Director of Public Prosecutions v Dennes

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No 926 of 2007

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

v

DARYLL JOHN DENNES

---

JUDGES:

DODDS-STREETON and WEINBERG JJA and WILLIAMS AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

2 March 2009

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

2 March 2009

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2009] VSCA 33

---

Criminal law – Sentence – Aggravated burglary, robbery, false imprisonment – Elderly couple tied up by respondent while he ransacked and burgled house –  Respondent sentenced to four years and four months’ imprisonment with two years and six months non-parole period – Whether individual sentences, total effective sentence, and non-parole period manifestly inadequate – Offending could not be described as sentencing judge had done as ‘mid to lower range’ example of aggravated burglary – Appeal allowed – Total sentence increased to five years and eight months with three years and eight months non-parole period

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Director Mr T Gyorffy Mr S Ward, Acting Solicitor for Public Prosecutions
For the Respondent Mr P F Tehan QC with
Mr L C Carter
Markotich Lawyers

DODDS-STREETON JA
WEINBERG JA
WILLIAMS AJA:

  1. This is an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions against various sentences imposed upon Daryll John Dennes for offences of aggravated burglary, robbery and false imprisonment.

  2. The respondent was sentenced to a term of three years' imprisonment on one count of aggravated burglary (count 1), one year on each of two counts of robbery (counts 2 and 3) and one year on each of two counts of false imprisonment (counts 4 and 5).  It was ordered that four months of the sentences imposed in respect of counts 2, 3, 4 and 5 be served cumulatively upon the sentence imposed in respect of count 1 and upon each other.  Accordingly, the respondent received a total effective sentence of four years and four months' imprisonment.  A non-parole period of two years and six months was fixed.  We were told that that period would expire on 4 April 2009. 

  3. The appellant contends that the individual sentences, the total effective sentence and the non-parole period are each manifestly inadequate. 

  4. The circumstances surrounding these offences, as found by the jury, were as follows.  At approximately 11.30 p.m. on 18 March 2006, the premises of Mauro and Carmella Montalto, part of a poultry farm complex in South Morang, were burgled.  The respondent was the offender.  He gained entry to the house by smashing a glass sliding door leading to the kitchen-dining area, after having forcibly opened a rear door to the sun porch.  On hearing the door being forced, the Montaltos, an elderly couple both in their eighties, left their bed and went into the kitchen.  There they observed the respondent outside the glass door.  After smashing his way in, the respondent, disguised with a balaclava, asked where the money was and if there was a key to the safe.  He tied each of the Montaltos to a chair, using cable ties for that purpose.  He then ransacked the house.  He took…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Dennes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] VSCA 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Dennes, the respondent was convicted of aggravated burglary, robbery, and false imprisonment, following an incident in which he entered the home of an elderly couple, tied them up, and ransacked their home. Dennes was sentenced to four years and four months imprisonment with a non-parole period of two years and six months. The Director of Public Prosecutions appealed the sentence, arguing that it was manifestly inadequate.

The appeal centred on whether the individual sentences, the total effective sentence, and the non-parole period were manifestly inadequate. The court considered whether the sentencing judge had correctly characterised the aggravated burglary as a 'mid to lower range' example. The respondent argued that his lack of remorse and his not guilty plea should not be considered aggravating factors.

The court found that the individual sentences for aggravated burglary and false imprisonment were inadequate. The court disagreed with the sentencing judge's characterisation of the aggravated burglary as a 'mid to lower range' example, finding it difficult to understand how the judge could have reasonably made such a characterisation. The court found that the offence was particularly grave and warranted severe punishment. The court increased the total sentence to five years and eight months with a non-parole period of three years and eight months.

The court's decision highlights the importance of appropriately characterising aggravated burglary offences and imposing sentences that reflect the gravity of the offence. The court found that the original sentence was manifestly inadequate and increased the sentence to reflect the seriousness of the respondent's criminal conduct.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent, Dennes, burgled the home of an elderly couple, the Montaltos, who were tied up during the offence. Dennes, disguised and armed with a knife, broke into the Montaltos' home and ransacked it while they were bound. He also stole a substantial amount of money. Dennes and an accomplice had planned the burglary, using cable ties and walkie-talkies. Dennes had been aware of the Montaltos' advanced age and vulnerability. The severity of the crime was compounded by the fact that Dennes had no previous criminal record. Dennes pleaded not guilty and showed no remorse during his trial. The trial judge sentenced Dennes to four years and four months’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of two years and six months for the charges of aggravated burglary, robbery, and false imprisonment.

The matter came before the court on appeal against the sentence imposed by the trial judge. Dennes was initially tried and sentenced in the lower court. The primary judge, his Honour, sentenced Dennes to four years and four months’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of two years and six months. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) appealed the sentence, arguing that it was manifestly inadequate. The appeal was heard by the higher court, which found that the original sentence did not appropriately reflect the gravity of the crime. The higher court allowed the appeal and increased the sentence to five years and eight months with a non-parole period of three years and eight months.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the respondent submitted that although he had pleaded not guilty, and given no indication of any remorse, these were not to be regarded as aggravating circumstances but merely meant that he could not call in aid a plea of guilty or remorse as mitigation. That last submission was, of course, plainly correct.Conclusion In our view, this appeal must be allowed. We consider that the individual sentences imposed on the counts of aggravated burglary and false imprisonment were manifestly inadequate. So, too, were the effective sentence and the non-parole period. We find it difficult to understand how his Honour could reasonably have characterised this particular aggravated burglary as falling within the ‘mid to lower range’. We reject the respondent's submission that this observation was intended to apply to the overall offending and not to the aggravated burglary standing alone. To read his Honour's sentencing remarks in that way involves a complete distortion of his carefully chosen language. That is so even when one has regard to the fact that during the course of the plea, his Honour said, in answer to a submission regarding the 'gentle' treatment accorded to the Montaltos by the offender, that this might 'possibly … lower the range'. In any event, irrespective of whether this passage reveals specific sentencing error, we are satisfied that this was a particularly grave offence warranting severe punishment. To smash one's way into the home of an elderly couple late at night, whilst disguised, intending to tie them up and rob them of a substantial amount of money, cannot, we think, properly be described as a ‘mid to lower range’ example of aggravated burglary, or the offending as a whole. This particular aggravated burglary was both premeditated and carefully planned. It was carried out in a fashion that involved more than one offender and the use of cable ties and walkie-talkies. The offence was significantly aggravated by the fact that the victims were both very elderly, and known to be so by the respondent. It was a grave affront to their dignity, as well as a significant threat to their well-being, to tie them up while their home was being ransacked before them. Any home invasion of this nature must warrant severe punishment. It is not to the point that there are cases in which greater violence has been used. If injury is caused in the commission of such an offence, that would normally warrant additional punishment. In our view, the term of three years' imprisonment that his Honour imposed for this particular offence falls far short of what the respondent's criminality merited. The same can be said of the twelve months imposed on each count of false imprisonment. To tie up two elderly and obviously vulnerable victims, while robbing them at night in their home, must be regarded as a most serious offence. It certainly warrants a considerably heavier sentence on each count than the twelve months' imprisonment that his Honour imposed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the gravity of the offence, which involved the respondent breaking into the home of an elderly couple late at night, while disguised, with the intent to tie them up and rob them. The Court emphasised that the victims were both very elderly and known to be so by the respondent, making the offence significantly aggravated. The use of cable ties and walkie-talkies, along with the involvement of more than one offender, further underscored the premeditated and planned nature of the crime. The Court was of the view that such an offence warranted severe punishment. The term of three years' imprisonment imposed for the aggravated burglary, and twelve months on each count of false imprisonment, fell far short of what the respondent's criminality merited. Consequently, the Court increased the total sentence to five years and eight months with a non-parole period of three years and eight months. The Court also rejected the submission that the trial judge's characterisation of the aggravated burglary as falling within the 'mid to lower range' was appropriate, finding it difficult to understand how the offence could be reasonably described in such a manner. The Court's decision highlights the importance of appropriate sentencing for serious offences involving vulnerable victims, and it sets a precedent for the treatment of similar cases in the future.