Arici v The Queen
[2019] VSCA 228
Citation 1
…isfied beyond reasonable doubt that your role was significantly greater than that of a courier. 20I note that unlike in the case of Arici v The Queen [2019] VSCA 228, there was in this case no prosecution concession that the evidence could not exclude the fact that Arici was not the primary organiser or distributo…
DPP v Condo
[2019] VSCA 181
Citation 2
…encing. This uplift sentencing practice is not a controlling factor in this sentence but remains a factor to take into account and I do so (See Condo [2019] VSCA 181.) 25Sentences therefore, for offending across the full range of seriousness have been increasing. The increase in sentences for the upper category ha…
Gregory (a pseudonym) v The Queen
[2017] VSCA 151
Citation 3
…ther relative measure the quantity is significant. 13I have taken into account in setting the sentence the line of authority from Gregory v The Queen [2017] VSCA 151, in which the court discussed the spread of sentences expected across the statistical range and the expectation of a certain level of sentence where…
Nguyen v The Queen
[2016] VSCA 198
Citation 4
…elegate this offending below the upper category to a mid-range category. 24Even in this category the court in Gregory at paragraph 101, and in Nguyen (2016) 311 FLR 289 decided the standard set did not only adequately reflect the objective seriousness of the offending or the offender's moral culpability but that it r…
DPP v Bchinnati
[2018] VCC 372
Citation 5
…r good qualities and of their support. 40I was referred by the defence to two sentences: one, mine, of 2016 in Bowden [2016] VCC 708 and of Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372, both of this court. 41In Bowden the quantity was 18.5 kilograms and four associates, included the accused bought butanediol in bulk. In that case th…
DPP v Bowden
[2016] VCC 708
Citation 6
…did Gayed. They all speak of your good qualities and of their support. 40I was referred by the defence to two sentences: one, mine, of 2016 in Bowden [2016] VCC 708 and of Bchinnati [2018] VCC 372, both of this court. 41In Bowden the quantity was 18.5 kilograms and four associates, included the accused bought but…