SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Dowling |
Citation: | [2023] ACTSC 49 |
Hearing Date(s): | 16 March 2023 |
DecisionDate: | 17 March 2023 |
Before: | Norrish AJ |
Decision: | See [89] |
Catchwords: . | CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – Aggravated Robbery – Ride Motor Vehicle without Consent – Cooperation – Plea of Guilty – Drug Addiction – Manipulation by Co-Offender – Offender “at the crossroads” – Good prospects of Rehabilitation – Good Behaviour Order |
Legislation Cited: | Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 7, 12, 13, 35, 36, 37, 57 |
Cases Cited: | Hall v The Queen [2017] ACTCA 16 |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown) Taylee Elizabeth Dowling ( Offender) |
Representation: | Counsel S Janackovic ( Crown) S McLaughlin ( Offender) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown) Legal Aid ACT ( Offender) | |
File Number(s): | SCC 321 of 2022 |
Norrish AJ
Introduction
Taylee Elizabeth Dowling, the offender, on 6 December 2022 pleaded guilty in the ACT Magistrates Court to a charge of aggravated robbery committed in Canberra, ACT on 5 August 2022. There is, in respect of this principal offence, a related offence to be taken into account of riding in a motor vehicle without the owner's consent committed on the same date in the ACT.
The offence of aggravated robbery carries a maximum penalty of 25 years imprisonment and/or a fine of $400,000. That maximum penalty serves as a yardstick against which to assess the objective seriousness of the offending, inviting comparison between the worst possible case and the case presented to the Court.
This is in the context of the consideration of other relevant matters, including subjective circumstances of the offender and other mitigating features. The related or additional offence that I am concerned with carries a maximum of five years imprisonment if dealt with discretely and/or a fine of $80,000.
Although the matter was mentioned a number of times in the Magistrates Court, ultimately, having regard to the relatively short time between the arrest of the offender and the entering of the plea of guilty, the offender being arrested approximately a week after the commission of the offence, the plea should be regarded…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Dowling and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] ACTSC 49
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the offender's personal circumstances, including her positive upbringing, qualifications, employment history, drug dependency, and mental health issues. The offender had shown genuine remorse, severed ties with her co-offender, and sought employment and rehabilitation opportunities. The court acknowledged the offender's cooperation with law enforcement authorities and her willingness to give evidence against her co-offender.
In determining the sentence, the court considered the purposes of sentencing, the objective seriousness of the offending, and the relevant statutory considerations. The court also reviewed comparative cases to ensure consistency in sentencing for similar offences. The court found that the offender was at a crossroads and had good prospects of rehabilitation.
The court imposed a sentence of one year and nine months imprisonment, to be suspended after six months, with the requirement for the offender to enter into a Good Behaviour Bond. The bond included conditions such as supervision by corrective services, mental health counselling, undertaking programs to address offending behaviour, seeking employment, performing community service, and abiding by protection orders. The court did not impose a reparation order due to the offender's lack of financial resources.
The final orders included a conviction for the principal offence of aggravated robbery, a suspended sentence of one year and nine months imprisonment, and the imposition of a Good Behaviour Order with specific conditions to be met by the offender.
Background
Background to the litigation
The circumstances surrounding the offence revealed that Dowling's then-boyfriend, Michael Manning, drove her to the scene of the robbery, provided her with the knife, and instructed her to commit the crime. Manning, who had not been charged due to insufficient evidence, had a more extensive criminal history and a significant drug addiction problem. Dowling's relationship with Manning subjected her to physical and emotional abuse, which pressured her into committing the offence. Although Dowling's account of being coerced did not amount to a legal defence of duress, it did explain her presentation during the offence.
The victim, who was unknown to Dowling and Manning, parked her vehicle in the vicinity of the University of Canberra on 5 August 2022. Dowling approached the victim from behind, holding a knife near her chest, and demanded the car keys and mobile phone. The victim was frightened by the presence of the knife and the threat she perceived from the Mazda vehicle nearby. Dowling then entered the Kia and drove off, followed by the Mazda. The victim reported the incident to the police, and Manning was arrested the next morning in possession of the stolen Mazda.
Dowling's pre-sentence report revealed a history of drug use, mental health issues, and a relationship with Manning that negatively impacted her life. Dowling had qualifications in horticulture, aged care, and individual support but had been on Job Seeker benefits for the past five years. Dowling expressed genuine remorse for her conduct and identified the loss of property suffered by the victim. She also noted the positive support from her family and her efforts to address her drug dependency and seek employment.
This case, Director of Public Prosecutions v Dowling, came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as an appeal against sentence. Taylee Elizabeth Dowling had pleaded guilty in the ACT Magistrates Court to charges of aggravated robbery and riding a motor vehicle without the owner's consent. Having regard to the relatively short time between the arrest of the offender and the entering of the plea of guilty, the plea should be regarded as having been entered at the earliest opportunity. The offender was sentenced in the Magistrates Court to two years imprisonment, wholly suspended after 18 months with a good behaviour order for two years. The Crown appealed the sentence as manifestly inadequate. The appeal was heard by Norrish AJ in the Supreme Court, who imposed a sentence of one year and nine months imprisonment, wholly suspended after 12 months with a good behaviour order for two years. The offender also received a 25 per cent discount for her plea of guilty and a 5 per cent discount for her cooperation with law enforcement authorities.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the appropriate discount for the offender’s plea of guilty under s 35 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT)?
2. How should the court treat the offender’s cooperation with law enforcement authorities under ss 36 and 37 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT)?
3. What weight should be given to the circumstances of the victim and the effect of the offending on the victim under s 33 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT)?
4. How should the court assess the subjective circumstances of the offender, including her background, personal history, and prospects of rehabilitation?
5. What is the appropriate starting point for sentencing the offender for the offence of aggravated robbery, considering the objective seriousness of the offending?
6. How should the court treat the related offence of riding a motor vehicle without consent in relation to the sentencing for the principal offence of aggravated robbery?
7. What are the relevant considerations arising under s 33 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) that the court must take into account in sentencing the offender?
8. What is the appropriate sentence for the offender, taking into account the discounts for plea of guilty and cooperation, as well as the circumstances of the victim and the offender?
9. Should the court impose a term of imprisonment for the offender, and if so, what conditions should be attached to any suspended sentence under s 12 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT)?
10. What are the appropriate conditions for a Good Behaviour Order under s 13 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) in this case, considering the offender’s background, personal history, and prospects of rehabilitation?
Held
1. The court concluded that the offender is entitled to a 25% discount for her plea of guilty under s 35 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT).
2. The court acknowledged the offender’s cooperation with law enforcement authorities and granted a 5% discount under ss 36 and 37 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT).
3. The court considered the circumstances of the victim and the effect of the offending on the victim under s 33 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) and found that these factors operated in mitigation of the appropriate sentence.
4. The court assessed the subjective circumstances of the offender, including her background, personal history, and prospects of rehabilitation, and found that she had good prospects of rehabilitation.
5. The court determined the appropriate starting point for sentencing the offender for the offence of aggravated robbery, considering the objective seriousness of the offending, to be two years and six months imprisonment.
6. The court treated the related offence of riding a motor vehicle without consent in relation to the sentencing for the principal offence of aggravated robbery and found it to be a minor role in the overall offending.
7. The court took into account the relevant considerations arising under s 33 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), including the circumstances of the victim, the effect on the victim, and the offender's background and prospects of rehabilitation.
8. The court determined the appropriate sentence for the offender, taking into account the discounts for plea of guilty and cooperation, as well as the circumstances of the victim and the offender, to be one year and nine months imprisonment, to be suspended with a Good Behaviour Order.
9. The court decided to impose a term of imprisonment for the offender, with the sentence to be suspended under s 12 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) and the offender to enter into a Good Behaviour Bond with specified conditions.
10. The court set appropriate conditions for a Good Behaviour Order under s 13 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) in this case, considering the offender’s background, personal history, and prospects of rehabilitation, including supervision, mental health counselling, employment assistance, and community service.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Director of Public Prosecutions v Dowling considered various legal principles and authorities in determining the appropriate sentence for the offender, Taylee Elizabeth Dowling, on charges of aggravated robbery and riding a motor vehicle without consent. Firstly, the court assessed the discount for the offender’s plea of guilty under s 35 of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT). The court accepted the Crown’s concession that the offender was entitled to a “full discount” of 25%, considering the plea was entered at the earliest opportunity.
Secondly, the court evaluated the offender’s cooperation with law enforcement authorities under ss 36 and 37 of the Act. Despite the lack of timeliness and the absence of other material, the court acknowledged the offender’s willingness to cooperate, awarding a 5% discount for cooperation. The combined discount for the plea of guilty and cooperation amounted to 30%.
Thirdly, the court considered the circumstances of the victim and the effect of the offending on her, as required by s 33 of the Act. The victim had suffered significant emotional and financial distress due to the stolen property, which was never recovered. The court highlighted the importance of recognising the victim’s losses and the impact on her sense of safety.
Fourthly, the court assessed the subjective circumstances of the offender, including her background, personal history, and prospects of rehabilitation. The offender had a history of drug addiction influenced by her relationship with a co-offender, but she had taken steps towards rehabilitation and sobriety since her arrest. The court noted her remorse, the severance of her relationship with the co-offender, and her prospects of rehabilitation as mitigating factors.
Fifthly, the court determined the appropriate starting point for sentencing the offender for the offence of aggravated robbery, considering the objective seriousness of the offending. The court concluded that the starting point should be two years and six months imprisonment, acknowledging the offender’s lack of significant planning and the relatively minor role she played in the commission of the offence.
Sixthly, the court addressed the related offence of riding a motor vehicle without consent. The court found that this offence, though relevant, did not warrant a substantial alteration to the appropriate penalty for the principal offence due to its unusual features and the minor role of the offender.
Seventhly, the court considered the relevant considerations arising under s 33 of the Act, including the circumstances of the victim and the offender. The court recognised the influence of the co-offender, the lack of significant planning, and the offender’s remorse and prospects of rehabilitation as mitigating factors.
Eighthly, the court determined the appropriate sentence for the offender, taking into account the discounts for the plea of guilty and cooperation, as well as the circumstances of the victim and the offender. The court proposed a sentence of one year and nine months imprisonment, to be suspended with the requirement for the offender to enter into a Good Behaviour Order.
Ninthly, the court decided to impose a term of imprisonment for the offender, considering her eligibility for an Intensive Correction Order and the need for deterrence. The court suspended the term of imprisonment, requiring the offender to enter into a Good Behaviour Order with specific conditions.
Tenthly, the court set appropriate conditions for a Good Behaviour Order under s 13 of the Act, considering the offender’s background, personal history, and prospects of rehabilitation. The conditions included supervision, mental health counselling, engagement in appropriate programs, seeking employment, and performing community service work.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that in sentencing offenders for aggravated robbery and related offences, courts must consider various factors, including the offender’s plea of guilty, cooperation with law enforcement, the circumstances of the victim, the offender’s background and prospects of rehabilitation, and the objective seriousness of the offending. The court must balance these factors to achieve justice in individual cases, taking into account the purposes of sentencing and the need for deterrence.