales police later located the stolen white Ford in Wagga Wagga.

The offending was driven by Girvan's need to fund his drug habit. Girvan had a history of drug use, primarily methamphetamine, and had turned to criminal activities to support his addiction. The spree of crimes was marked by violence and a willingness to damage property in order to steal vehicles.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Girvan came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory for sentencing after the offender, Corey Girvan, pleaded guilty to a series of serious criminal offences. Girvan's offending spanned the early hours of 21 May 2022 and involved multiple victims, the use of dangerous weapons, and a clear intent to fund his drug habit. Initially, Girvan was charged in the Magistrates Court with three offences, to which he pleaded guilty, resulting in a 25% discount on his sentence. These charges were subsequently transferred to the Supreme Court along with additional charges. In the Supreme Court, Girvan pleaded guilty to the remaining four charges, attracting a 20% discount on his sentence. The cumulative effect of these pleas resulted in significant reductions to the potential penalties for each offence. The court considered various pre-sentence reports, victim impact statements, and submissions from both the prosecution and the defence before delivering its sentencing decision. The primary focus of the court's deliberations was on the gravity of the offending, the subjective circumstances of the offender, and the prospects for rehabilitation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate sentence for the defendant's crimes, considering the objective seriousness, subjective circumstances, and the need for deterrence, denunciation, and rehabilitation?
2. How should the court approach sentencing a young offender with a drug-related explanation for their criminal conduct?
3. To what extent should the court consider the defendant's pleas of guilty in determining the appropriate sentence?
4. How should the court balance the need for punishment and deterrence with the potential for rehabilitation in this case?
5. What is the appropriate level of concurrency between the sentences for the multiple offences committed within a short period?
6. Is the defendant eligible for entry into the Drug and Alcohol Sentencing List, and if not, how should this factor be considered in sentencing?
7. How should the court consider the impact of the defendant's youth and lack of prior custodial sentences on the appropriate sentence?
8. What is the appropriate fine for the transfer charge of driving without a seatbelt?

Held
1. The court concluded that the appropriate sentence for the defendant's crimes, considering the objective seriousness, subjective circumstances, and the need for deterrence, denunciation, and rehabilitation, is an aggregate sentence of five years and three months with a non-parole period of 33 months.
2. The court held that when sentencing a young offender with a drug-related explanation for their criminal conduct, the subjective circumstances must be considered, including the offender's age, lack of prior criminal history, potential for rehabilitation, and support from family.
3. The court held that the defendant's pleas of guilty should be considered in determining the appropriate sentence, resulting in a discount of approximately 20-25% on the sentences for each offence.
4. The court held that in balancing the need for punishment and deterrence with the potential for rehabilitation in this case, a relatively modest non-parole period should be set, along with a substantial period of supervision in the community, to motivate the offender to avoid relapse into drug use in the future.
5. The court held that there should be a significant degree of concurrency between the sentences for the multiple offences committed within a short period, but not so great as to be seen to give a bulk discount for multiple offences.
6. The court held that the defendant is not eligible for entry into the Drug and Alcohol Sentencing List, but this factor should still be considered in sentencing due to the drug-related nature of the offending.
7. The court held that the defendant's youth and lack of prior custodial sentences should be taken into account when determining the appropriate sentence, resulting in more modest individual terms of imprisonment than would otherwise be warranted.
8. The court held that the appropriate fine for the transfer charge of driving without a seatbelt is $200 with no time to pay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced its sentencing analysis by examining the objective seriousness of the crimes committed by the defendant. Each offence was considered individually and collectively, taking into account the violence, randomness of the victims, and the overall impact on the community. The court noted that the crimes, while varied in their specific nature, collectively represented a serious crime spree driven by the need to fund a drug habit. The court found the objective seriousness to be high, justifying significant custodial sentences. This assessment aligns with the principle that the severity of the sentence should reflect the gravity of the crimes committed.

In sentencing a young offender with a drug-related explanation for their criminal conduct, the court balanced the objective seriousness of the crimes with the subjective circumstances of the defendant. The court recognised the defendant's young age at the time of the offending, his limited criminal history, and his drug dependency as factors that could potentially support a more lenient sentence. However, the court emphasised that drug dependency, while an explanation, does not excuse criminal behaviour. The court's approach reflects the principle that while youth and circumstances should be considered, they do not negate the need for punishment and deterrence.

The court gave significant weight to the defendant's pleas of guilty, applying a discount to the sentences for each offence. The court noted that entering a plea of guilty demonstrates a level of remorse and acceptance of responsibility, which can be a mitigating factor in sentencing. This application of the plea discount is consistent with the legal principle that early pleas of guilty should be rewarded with a reduction in the sentence.

In determining the appropriate level of punishment and deterrence, the court had to balance this with the potential for rehabilitation. Given the defendant's age and lack of prior custodial sentences, the court opted for a sentence that, while severe enough to deter future offending, also provided an opportunity for rehabilitation. The court's decision to set a relatively modest non-parole period, with a significant period of supervision post-release, reflects the principle that rehabilitation should be a key consideration in sentencing, particularly for younger offenders.

Regarding the level of concurrency between the sentences for multiple offences committed within a short period, the court allowed a significant degree of concurrency to avoid disproportionately punishing the defendant for committing multiple offences. This decision was made to ensure that the total sentence was just and appropriate, considering the circumstances of the defendant and the nature of the offending. The court's approach in allowing concurrency while still imposing substantial custodial sentences demonstrates a balanced application of the principles of deterrence, denunciation, and rehabilitation.

The court considered the defendant's eligibility for entry into the Drug and Alcohol Sentencing List but found that he was not eligible given the sentences that would be imposed. However, the court did not let this factor dominate the sentencing decision, instead focusing on the overall need for punishment, deterrence, and the potential for rehabilitation. This decision reflects the court's discretion in applying sentencing principles in a way that considers all relevant factors, including those that do not directly lead to a specific sentencing option.

In considering the defendant's youth and lack of prior custodial sentences, the court applied a more lenient approach to the length of the individual terms of imprisonment. The court recognised that these factors could indicate a greater potential for rehabilitation and a lesser degree of entrenched criminal behaviour. This application of sentencing principles aligns with the legal understanding that younger offenders with fewer prior convictions may be afforded more leniency, provided the crimes committed are serious enough to warrant substantial punishment.

Lastly, regarding the appropriate fine for the transfer charge of driving without a seatbelt, the court imposed a modest fine with no time to pay. This decision reflects the relatively minor nature of the offence in comparison to the other charges and the court's consideration of the defendant's financial situation, as no specific time to pay was set. The court's decision in this regard demonstrates a balanced application of the sentencing principles, taking into account the specific circumstances of the lesser offence within the broader context of the defendant's criminal conduct.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in sentencing a young offender with a significant drug-related explanation for their criminal conduct, the court must balance the objective seriousness of the crimes with the subjective circumstances of the offender, including their age, criminal history, and potential for rehabilitation. The court must also consider the plea of guilty, the need for deterrence and punishment, the potential for rehabilitation, and the overall impact of the offending on the community. The court's discretion in applying these principles allows for a sentence that is just and appropriate, considering all relevant factors.