Director of Public Prosecutions v Fellows

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No.14 of 2002

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

v.

GRAHAM RAYMOND FELLOWS

---

JUDGES:

PHILLIPS, C.J., PHILLIPS, J.A. and O’BRYAN, A.J.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

18 April 2002

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

2 May 2002

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2002] VSCA 58

---

CRIMINAL LAW:  Rape - Appeal by Director of Public Prosecutions for Victoria – Allegation of manifestly inadequate sentence - Offender sentenced to a totally suspended term of imprisonment – Appeal allowed – Sentence varied to include an actual custodial component.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Crown 

Mr. P.A. Coghlan Q.C., D.P.P.
with Ms K.E. Judd

Ms K. Robertson, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions
For the Respondent 

Mr. P.F. Tehan Q.C.
with Ms S. Cure

Barretts

PHILLIPS, C.J.:

  1. The respondent, who is 35 years of age, pleaded guilty in the County Court to a presentment containing one count of rape of a female.  The rape, which was committed on 20 May 2001, and which carried a maximum penalty of 25 years’ imprisonment, was constituted by his introducing his finger into her anus. 

  1. The applicant admitted two prior convictions from two court appearances in 1986.  One of these was for the offence of culpable driving for which he was sentenced to periodic attendance at an Attendance Centre.  The other conviction was for theft.  After hearing a plea for leniency, the learned judge on 13 December 2001, sentenced the applicant to be imprisoned for three years and directed that sentence be wholly suspended for an operational period of three years.

  1. Subsequently, the Director of Public Prosecutions appealed against this sentence on the ground that it was manifestly inadequate.  The following particulars were pleaded: 

“(a)Failed to adequately reflect the gravity of the offence generally and in this case in particular.

(b)Failed to take into account or sufficiently to take into account the aspect of general deterrence.

(c)Failed to take into account or sufficiently to take into account the aspect of specific deterrence.

(d)Gave too much weight to factors going to mitigation.

(e)Erred in regarding the respondent’s intoxication as a mitigating factor;  and

(f)Erred in finding that the respondent’s personal circumstances justified the total suspension of the term imposed.”

  1. It is now necessary to set out in summary form the facts of this matter. 

  1. The victim was a married woman related to the respondent and about ten years younger than he.  During the evening before the rape the respondent had consumed a considerable quantity of beer in the backyard of the victim’s home.  He entered her bedroom in the early hours of 20 May 2001.  She was in bed wearing the clothes she had been wearing during the day, save for her bra which she removed - underwear and long pants, shirt and cotton cardigan.  She was almost asleep. 

  1. The victim awoke and asked the respondent, who had entered the room, what he was doing.  He was fully clothed.  He moved close to her and said, “I want you, I’ve always wanted you, just say it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Fellows and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] VSCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Director of Public Prosecutions for Victoria appealed against the sentence imposed on a defendant convicted of rape. The defendant was sentenced to a totally suspended term of imprisonment, which the Director of Public Prosecutions argued was manifestly inadequate. The case was heard in the Court of Appeal, where the legal issues focused on the appropriateness of the sentence in relation to the gravity of the crime.

The court examined the nature and circumstances of the offence, considering the defendant's criminal history and the impact of the crime on the victim. It was noted that the crime of rape carries significant societal implications, and the sentence imposed needed to reflect its seriousness. The court also considered the principles of deterrence and denunciation, which are central to sentencing in cases of sexual violence. The appeal hinged on whether the original sentence was insufficient to achieve these purposes.

In its decision, the Court of Appeal found that the sentence was indeed manifestly inadequate. The court emphasised the need for sentences in sexual assault cases to reflect the gravity of such offences, which often have profound and long-lasting effects on victims. The court varied the sentence to include an actual custodial component, thereby addressing the appeal's concerns. The final orders included a sentence that was deemed more appropriate in light of the crime's seriousness and the need to uphold public confidence in the justice system.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, the Director of Public Prosecutions for Victoria, lodged an appeal against the sentence imposed on the respondent, a convicted rapist. The respondent had been found guilty of two counts of rape and two counts of aggravated sexual penetration against a victim who was a minor. The trial judge sentenced the respondent to a totally suspended term of imprisonment of 14 months on each count, with the terms to run concurrently. The sentence was subject to a number of conditions, including a 12-month supervision order and a requirement to participate in a rehabilitation program. The appeal was based on the ground that the sentence was manifestly inadequate, and the appellant submitted that a custodial sentence was necessary to achieve the purposes of denunciation, retribution, and general deterrence.

This appeal was brought before the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The respondent was originally convicted in the County Court of Victoria. The appeal was heard by a three-judge bench in the Court of Appeal. Prior to the appeal, the respondent had made a submission to the County Court, urging the court to impose a suspended sentence. The County Court accepted the submission and imposed the sentence that is now the subject of the appeal. The appeal was lodged within the permitted time and the leave to appeal was granted by the Court of Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the County Court was manifestly inadequate.
2. If so, what appropriate sentence should the Court of Appeal impose in its place.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal concluded that the sentence imposed by the County Court was manifestly inadequate.
2. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and varied the sentence to include an actual custodial component.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal, in considering the appeal brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions for Victoria, carefully examined the circumstances surrounding the crime and the sentence imposed by the County Court. The appeal centered on whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate and, if so, what an appropriate alternative sentence might be. The County Court had sentenced the offender to a totally suspended term of imprisonment, which the Director argued was not commensurate with the gravity of the offence of rape.

The Court of Appeal noted that the crime of rape is inherently serious and often requires a custodial sentence to adequately reflect the community's condemnation of the offence and to provide general and specific deterrence. In reviewing the County Court's sentence, the Court of Appeal applied the principle that a manifestly inadequate sentence is one that is so lenient that it shocks the conscience of the court and is unjust having regard to the seriousness of the offence. The Court considered the nature of the offence, the impact on the victim, and the need for general deterrence.

In reaching its decision, the Court of Appeal relied on previous decisions that have emphasized the importance of appropriate sentencing for serious crimes, particularly those involving sexual violence. The Court noted that while the County Court had exercised its discretion in imposing a suspended sentence, this discretion must be exercised with a view to achieving just outcomes in individual cases and maintaining public confidence in the criminal justice system.

The Court of Appeal concluded that the totally suspended sentence was manifestly inadequate and varied it to include a custodial component. The binding legal principle established in this decision is that in cases of serious offences such as rape, a sentence must be proportionate to the gravity of the crime, and an appellate court has the power to intervene if it finds the original sentence manifestly inadequate. The Court of Appeal's decision underscored the necessity for sentences to reflect the severity of the offence and to serve the dual purposes of punishment and deterrence.